Anyone actually use a Randall Knife

Another Randall knife story I enjoyed. This is kind of paraphrased because its been a while since the guy told it to me.

Another friend of mine had wanted a Centennial Randall for a long time. His wife had been wanting to go shopping at a place an hour or so way. He located a knife and talked to the seller on the phone. He got driving directions. Then he told his wife he'd take her where she wanted to go, but he wanted to make a stop, too.

So off they went the next day. When he got to the sellers house, they went up and knocked. The guy invited them inside, sat them down at the kitchen table and offered them some coffee. They chatted for a short while and the guy went out and brought back the knife. Our guy looked it over and agreed it was what it should be. Then he asked if there was any room on the price. The seller said no. So he counted out $800 and handed it to the man. He heard his wife gasp. But he took his knife and they left.

When they got to the car, his wife started a multi year tirade about spending that kind of money on a stupid knife. He took his lumps like a big boy. He wanted that knife. He took the accompanying abuse from his missus. And she went on relentlessly for a few years.

Then one day there was a knock at the door. Our guy opened the door and invited the guest inside. In a repeat of his show a few years earlier, he took him to the kitchen, got him coffee and left for a few seconds. He returned with "the knife." The guy looked it over, tried to get an accommodation on the price, failed, and took out an envelope. He counted out $3200 and handed it over. Wife gasped in the background. The new owner left with a thanks. And our guy took the money (every red cent) and left the room. Since that second day, no one word has been said about his knife dealings. Go figure.
 
My first Randall is a Model 16. It was originally taken to Vietnam by a GI. When he left, he gave it to another GI because the knife had too many bad memories, and he never wanted to see the knife again. I got it from the second GI. I use that knife, but I always wonder what bad memories it has.

I have two Model 1s, a Model 2, a Confederate Bowie, and a Model 14. I have used the 14 only once; to cut a birthday cake. I got all these while Bo Randall was alive. After he died, I lost interest.
 
The grind is typical of early 14's starting with the tennite handles and the skull crusher tang.
Curtis, the tang and handles have nothing to do with the grind, grind refers to the blade. Keep in mind that you are looking at a Solingen and not a Randall blade. No Randall 14s have ever been ground like your knife. In fact, one of the reasons Randall stopped buying the German blades was because it took so much shop time trying to get them shaped like a Randall that it was not cost effective.

In any event, you have a great knife that has a lot of value. Certainly the sentimental value alone make it a keeper.

Bob
 
100_0334.jpg

I think I should clean mine. These are from around 1960+/- . Can you tell what model they are?
 
100_0334.jpg

I think I should clean mine. These are from around 1960+/- . Can you tell what model they are?

The Bowie is a Model 12 and would depend on blade length as to the specific version.

The other one appears to be a Model 3 or a Model 4 with a stag handle.
This is based on the current catalog and blades/models have changed some over the years.
 
I saw my first Randall in 1967 when I was 12. My older brother had just graduated from Ranger School and Infantry OCS and was headed to Vietnam. My dad bought it for him as a graduation present for making it through Ranger School. If I recall, it looked like the one Cooter posted a pic of. I remember how sharp it was, because I still have the scar on my left index finger... Anyways, two tours later Bob brought it home, but it sure wasn't the shiny new knife I remembered. I think he still has it, but don't know for sure.
 
I saw my first Randall in 1967 when I was 12. My older brother had just graduated from Ranger School and Infantry OCS and was headed to Vietnam. My dad bought it for him as a graduation present for making it through Ranger School. If I recall, it looked like the one Cooter posted a pic of. I remember how sharp it was, because I still have the scar on my left index finger... Anyways, two tours later Bob brought it home, but it sure wasn't the shiny new knife I remembered. I think he still has it, but don't know for sure.

I can only speak for myself, but I know I would love to see pics of it and hear a story or two. I am sure others feel the same.
 
I think I should clean mine. These are from around 1960+/- . Can you tell what model they are?
Looking at the knives tells me you know better than to "clean them up". The #12 Bowie was introduced in 1953 and the wide top stone pocket was replaced by the narrower top around that time. My guess is that even with slower moving models like the Bowies, the older style sheaths that were in the bin would have been used by the end of 1954. The heft of the lugged hilt seems a little on the light side for that era but is probably correct. The Model #3 shealth, pin, choil and spacer stock place it perhaps a few years later but not by much. This is based on what I can see and you need to keep in mind that there are things that I can't see in the pics that could change what I think of the date. Seeing the stones would also help as they changed during this time frame.

Valuable? Very, but I suspect you knew that also.:D Two very desirable knives.

Another friend of mine had wanted a Centennial Randall for a long time.
Dick, what's a Centenial Model? I don't think I've ever heard of that one.

Bob
 
100_0334.jpg

I think I should clean mine. These are from around 1960+/- . Can you tell what model they are?


Can't you at least clean the verdigris off of the brass guard on the Model 3? That looks atrocious!
 
It looks like there are some very knowledgable "Randall" people here on the S&W forum.

Can anyone tell me if Randall actually made some "All Stainless Steel"------- ( No Brass) Model 18 Survival Knives?

I have a friend who claims he has one, although I have never seen it
 
I use these three... to dress up a book case! They're all JRB's from the 70's. The only thing I've ever cut with them was myself, ergo the enclosed display! :o

I haven’t needed a combat knife and the hunting and fishing knives I use (Marble’s, Bark River, Western, Marttiini, Wyoming) are far less valuable and meet my needs.

attachment.php


attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • 000_2034.jpg
    000_2034.jpg
    70.3 KB · Views: 2,183
  • 000_1528a.jpg
    000_1528a.jpg
    133.7 KB · Views: 2,187
Last edited:
It looks like there are some very knowledgable "Randall" people here on the S&W forum.

Can anyone tell me if Randall actually made some "All Stainless Steel"------- ( No Brass) Model 18 Survival Knives?

I have a friend who claims he has one, although I have never seen it

I guess it is possible, but Randall does not currently list a stainless guard as an option. It could have been a special order request, or he is mistaking a nickle silver guard as stainless.
 
Can anyone tell me if Randall actually made some "All Stainless Steel"------- ( No Brass) Model 18 Survival Knives?
In the 1980's Randall did some real creative things with the Model 18. One was the all stainless and there were probably less than 100 made. They also made perhaps 100 #18 handled knives with several other blade grinds, everything from Bowies to fighting knives. As you can imagine they are all collectable and yours truly for one will try to buy every example I see(which isn't many:().

As to value of your friend's #18, a guy at a show here had one on his table not that long ago and he wanted $3,000 for it. That's high and is especially so in today's very soft market but they are worth good money. If your friend is interested in selling PM me. I would make an offer that could make this a really Merry Christmas for him.

Sorry, its the Anniversary, not Centennial. The latter is a gun!
Thanks Dick! I was racking my feeble brain and keep coming up blank...should have guessed the Anniversay knife.

Bob
 

Latest posts

Back
Top