"Borrowed" Guns?

Flattop5

Member
Joined
Sep 12, 2013
Messages
676
Reaction score
1,166
Location
Southern Arizona
My sister borrowed a S&W model 15 .38 Special revolver from me about a year ago. I haven't seen it since. I'll probably never see it again. :D

Has anyone else experienced such gun "borrowing"? I'll bet so. An aunt, an uncle, a friend, a wife, an ex-wife - who "borrowed" your gun?



-------
 
Register to hide this ad
My wife has "borrowed" several of my handguns, but I see them on a regular basis.

I have lent other things to family and friends that have never returned. In the case of a handgun, especially a S&W 15, I'd be demanding it back. Don't know your sister, but is it possible she has sold, hocked, or lost it?
 
I loaned my Model 17 to my sister about 30 years ago to shoot at rabbits in her garden. She gave it back OK but she had scratched my name onto the side plate because she was afraid it might get stolen. ARRRGHHHH! I love my sister very much. Really, I do. I really do love her. I love her more than I could ever say. I'm reminded how much I love her every time I look at my Model 17. (All true)
I also loaned my Model 63 to my son. He knows not to scratch my name onto it and to not let it get stolen. And anytime I want to use it he says I'm welcome to; he has it right there with him. (Only a bit exaggerated)
Scott
 
I loaned a relative a S&W Model 10 in a very nice holster. After he died, his widow returned the gun in a cheapo $5.00 holster. Someone had switched out my expensive holster for the cheapo, but I didn't have the heart to say anything to the widow.
 
My brother loaned me his 222 contender about 25 years ago
Every once in a while he asks about it
I told him I'm not giving it back
I said he could pick something else but I wasn't giving that one back
:D
I recently loaned one of my model 14's to a club member I shoot with often.
He will likely take better care of it that I would.
I am in no rush to get it back.
 
NEITHER A LENDER NOR A BORROWER BE.

There are good reasons these old sayings came about. Enjoy trying to remember who you loaned it to, then having to chase them to get it back, only to hear "I never borrowed that" or "it was like that when I borrowed it" ? :mad:
 
Yet another good reason for not loaning. CONDITION. Guns are expensive and often worth more than double what we paid.
 
My brother has a saying, "if you loan something to a family member consider it a gift."

He was talking about lending money to his daughter, but his saying has application to lending other things also.

I've lent my 20ga "barn shotgun" to my other brother and it came back in nicer condition than it went out in. It just depends on the person
 
Loaned a snub model 10 to a friend who had a scared wife, and whose neighborhood had become a "regular beat" for the thuggery generation.

Sure enough; home broken into and my 10 is long gone. His crack-head son is not above my suspicions as the leader of that clan but,.........
 
Borrow a gun from me------- now that is a small list . Two kids and one close friend. Let others shoot my things at a range now thats very common!

Due to NYs asinine regulations on handguns that is now impossible to loan out a handgun. If you ask to borrow any gun the answer will be no, except for the above people BUT I did once volunteer a gun to my brother in law.

I have a few BILs but this one I like and was very friendly with, and when he got accepted by the sheriff's department they of course gave him a pistol. It was such a hunk of junk that I went home got my 2 year old Ruger Security Six .357 and loaned it to him (that at the time was legal in my state as he was a LEO).

I figured he had a better chance with this gun that the beat up model 10 4'' he was issued. It fits the issued holster perfectly. He carried that gun for a few months and picked up a nice Model 19 and I then got my Ruger back. It was in as good as shape as when I presented it to him.

I'm no dummy and realized as he was a LEO bad things could have happened to that gun but I took my chances as I said he was a good decent fellow and I wanted the best for him.
 
I sold a rifle to my cousin who didn't have any cash at the moment. It was a 35 Whelen on a 98 Mauser with a walnut stock. I never got a penny from him. That was about 15 years ago.

Lesson learned: never again.
 
I loaned a snub model 19 to my father and mother who were scared and threatened by wierdos and thugs in their deteriorating neighborhood in a big city. After Mom died, Dad moved in with my sister and BiL a thousand miles away. Not long after his move, Dad & I had a long conversation about sister's financial future, my well off enough situation and we agreed it was OK for him to bequeath all his assets to my sister when he died.
After he passed, when I asked for my gun back, BiL said it was "his" because Dad left everything to "him". He is not named in the will. I still have the original box and purchase receipt. I could declare the gun stolen and get him in a bit of hot water, but I haven't the heart to do that to my sister. My mistake was not asking Dad to add a sentence in his will that the gun was to be returned to me.
OTOH, I loaned my first gun, a Marlin 39A, to a friend who moved, died, and 20 years later, once I found his son, got it back with no problem.
Too often though, borrowers and lenders tend to process information about interpersonal transactions in a self-serving way. "Neither a borrower nor lender be" is a wise adage if you want to avoid lost equity or a lost friend.
 
Last edited:
I have a beautiful little no-dash Model 36 (my only J-frame) that I loaned to my mom. I told her she can have it, but she said no, she wants to be able to honestly tell anyone that asks that she doesn't own a gun. But it stays in her kitchen, with spare ammo, and if I never get it back I'm okay with it.

Way back when I was in the Navy, I left a rifle with my best friend Pete. It was a Rossi copy of a Winchester Model 62, a nice little pump action .22 LR. I told him don't loan this to anyone! Well, I came home on leave, went over to his house, and said I'd like to go shoot it. He had to go get it, it was at his neighbors, and it was covered with rust!

That made me real picky about who I leave what with!
 
Last edited:
Loaned a snub model 19 to my father and mother who were scared and threatened by wierdos and thugs in their deteriorating neighborhood in one of the Kommie blue states. Mom died, Dad moved in with my sister and BiL a thousand miles away. Not long after his move, Dad & I had a long conversation about sister's financial future, my well off enough situation and we agreed it was OK for him to bequeath all his assets to my sister when he died.
After he passed, I asked for my gun back, BiL said it was "his" because Dad left everything to "him". I still have the original box and purchase receipt. I could declare the gun stolen and get him in a bit of hot water, but I haven't the heart to do that to my sister. My mistake was not asking Dad to add a sentence in his will that the gun was to be returned to me.
OTOH, I loaned my first gun, a Marlin 39A, to a friend who moved, died, and 20 years later got it back from his son.
Too often though, borrowers and lenders tend to process information about interpersonal transactions in a self-serving way. "Neither a borrower nor lender be" is a wise adage if you want to avoid lost equity or a lost friend.


bIL is a jerk. It was not your father's gun to bequeath. Sounds more like conversion than theft but I'm not a lawyer. If it was me I would pursue it in civil court. Nothing like litigation to make holiday parties interesting.
 
You might tell her you want it back and let her use some other gun you have.
I will loan a gun to someone if I can be right there with it while they use it. Otherwise nope- no way Jose. People for some reason think borrow means it will be a gift.
Sure I will let you borrow it when you let me borrow your car and it all will be in writing. You get your car back when I get my gun back. Like they say don't lend things to family or friends.
 
Me and a couple of real close friends have loaned guns back and forth over the years. I'd say the average "loan" would be about 10 years. enough time to really enjoy it. Also, it's not like we didn't get to shoot the loaned gun a time or two.
 
My answer to someone who wants to borrow one of my guns. Do you want to sleep with my woman too?

Not quite that bad, but close.

I have used the 'quite bad' response frequently when someone asks to drive my Harley.

I don't loan guns to anyone. No one in my family or circle of friends shares my passion for them.

Have given, but, not loaned.

Don't expect to change that thought either.

bdGreen

 
I have 2 old close buddies I would loan a gun to, but they have plenty of their own.
I have another old close friend, who introduced me to gun shows about 35 years ago. He asked me if I found a good model 10 for around $200 or less to pick it up for him. He doesn't go to shows anymore, and has a spotless 10-5 that his grandfather gave him, but he doesn't want to keep it loaded. Well, I knew the days of nice 10s for less than $200 were pretty much done. I found a sound one with plenty of blue wear, and bought it. When I visited him, I asked if he ever found a gun, and he said no. I gave him the gun, and told him I was loaning it to him, for as long as he wanted it. If he ever has to use it to defend his home or family, it's his. He and his wife were really appreciative. They have let me stay at their house for a weekend, a couple of times a year for the past 40 years. I think they earned it. Made me feel good, too.
 
A few years ago my son in law asked me about buying a handgun. I asked him how much he was planning to spend and he told me a couple hundred. I told him we don't buy couple hundred dollar hand guns and I loaned him my 40 cal. Shield. After a couple years without seeing the Shield again, I gave him the box and extra mag. Figured the package may as well stay together.
 
In our 1st year of marriage my little bride went withme to see what deer humting was all about. She told me I was to teacher safety, how to shoot and next year she was going. I had custom rifle in 6.5 swede o. A commercial mauser 98. It was light, death o. Deer and no recoil. Perfect gun for her. What does she pick when I open the safe?

My custom pre 64 win in 270. It wasone of the luckiezt guns ever. Take it and deer lined up. Worked well for her. 15 years of bucks and does. She complaimed about the seight and I bought her a Kimber 84 in 7mm 08. It has worked well. She bagged a real wall hanger the 1st year. I think great now I can use my custo pre 64. Then she told me the 64 is still hers no tradimg. Well I still use it. Its bagged lots more deer. When my son got back into der hunting he killed some deer witn it.

In the 70s a guy I knew bought lots of S W and all Win mod 94s in the commeratives. Nice guy. I ran into him montjs after deer season and he said did I lend you a 94? I said no I came ovef with my FIL and he borrowed a rem 700.he returned it rigjt after season. He said he lent some 94s amd now doesnt re, ember who to.some years later I asked if they came home. He said nope.

Excuse spellin airs. Pc is dead and usi g ipad, cheap ipad.
 
I "loaned" my sister a factory-refurbished .38 Victory (updated with a Model 10 barrel) when she showed me the gun her deceased husband left behind, a badly reconstructed S&W Aircrewman with intact frame and aluminum cylinder. Not only was the Aircrewman dangerously unsafe, the aftermarket junk barrel was improperly indexed. I gave her the Victory and took possession of the Aircrewman, which has since been rebarreled and restored to a correct and safe (as safe as it can be) condition. I'm happy to report that she has received professional firearm instruction and is quite competent with the Victory. I'm also happy to report that the Aircrewman is now part of my personal collection.

I have loaned a revolver, a .22 rifle, and a Garand to friends over the years. All came back with condition issues. I no longer loan firearms because I cannot control what happens to or with them. And, I don't want to be "that guy" if something goes awry.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Back
Top