I wanted to check out their brass credit program, so here is my experience:
I sent them 27 lbs of brass in a USPS large flat rate box. I could have packed more brass in the box, but that was all that I cared to part with from my stash. The brass was mostly .40 S&W, with smaller quantities of .223/5.56mm, .44 magnum, .308, and 10mm. The .223/5.56 was some oddball stuff that I didn't want to mess with, as I keep only Lake City, Federal, Remington,and Winchester for my own use.
I ordered six boxes of their Blaster ammo - 3 of 9mm, 2 of .45, and one .38 Special. The shipment arrived yesterday, and I inspected the ammo this morning. I am well pleased with what I found. The Blaster grade is supposed to have visual imperfections, but mine looks as good as any factory stuff. It is all mixed head stamp, of course. The .45 is all small primer, which is fine with me. If this stuff shoots as good as it looks, I will be satisfied.
Now, the economics of the deal: The flat rate shipping cost me $15.45, and after the brass credit of $67.50, I was charged $13.30 for the order, including shipping. Therefore, my out of pocket was $28.75. My local scrap dealer pays $1.45 per lb for brass, so there was an opportunity cost of 27 x $1.45, or $39.15. Adding that to my out of pocket cost comes to a total of $67.90 for the six boxes of ammo. You can draw your own conclusions as to whether of not this is a good deal, depending on your local circumstances. I am fine with it.