686 series- favorite dash?

Fide686

Member
Joined
Dec 4, 2016
Messages
186
Reaction score
325
Location
Near Canandaigua, NY
I am new here. I have a 686-1 4", a 686-3 6", and my 2 1/2" 686-4, that I had the trigger tuned for carry.
Curious as to opinions about the different "dashes."
Thanks.
 
Register to hide this ad
As many will point out, the -4 is often considered the pinnacle of the 686 line because it was the most refined before the demise of the hammer mounted firing pin and the introduction of internal lock system. It is also the model where seven shot cylinders were introduced.
 
As many will point out, the -4 is often considered the pinnacle of the 686 line because it was the most refined before the demise of the hammer mounted firing pin and the introduction of internal lock system. It is also the model where seven shot cylinders were introduced.
That and you had the new retention hole for the rear sight leaf, which means more aftermarket sights for customization.
 
Same 686's here....

Have the same 686's that you do except my 6" is a dash 5. The 4" -1 is by far the best handgun I've ever shot, including my "tuned" Colt Gold Cup. Had Nelson Ford go through it and also put a small diameter fiber optic front sight on it. PERFECTION. Just got the 2 1/2 -4 yesterday...anxious to shoot it and hoping it comes in second place to the -1. The 6" -5 has a Ultra Dot on it and does VERY well for a close range hunting handgun. Like others have said.....Love Em All.
 

Attachments

  • 31162012040_e9f66a43de_o.jpg
    31162012040_e9f66a43de_o.jpg
    96.8 KB · Views: 73
They're all good. I've got a dash 4 plus with a 6-inch barrel. Years ago, I traded in a four-inch 686-3 for a semi-auto, and have regretted that move ever since.

MANY TOUT THE 686-3 AS THE BEST ITERATION. I HAVE A NO DASH 2 1/2" AND A NO DASH 8 3/8", AS WELL AS A 4" 686+ MOUNTAIN GUN. I LOVE THEM ALL.......
 
I'll go with the -3 as most of them had square butts making them compatible with the nicer wood factory stocks no longer available on newer guns.

Ed
 
The nice thing about the newer Smiths, like the -5, -6, & -7, is that parts and service will be in production and available for them for the foreseeable future. Your great grand kids will the able to "mind meld" with S&W customer service and have a replacement part "teleported" to them instantly on their "replicator" for their -5.

The older Smith parts, not so much. Many of the key parts, the one ones most likely to break, are already out of production -- hammers, triggers, rear sights, etc. And will likely never be made again.

S&W refuses to work on older Smiths already, like pre WWII guns, due to no parts. How long before they refuse to work on pre MIM guns? Will the millennials of today leave their safe spaces and grow up to be the skilled revolver gunsmiths of the future? If not, who will keep the old -4 and below M686's running 50 years from now?
 
50 years! ha ha that's the next generations problem not mine.
 
My favorite dash is the -6 Performance Center, since it is the only one I own, plus I removed the wart.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0702.JPG
    IMG_0702.JPG
    130.5 KB · Views: 62
My -3, it's my only L-Frame. Between the balance and grips on it I'm thrilled with how good it shoots.

FullSizeRender%203_zpslvw6kazl.jpg


FullSizeRender%204_zpski8sskws.jpg
 
As many will point out, the -4 is often considered the pinnacle of the 686 line because it was the most refined before the demise of the hammer mounted firing pin and the introduction of internal lock system. It is also the model where seven shot cylinders were introduced.

And, it's factory drilled and tapped for a scope! Absolutely the pinnacle.
 
50 years! ha ha that's the next generations problem not mine.
I understand the mindset.

But how many times have we read a post with words to the effect, ".... treat it right and your grandkids will be shooting it!" I've seen it a hundred times. Empty words?

How many of us have a gun handed down from a grandfather? Or father? How many of us have Smiths that are already 50 years old? It's only 1965. Guns from that era are bought and sold everyday. They're not antiques. Many are just shooters.
 
I can't speak for the no dash or all the other dashes other than the -1. My -1 is "just fine" speaking in Deep Southern Lingo.
 
I have a -4, a -5, and a -6. I like them all, but my -4 snub-nose is my favorite.

686-4
5f2a1b99-cea5-4122-bf1d-b96f8402ebf0_zpsvezgfcce.jpg


Sent from my SCH-I545 using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
At present I own a 6" 586 no dash. That one has been a workhorse.
Also have a 686-2 4".
Both guns shoot great.
Jim
 
I'm stuck with a 686-3 6" and love it:) When I got it it had rubber grips, did a little work on a guys 586-1 that had original wood grips and he said he would trade me rubber for wood, well that made me happy and made my gun look better!

p1109920429-3.jpg


Karl
 
THAT'S A BEAUTIFUL 686-3, KARL. I CAN'T IMAGINE SOMEONE ACTUALLY WANTING TO SWAP THOSE BEAUTIFUL FACTORY STOCKS FOR A SET OF UGLY GOODYEARS. THERE IS NO ACCOUNTING FOR PERSONAL TASTE.......
 
My favorites are a 4" 686 no dash I had round butted in the 80s and the action polished.... and a 586-4 factory round butt (95/96)...... LOVE Round butts!!!!!!

Have a 681 I would love to round butt but the serial # won't cooperate !!!!
 
I understand the mindset.

But how many times have we read a post with words to the effect, ".... treat it right and your grandkids will be shooting it!" I've seen it a hundred times. Empty words?

How many of us have a gun handed down from a grandfather? Or father? How many of us have Smiths that are already 50 years old? It's only 1965. Guns from that era are bought and sold everyday. They're not antiques. Many are just shooters.
WHEN IT COMES TO FINE FIREARMS, WE ARE ONLY CUSTODIANS. WITH REASONABLE USE, AND TLC, THEY WILL LAST FOR GENERATIONS PAST OUR LIFETIMES.......
 
best is tough to choose...

hard to pick a favorite...
686-0 CS-1 2M 3 INCH
686-3 6 INCH
686-6 5 INCH HALF LUG DEALER SPECIAL

each one is great for different reasons...
but it is a close tie between the 3 inch and 5 inch...
 
Well .... my only 686 is a 4 inch -4. Probably the most comfortable S&W I own. And the difference on the dashes? Personal preference it seems to me!
 
Seems like a lot of 2 1/2 inchers are -4s, as mine is. Mine has the flash chromed hammer and trigger, while others are case hardened. Apparently, they were made both ways.

I think I like the flash chrome better.
 
Back
Top