Another Model 41 question

A

AveragEd

Member
Joined
Oct 8, 2010
Messages
3,494
Reaction score
2,882
Location
Enola, Pennsylvania
I purchased a new seven-inch Model 41 from the current production run on Thursday and shot it today. I may have overthought my choice of ammunition a bit.

I only fired 10 rounds each of two different brands of quality pistol match ammo because 16 of those empty cases failed to eject - they hung up in the ejection port along with the new round being chambered. I assumed that a target pistol would function best with ammunition intended for that type of firearm but the problem suggests that I either use match ammo intended for rifles like the Lapua Center-X that I use in my rimfire precision rifle or change the recoil spring to a slightly softer one.

I'm hoping the members of this Forum with Model 41 experience can offer some suggestions. I did clean and oil it prior to shooting it and do believe it needs breaking in because on the four occasions it did eject the empty the slide failed to completely return to battery - I had to nudge it about 1/8" forward.

Thanks for any thoughts.

Ed
 
Register to hide this ad
I only use standard velocity ammo in mine and even then, some brands just are not 100% reliable.
I would put a few hundred rounds thru it and see if it's maybe just a break in situation. I would also number the magazines to eliminate a bad mag. I've found CCI standard velocity to be the best for my gun. Good luck.
 
My Model 41 would do the same thing rather randomly. It would be fine for weeks and then act just as you described. I took my CCI standard velocity and dumped it into a small plastic container. Every 100 rounds I would spritz a little Ballistol on the ammo. The container holds 300 rounds. Gave the container a few shakes and good to go. I have not had one failure to feed or eject since doing this. As a bonus after loading up a few mags I use the Ballistol residue on my fingers to wipe down my mags. Now they drop free much quicker.
 
Eley Pistol Match

My 41 only acts up with match ammo, most notably Eley. It does give me an early warning by failing to go back into battery by 1/8 in. When this happens it's time to swab out the dirty burning, low pressure match ammo residue and all is well. They have tight chambers for blowback semi-automatics, a reasonable tradeoff for gilt edged accuracy vs. lifesaving reliability.
 
My M41 can be TOO clean. I oil the top round of the first few magazines after scrubbing the chamber. After that, it has enough bullet lube and soot to lubricate for easy extraction.

on the four occasions it did eject the empty the slide failed to completely return to battery - I had to nudge it about 1/8" forward.
Click to expand...

That might be the extractor rubbing in its slot in the barrel or camming up against the front of the cut.
 
I’m not sure how much evidence needs to pile up before it becomes generally known that new production S&W Model 41 pistols are not quality items and are priced about 2x what they’re worth.
 
A few bad apples don’t ruin the whole barrel. I read all the m41 posts on several forums for educational purposes. The unsatisfied, and rightly so S&W m41 customers make a lot of noise. Much more than those who have no major complaints. Same thing goes for other models. Problems as I see it are in both work force and management. They are losing the old guys that had pride in their work. Management is allowing substandard product out of house.
We are in the middle of a race to the bottom. It’s not just S&W. People are already crying about the quality of the new Colt revolvers vs price. Face it all the Trademarks are owned by big Corporations that have people at the top that see no difference in guns or toasters, only bottom line.
 
Similar to Jim Watson above, I lube my cartridges. Drop of oil on my fingers, roll the cartridges in it before loading mag. Gives me 100% reliability.

Because of reduced chamber adhesion by lubed cases, I use only low powered ammo, chiefly Federal Gold Medal Target 711B.
 
I use a lot of Lapua Center-X in my rimfire precision rifle so two of the pistol match ammos I have are Lapua OSP and Pistol Match; I tried the OSP as well as SK Pistol last weekend. Both brands carry the same cartridge head stamp and both have a oily coating (which leads me to believe both are loaded by the same company). Given that coating, I have to doubt that cases needing lubed is the problem. Very good thought, though.

I called S&W yesterday and the gentleman with whom I spoke told me they use CCI SV exclusively in their test-firing of all 22LR semiautos. I have several thousand rounds of that so I'll try a few hundred rounds of it this weekend.

I had the same thought as Dave.357 - maybe it needs a "wake-up call" with high-velocity fodder. Perhaps a hundred CCI MiniMags would do the trick...

Ed
 
I too have a new one and after two barrels that were bad I had it lined at Ten Ring Precision. now it shoots good but did not function, I changed the spring to a 7 lb. Wolff and it run well now. The other way to go is send it back to the shoemakers at S&W and they will keep it for 4-6months and more than likely it will come back with the same problem. A better choice is to send it to a reliable pistol smith that can fix it right the first time.... Jim
 
First off the M41 is one of the most finicky Target Grade Semi Auto pistols available - it just is. The current run of magazines are mostly garbage. As others have stated, the one round that seems to work best in the vast majority of M41's is the CCI Standard Velocity - that's been my own experience as well. I know some shooters have given up on standard velocity ammo and opted to use High Velocity as it seems to improve reliability - however some slight accuracy and longevity loss will of course occur.

Here are a few suggestion. Use the CCI std. vel. and see how they work. You can also play with different value recoil springs - they are available in many weights and sometimes that helps. The one thing I ALWAYS suggest is to replace the Extractor with a Volquartsen version. They are about $14 bucks or so and usually eliminate any ejection issues. It is a much better part than the Factory one.

As a LAST RESORT you can send it back to the Factory and cross your fingers.

I am one of the very lucky M41 owners as my M41 probably has not had a malfunction in 20 years (other than a bad round of course). In general, the older ones seem to behave better, but the newer ones seem to be either great or terrible - not much in between. The good news is that once you tweak it and figure it out, it is a very accurate pistol with a descent trigger - don't give up yet.

Last suggestion..... If you try everything and still have an unreliable or problematic M41, get rid of it and get yourself a used vintage High Standard 22 target pistol. There are a few different variations, but the vintage models seem almost bullet proof! They are very reliable, accurate, have a fantastic trigger and about the only two negatives are the magazine release being on the bottom of the butt and the slide release being on the "wrong" side of the gun for right handed shooters. Oh - and like the M41, if you get a vintage model you pretty much must buy vintage spare mag's. their new ones are no better than Smiths!

Good luck - I hope some of the suggestions help out!
 
I had a High Standard Supermatic Trophy with the five-inch heavy barrel. I bought it for $150 from a friend who shot maybe 50 rounds through it and figured he wouldn't be interested in bullseye competition back in 1974-ish. It shot great for me and I never bought any "good" ammo for it so it probably could have done better.

About 20 years later, I was watching an indoor bullseye shoot at my club and during a break, started talking with an older shooter. When I told him I had that gun, he offered me $450 for it sight unseen. That should have told me it was worth keeping but you already know the rest.

I know this Model 41 will come around. It might take some massaging from a good gunsmith but that's okay with me as I've always wanted one but couldn't bring myself to spend that much for "a 22." For now, I'll try different kinds of ammo as I have well over a dozen of various velocity ratings on hand from which to choose. It is a beautiful handgun and I'm on the hunt for some stocks in fancy walnut for it. Any suggestions?

I thank all of you for your input and encourage more.

Ed

Forgot to ask - what is the standard recoil spring tension? If breaking it in doesn't help, the person at S&W suggested an aftermarket recoil spring but I neglected to ask what weight he would recommend.
 
Last edited:
This is a rather timely thread; I took my new-to-me M41 to the range today for the first time since I bought it last week. Mine is a 1985 vintage. I grabbed a box of some Winchester Super-X .22LR, not sure how long I've had that ammo. I fired 60 rounds, and out of that I had three failures to feed, one of which was a mal-formed bullet. I had one stovepipe , and three times it failed to chamber a round after extracting and ejecting a fired round. The gun was clean, the ammo was clean. I do not know how much use the pistol had before I got it, but I got the box, tools and paperwork with it, and the pistol looks brand new.

When it functions well it is a tack driver, more accurate that I can shoot. The trigger is like a nice DA revolver fired single action. I'm hoping the more I shoot it, the better the function will get.

Something I found, while policing my brass; I picked up a couple of CCI cases someone else had shot, and when compared to my Super-X cases, the CCI are a couple of millimeters longer than the Winchester. Is that usual, or is my older ammo shorter than current .22 cases? Would the shorter cases have anything to do with function?
 

Attachments

  • IMG_1757.jpg
    IMG_1757.jpg
    259.3 KB · Views: 16
AveragEd My advice would be to try different types of .22 ammo until you find one that your 41 likes. Stay with in the 1070 fps to 1200 fps range. I have a 1963 41 that only likes Remington Target. Also don't change any parts until you sort out what ammo your 41 likes.

Hair Trigger The CCI cases you found are "Stingers" they are longer than a long rifle case.
 
Last edited:
Thanks Jim - I have a Wolff spring kit for the gun on order.

Stingers can be problematic in certain 22LR firearms. For example, Remington 541S rifles had shorter throats; I was unable to extract unfired rounds from mine without using a cleaning rod because the bullet would be slightly contacting the rifling and the extractors would slip off the case rim. Unfired standard-length rounds extracted easily.

Ed
 
Hard to figure out

I purchased a new 7” M41 in 2021. Runs fine. Used all kinds of ammo. Had some old Federal that had a few Fail to Fire. Fifteen years in the attic may have contributed.
I really think the preference for older guns runs in every gun. Some I feel are about the same, others the newer production benefits from CNC manufacture.
My gun gets complimented regularly. Usually see the lower cost guns where I shoot. Hearing good things about Taurus, Glock, and of course Roger and Buckmark
Usually shoot CCI SV in Target pistols. Like the Norma and all the cheap HV.
One tip,make a chamber brush. Use it regularly. 25 caliber brass with a 90 one inch from end. Helps scrub the tight chamber.
Also I never stick a cleaning rod down the barrel. I lol up a patch, soak in No 9, and push through with bamboo skewer.
 
Hair Trigger said:
Something I found, while policing my brass; I picked up a couple of CCI cases someone else had shot, and when compared to my Super-X cases, the CCI are a couple of millimeters longer than the Winchester. Is that usual, or is my older ammo shorter than current .22 cases? Would the shorter cases have anything to do with function?
Click to expand...

Those look like stinger cases; are they nickel plated? CCI Stingers, use a longer case (.700 vs .600) with a shorter lighter bullet so they have the same loaded overall length as .22 LR
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

pmhayden
Model 41 Spring Wt?
Replies
6
Views
981
reedybart
R
K
Model 41 not ejecting empty case
Replies
12
Views
1K
reedybart
R
R
Model 41 Ammo Suggestion
2
Replies
30
Views
2K
Troystat
T
Tom S.
On Buying a Pig in a Poke
Replies
2
Views
727
Yendor357
Y
P
Model 41 (1971) – Slide Doesn’t Lock Back – Follower Wear?
2
Replies
23
Views
976
PeKron
P

Latest posts

Back
Top