I love my 686-1 (4 inch) and trust it with the protection of the lives of my family and those dear to me. That being said, there are times where bringing it with me is just not practical. While it is easy to conceal and carry for our long winters here on the North Coast of Lake Erie in Ohio, during Summer it is near impossible at times. I love to hike and kayak with my daughter and concealing my 686 in board shorts and a tank top just is not realistic.
I have thought of several possible options to fill this summer carry role, but admittedly have no experience with any of them. I prefer revolvers, but would consider an auto loader that has legendary reliability as well. I have tried the Taurus 586 (twice) first the air weight, then the carbon steel version which was 6 oz heavier. I found them both to be far too snappy to enjoy practicing with them. My philosophy is that If I do not want to practice with a gun I should not own that gun, thus I traded both back in. They were reliable and accurate for me, I just did not enjoy paying a blood price to shoot them.
Update: I have eliminated the options for this to be more open-ended. I am liking what I am hearing about the J Frame guns and Model 10. Still open to other suggestions and going to try and get my hands on some to test before buying.
I have thought of several possible options to fill this summer carry role, but admittedly have no experience with any of them. I prefer revolvers, but would consider an auto loader that has legendary reliability as well. I have tried the Taurus 586 (twice) first the air weight, then the carbon steel version which was 6 oz heavier. I found them both to be far too snappy to enjoy practicing with them. My philosophy is that If I do not want to practice with a gun I should not own that gun, thus I traded both back in. They were reliable and accurate for me, I just did not enjoy paying a blood price to shoot them.
Update: I have eliminated the options for this to be more open-ended. I am liking what I am hearing about the J Frame guns and Model 10. Still open to other suggestions and going to try and get my hands on some to test before buying.
Last edited: