Cigars

RonJ

US Veteran
Joined
Mar 31, 2006
Messages
3,939
Reaction score
2,574
Location
Missouri
I've given up cigarettes but I still light up a cigar occasionally, especially after dinner. I prefer smaller bodied cigars because I seldom want to spend more than a half hour smoking one.
I don't usually spend much money but I'm beginning to wonder about better quality smokes. Care to name some of your favorites?
Just as a matter of curiosity, what makes a pre Castro Cuban better than current ones?
 
Register to hide this ad
When I want to smoke a good cigar, I most likely reach for one of these: Arturo Fuente Hemingway Classic

In my experience, it's a nice, mild, smooth smoke. Not harsh at all.

Here's a little review: Arturo Fuente Hemingway Classic Matt’s Cigar Journal

There is a link within the above review that leads to further comments on the Hemingway line of cigars.

Barry D. Harsh
 
Last edited:
dont know where abouts you live ron. but ask around some of the nice restaurants that have a coctail bar in them there are quite a few that one day a week have a cigar roller come in and roll right in the bar that way you can choose tobacco and mildness and its a cheeper way to get a good handfull of quality cigars
larry
 
I too quit smoking cigarettes and went to cigars for a few years. Then I gave them up too. I get enough allergies without compounding them with smoking, but I sure did give it a try. I sure am not an expert, though.

I live in Mexico, so Cuban cigars were fairly easy to get. I still have a few boxes in the veggy bin of the fridge that friends who haven't figured it out "that since they haven't seen me smoking in about 5 years might mean that I don't smoke anymore" give me from time to time.

However, I used to like the Dominican Republic cigars, and the Mexican "Te Amo" brand -- which was alway real easy and cheap to get around here.

Back when I used to go to bullfights a lot -- another thing I've given up -- I'd always smoke a cigar, usually one of the Te-Amo Torpedos. Ah, those were the days.

The last time I smoked a cigar was at my wedding, about a year and a half ago. It was a VERY old Cuban I had laying around that the former U.S. Consul here in San Miguel had given me from his collection. Maybe it was pre-Castro. He told me once that "cigars can go bad. You can get a Pre-Fidel cigar that tastes like crap or has gone dry. But they are all the rage." I remember reading something along that line once in Cigar Afficianado as well, so I imagine the Colonel had his facts straight. Anyway, I smoked the cigar at my wedding SLOWLY, but it still gave me a headache. Still....I sometimes miss sitting back and having a nice smoke.

I still have, as I mentioned, quite a few probably pretty good cigars sitting in the veggy box in a zip-lock bag with a small slice of apple in it to keep them moist. Some purists will scream in agony at that, put others will say they've heard of doing that too.

When the comet comes, I imagine I'll stand up on the roof and light up and watch the show before extinction. And I want my stogies to be in smokable shape!

Sorry I can't be of more help.

Photo; Got my wedding photo took, then I went and smoked a good cigar. It was a Cuban Cohiba -- quite old and in a tin outter wrapper.
Miami.JPG


Photo; Should my yokel writing style give you the impression I really don't know nuthin' about cigars, I have this photo from the bachelor days of me and a Canadian friend up on the balconey BBQing hotdogs (that we would immediately slobber ketchup onto) and drinking beer and smoking stogies. I really gotta get a decent camera, all I have for photos around here are old scanned crap. So anyway, so there. I have smoked a few, I'm just no real expert on them. I suggest "Cigar Afficianado" if it's still in print. I mean, down here, we can't even get gun magazines, so I just don't know. However, many moons ago when I had some copies brought down by visiting friends, it was an informative read. Can't speak too much for these days, though.
CalBBQ.jpg
 
any of the dominican cigars will be fairly mild. the hondurans more so and the cubans best of all if you can get them. had to give smoking cigars after 35yrs and still miss it. to calmex: you aren't doing your cigars any favors by keeping them in the refrigerator. they will dry out due to the low humidity. the apple slice will detract from their natural flavor too. cigars go through at least 3 stages of maturation during time. these changes can take more than 20yrs. properly stored, cigars will be good for 30-50yrs. the stronger they were new, the longer they will hold the flavor of the tobacco. they do not get milder with age but they do get smoother and more refined, think old bourbon and scotch and cognac. cigars need to be stored in a controlled environment which is what a good humidor is. hope this is some help. for ronj, if you would like some help choosing cigars, send an email to my address in profile.
 
I used to love the Macanudo Diplomat with the Robust wrapper-wonderful short smoke.
Barry is also correct with the Hemingways-a smoother cigar you will not find.
Alas I have forsaken Tobacco in ANY form as I am hopelessly addicted to the wonderful weed. It has been over 4 years since I have smoked cigar or pipe and snorted or chewed. Rest assured however if I am ever diagnosed with a terminal disease, I WILL resume its' pleasures ;)
 
Nubs are pretty good and popular in my humidor. Also frequenting are AVO XO's, Joya de Nicaragua's and CAO criollo's.
 
Ceegars

I gave it up 5 1/2 yrs ago, long story:rolleyes:
I have all the ones I had in coolers for trade in the classifieds.:D
 
I have a taste for the flavored cigars as use for a "desert" smoke. Tatianna makes several different sizes and flavors if you are interested. Anything from chocolate, vanilla, honey, cherry, etc. I do enjoy the coronas in the Punch and Romeo Y Julieta as I find them a good smoke that doesn't last too long.

Tatiana Cigars | Famous Smoke Shop
 
My favorite cigar is a Fuente Robusto, if I cannot find Robustos then any Fuente will do. There are lots of other fine cigars out there but any cigar made by Arturo Fuente has always been a satisfying smoke in my experience. I also smoke a pipe and enjoy pipe tobaccos that are a cigar leaf blend.
 
Care to name some of your favorites?
Just as a matter of curiosity, what makes a pre Castro Cuban better than current ones?

I quit smoking cigars when the became trendy and the prices went through the roof, let me rephrase that, I quit buying them when my favorite 4-6 dollar cigars started costing 8-12 dollars. I liked Partagas, Macanudo, and H. Upman cigars with the maduro wrappers.

As for why pre-commie cigars are considered better?? This is what I have heard, so take it with a grain of salt. Before the commies took over the tobacco crops were rotated with pepper crops which gave the tobacco pepper overtones. Since there is no money in communism but tons of cash in tobacco they quit the pepper rotation to produce more tobacco and the pepper nuances that used to be in the tobacco were lost.
 
JR Alternative Edition Limitada, any size, are good inexpensive cigars imho.

Tatuaje Reserva J21, Winston Churchill No. 10 (Davidoff), Frank Llaneza 1961 Magnum, Oliva Cain, are pricier cigars I've enjoyed recently. :)
 
I made a personal decision to stop smoking about 7½ years ago. (I didn't quit smoking because I am not a quitter!) and Nat Sherman finally stopped sending me catalogs. Good smoke shops are becoming harder to find these days, but Nat seems to be doing OK.

My favorite cigar quote came from Kinky Friedman - the man who should be governor of Texas! He tells the story of the time he was at some sort of gathering with Bill Clinton and he handed him a Cuban cigar. Clinton was astonished that Kinky had the cojones to offer him a Cuban and asked why he was supporting the Cuban economy when he knew they were illegal. Kinky replies, "I am not supporting their economy. I prefer to think of it as burning their crops!"

Scott
 
I am a cigar devotee but don't smoke as many...as often...now that smoking is banned state-wide in all but a few establishments.

Usually fire up a few whilst on the golf course...like yesterday...and tailgating as I shall be doing in just an hour or so.

There is a very nice...and I do mean very nice cigar bar in my town. Don't go there often as the staff is simply horrible but when I do I retreat to the lounge, plop my butt in an easy chair, and stare out the window whilst enjoying a stogie and a beer or two.

FTR, my cigar of choice is a Dunhill Peravia...simply a lovely smoke. On the golf course I usually fire up something cheaper as I am prone to leaving them on the back of the cart and then driving off forgetting them. Dumb!

Be safe.
 
And you'll need no other...

Leon Jimenes Cigars

It's hard to get this brand here in Switzerland. But if is see
some of the No.1 and the Robustos, they are mine.

Swissman
 
Back
Top