Best sandwich?

Best Sandwich?

  • PB&J

    Votes: 8 4.6%
  • Club

    Votes: 9 5.1%
  • Bacon Cheeseburger

    Votes: 30 17.1%
  • Tuna salad

    Votes: 3 1.7%
  • Reuben

    Votes: 52 29.7%
  • PB&bacon

    Votes: 2 1.1%
  • Philly cheesesteak

    Votes: 24 13.7%
  • Leftover turkey

    Votes: 11 6.3%
  • Meatloaf

    Votes: 12 6.9%
  • Sub, Hoagie, Grinder

    Votes: 17 9.7%
  • Grilled cheese

    Votes: 6 3.4%
  • Folded pizza

    Votes: 1 0.6%

  • Total voters
    175
News to me. I'm going to file that away with chitlins, mountain oysters, tribe, and brains and never think about it again.

Please, eveyone, feel free to tell me how delicious all of the above are. ;)

The Commander of my Sons of the American Legion squadron brought around some mountain oysters one time. They were actually quite good.
 
The term "comfort food" conjures up many, many pleasant "mom's table" experiences that went far beyond just sustenance.

While the list is long, and like others here have said, grilled cheese and tomato soup occupy the coveted top spot.

I remember that my late mother made wonderful baked beans. After she died in 1991, her recipe was temporarily misplaced, but my brother found it and sent it to me. So for a family gathering I decided to try my hand making Mom's baked beans. When we were setting out the food, my dad decided to try a sample of the baked beans I made before everyone sat down. I was overjoyed when Pop announced that the baked beans I made were just like the ones my mother made.
 
I have been on a quest to find the perfect Reuben for a few years now. An automatic disqualification is awarded for anything that resembles a sliced corn beef 'loaf'. I actually prefer a pastrami reuben but those are even more difficult to come by. A small chain in our former town may have been close to perfection with pastrami, swiss, sauerkraut and 1000 island on black rye but they are long gone. Through our travels my list is topped by a hotel bar in Rapid City, SD, and a local dive bar in Peoria, IL. And the search continues...
 
Last edited:
The "best" depends on what mood I am in. I am not a fast food kind of guy, but two days ago I went to Culver's for only the second time after a friend helped me move a new big screen TV inside - I treated him to lunch. I have to say, for a fast food place Culver's was pretty darn good! It blows away McDonalds, BK, Wendy's, etc. and is a much more comfortable place to eat. Their Butter-burger with Swiss, Mushrooms, Onions and pickles was actually quite good! Fries were descent as well.

That said, Mrs. Chief38 still makes the best Burgers from her own recipe (actually my Mother gave it to her many years ago). She makes 'em thick too and I grill 'em up once a week. A nice thick slice of Cabot's Cheddar Cheese from Costco tops it off nicely!
 
Somebody may have mentioned this, but: braunschweiger (liverwurst) on buttered black rye with yellow poster paint mustard and sweet onion. There are dozens of ways to riff on this: whatever bread you have, pickle, cheese, Durkee's instead of mustard, but it tastes best if you keep it simple.

Caveat: finish off the liverwurst fairly quickly. If you let it grow mold you will feel a deep sense of loss.
 
The "best" depends on what mood I am in. I am not a fast food kind of guy, but two days ago I went to Culver's for only the second time after a friend helped me move a new big screen TV inside - I treated him to lunch. I have to say, for a fast food place Culver's was pretty darn good! It blows away McDonalds, BK, Wendy's, etc. and is a much more comfortable place to eat. Their Butter-burger with Swiss, Mushrooms, Onions and pickles was actually quite good! Fries were descent as well.

That said, Mrs. Chief38 still makes the best Burgers from her own recipe (actually my Mother gave it to her many years ago). She makes 'em thick too and I grill 'em up once a week. A nice thick slice of Cabot's Cheddar Cheese from Costco tops it off nicely!


I go to the local Culver's maybe once a year. You are correct, they are heads above the others. Their burgers appear to be real meat. :D.
 
The Philly is a Regional Sandwich.
Have had a 'Philly' but usually a Smart Yankee Boy pops up and says this ain't a real Philly.
They are much better in Philly.
They probably are!
The Hamburger - Cheeseburger is a National -International sandwich.
Let's go local , again.
Here in NM the Green Chile Cheeseburger is the Cats Meow.
New Mexico Green Chile Cheeseburger Trail | New Mexico True
We got the Green Chile Cheeseburger Trail.
But if you ain't been here it's unlikely that you ever had one!
Go West of Albuquerque on I40 to the Laguna Reservation. Go into a Gas Station Convenience Store where you can get the Laguna Burger.
The Regular one is 1/2 Pound of loaded Cheeseburger Goodness.
I usually get the Wimp, a mere 1/3 Pound.
 
Last edited:
The Philly is a Regional Sandwich.
Have had a 'Philly' but usually a Smart Yankee Boy pops up and says this ain't a real Philly.
They are much better in Philly.
They probably are!
The Hamburger - Cheeseburger is a National -International sandwich.
Let's go local , again.
Here in NM the Green Chile Cheeseburger is the Cats Meow.
New Mexico Green Chile Cheeseburger Trail | New Mexico True
We got the Green Chile Cheeseburger Trail.
But if you ain't been here it's unlikely that you ever had one!
Go West of Albuquerque on I40 to the Laguna Reservation. Go into a Gas Station Convenience Store where you can get the Laguna Burger.
The Regular one is 1/2 Pound of loaded Cheeseburger Goodness.
I usually get the Wimp, a mere 1/3 Pound.

I can accept the argument to a degree.
That degree being that the fauxphillies popping up on menus nationwide, though likely inferior to the real Philly from Philly, still manage to spank the faces of many sandwiches
 
Ruthie's Aunt Judy is a hamburger tartare fan. Raw hamburger, sliced onion, salt, pepper on bread. Her kitchen, her rules, she wins.

On the subject of raw hamburger I feel the need to edgumakate y'all on hamburger meat. I expect many of you already know but this for the one(s) that don't. I feel qualified to post this because for the past year of high school (class of 1962) I worked i the meat market of a large chain grocery store. to this day this is how things were done. (Pretty much)

My official job title (description) was clean-up boy. Every night I would clean all the knives, pans, and, the meat grinder, and the band saw. Then sweep all the old blood soaked sawdust out of the cooler and put down fresh. sweep and mop the market, turn out the market lights, clock out, and go home.

But after few months I got unofficially promoted to what amounted to assistant butcher. Cutting up/splitting chickens, pork loins, beef ribs, and most things using the band saw.

But most often and my favorite task was making hamburger meat. First I would cut up 25# block of frozen bull meat on the band saw. This made up about half of the meat. Then I wold pull all the steaks, roasts, stew meat, etc that had not sold and was turning dark from the meat case. next I would de-bone all this. This was the rest of the meat that went in to it.

Here's where it gets really interesting. To all that I mentioned above I would add all the fat that the butchers trimmed from all the steaks, roasts, briskets, etc.

Then I would add all the suet trimmed from the beef kidneys. There was a surprisingly large amount of this. :eek:

The butchers would sort out all these ingredients and fill tubs with the correct proportion for lean, fat, or more fat accordingly and label them accordingly and set them on a rack next to the meat grinder. I did all the grinding and filling Styrofoam trays for the ladies to wrap.

From the first tub of meat and fat I ground I made SURE my hamburger was the leanest available and cooked to well done.

Raw hamburger? Ughh! FUGGEDABOUDI. ;)
 
Ruthie's Aunt Judy is 82 years old and still with us.

Yep. I get it. A family friend from my early childhood smoked 2 packs a day since he was 17 years old. he lived until 3 weeks from his 101st birthday. I don't know if he ate raw hamburger. some people get away with "bad behavior and some don't.

Anyway I guess I know that the suet around beef kidneys is not harmful. To me its a psychological issue. and there is the risk of eating uncooked meat. I kind of take after my grand father. He always said that if meat had any other name than meat (ie, organ meats...liver, kidney, tongue, etc) he would have to give it a pass. Just couldn't get passed the psychological issue.
 
It's hard to beat a hot pastrami with deli mustard and slaw from 42nd St Deli in NYC. A half (new) dill pickle and Dr Brown's Cream Soda and a bag of chips to top it off.
Of course now that NYC has basically become a "No Go Zone", it's been a while since I've had that culinary delight.
 
On the subject of raw hamburger I feel the need to edgumakate y'all on hamburger meat. I expect many of you already know but this for the one(s) that don't. I feel qualified to post this because for the past year of high school (class of 1962) I worked i the meat market of a large chain grocery store. to this day this is how things were done. (Pretty much)

My official job title (description) was clean-up boy. Every night I would clean all the knives, pans, and, the meat grinder, and the band saw. Then sweep all the old blood soaked sawdust out of the cooler and put down fresh. sweep and mop the market, turn out the market lights, clock out, and go home.

But after few months I got unofficially promoted to what amounted to assistant butcher. Cutting up/splitting chickens, pork loins, beef ribs, and most things using the band saw.

But most often and my favorite task was making hamburger meat. First I would cut up 25# block of frozen bull meat on the band saw. This made up about half of the meat. Then I wold pull all the steaks, roasts, stew meat, etc that had not sold and was turning dark from the meat case. next I would de-bone all this. This was the rest of the meat that went in to it.

Here's where it gets really interesting. To all that I mentioned above I would add all the fat that the butchers trimmed from all the steaks, roasts, briskets, etc.

Then I would add all the suet trimmed from the beef kidneys. There was a surprisingly large amount of this. :eek:

The butchers would sort out all these ingredients and fill tubs with the correct proportion for lean, fat, or more fat accordingly and label them accordingly and set them on a rack next to the meat grinder. I did all the grinding and filling Styrofoam trays for the ladies to wrap.

From the first tub of meat and fat I ground I made SURE my hamburger was the leanest available and cooked to well done.

Raw hamburger? Ughh! FUGGEDABOUDI. ;)

Thanks for the info, but nothing in your post sounds unsanitary or off-putting.

In fact, it sounds rather appetizing!

John
 
Ruthie's Aunt Judy is 82 years old and still with us.

My hat is off to Aunt Judy (another raw hamburger fan)!

I'll be 70 in 3 months and have been eating raw meat since I was 14 years old.

I'm almost never sick (haven't had a cold or flu in years), I have no aches and pains or chronic illnesses.

I feel great (like I'm 17 years old), and do nearly all of my own work, inside or outside.

I think the fear of raw meat is mostly psychological for most folks.

John
 
Back
Top