Gun Laws that may help

Status
Not open for further replies.

Barrie

Member
Joined
Oct 4, 2011
Messages
2,357
Reaction score
713
Location
Canada
We read in the news about the trouble in the US regarding gun control. WE live under heavy control here in Canada but don't mind all that much at all. Fortunately we have been fortunate enough to keep guns out of the hands of unstable people by our laws here alone which has helped us not have hardly many major incidents with firearms at all. Our handguns are classed as resticted weapons and you must pass certain tests in order to obtain a licence to buy one here. They also call your spouse and a few friends to check on your sanity, political views and so forth as well. And a security check as well. This all takes around 3 months after you apply and then the club you join watchs you like a hawk for the 1st 3 months or so as well to see if you re a good guy or a squirrel. I suggest maybe something alone these lines may be useful to the good people of the US.:)
 
Register to hide this ad
Unlike Canadians, we have a Constitutionally-guaranteed (not granted, guaranteed - our Constitution doesn't grant rights to the people, rather it grants certain limited rights to the government) to keep and bear arms, subject to reasonable restrictions per the Heller decision. I, for one, have no particular desire to live under a government that thinks checking on my "political views and so forth" before I can exercise my constitutionally-guaranteed rights is a reasonable restriction. If I did, and if I were prepared to give up many other freedoms, I might consider moving to Canada, but that's mighty unlikely. Mighty unlikely indeed.
 
Barrie, you have been around almost 5 years so you must know how the wind blows around these parts. I'm sure our politicians would love to implement your ideas, however the pesky "we-the-people" would not only balk, but break out the pitchforks and torches. Let's talk about your everyday carry gun instead. Joe
 
Barrie, you have been around almost 5 years so you must know how the wind blows around these parts. I'm sure our politicians would love to implement your ideas, however the pesky "we-the-people" would not only balk, but break out the pitchforks and torches. Let's talk about your everyday carry gun instead. Joe

I don't think it would be pitchforks.
 
We have a criminal under class that deal in everything outlawed by the Gov. And they appear to prosper just the same. I do not see why they could not add guns to their list of outlawed items.

Without this outlaw class America would have virtually no gun crime or violence.

Its nice to know that you in Canada are comfortable and satisfied to have the Government dole out its privileges and permissions to those of you who remain good children and Subjects. We in America are not Subject to any government permission but demand and insist on our Rights remain untouched or the government be dammed.
 
We read in the news about the trouble in the US regarding gun control. WE live under heavy control here in Canada but don't mind all that much at all. Fortunately we have been fortunate enough to keep guns out of the hands of unstable people by our laws here alone which has helped us not have hardly many major incidents with firearms at all. Our handguns are classed as resticted weapons and you must pass certain tests in order to obtain a licence to buy one here. They also call your spouse and a few friends to check on your sanity, political views and so forth as well. And a security check as well. This all takes around 3 months after you apply and then the club you join watchs you like a hawk for the 1st 3 months or so as well to see if you re a good guy or a squirrel. I suggest maybe something alone these lines may be useful to the good people of the US.:)

I suggest you keep those ideas on ice, north of the border. I'm sickened to think that people are content to live under such tyranny.
 
Thank you for your input.

"We read in the news about the trouble in the US regarding gun control."

True - we have 30,000 + gun control laws and regulations at the Federal, State and local levels by report. Please point us to one that has prevented a violent crime from being committed by someone crazy enough to assault or murder someone? Especially when our Federal government has made prosecution of possession of any firearm by a convicted felon (mandatory 10 year prison sentence) an extremely low priority.

"...we have been fortunate enough to keep guns out of the hands of unstable people by our laws here alone which has helped us not have hardly many major incidents with firearms at all."

Can you tell us when Canada has had a higher firearms violence rate than the US? Please include the time before mandatory handgun registration began up north in 1934, when neither the US or Canada had any sweeping gun control laws on the books. I suspect that due to various cultural and social factors, Canadians have simply been less prone to using guns for violence.

However, with the understanding that statistics are not completely comparable between the two countries, I see the reported US violent crime rate at 387 per 100,000 in 2013 (at a 20 year low, despite tens of millions of new guns sold in the interim) and Canada at 1190 per 100,000 in 2012, roughly three times higher.

Do you think US gun owners using firearms for defensive purposes between 1-3 million times per year (rarely with a shot fired, and even less rarely resulting in injury or death) has contributed to the lower crime rates here? Do you think it is possible that violent crime in Canada might decrease if more private citizens had an effective means of defending themselves?

"Our handguns are classed as restricted weapons and you must pass certain tests in order to obtain a licence to buy one here. They also call your spouse and a few friends to check on your sanity, political views and so forth as well. And a security check as well. This all takes around 3 months after you apply and then the club you join watches you like a hawk for the 1st 3 months or so as well to see if you're a good guy or a squirrel".

Several areas of the US have tried, or are still following, similar regulations - Washington, DC, New York City and Chicago are three that come to mind, neither of which has achieved the gun (or violence)-free paradise envisioned by the government enforcing these laws.

Hope this is helpful.
 
Last edited:
your opinion

We americans (as some have already stated) have rights under the law to keep and bear arms, so what you do in Canada is your business I guess but don't try to tell us what we need, thank you anyway! 2nd amendment shall not be infringed!!!
 
Well, so far , the sergeant-at -arms in our Congress hasn't had to shoot any nuts who've just murdered soldiers at a war memorial and then gone on to attack Congress.

On the other hand, your sergeant-at-arms gets to wear a nice sword as well as have a pistol handy. The sword is rather classy, but that mace looks heavy!

Is it true that the one who killed the assassin in Parliament is now Canada's Ambassador to Ireland? I hope his replacement in Parliament is as good and quick a shot as he is. Oh, this is S&W related: he used a S&W 9mm auto pistol, like he learned to use while in the RCMP. Canada has no firearms industry to speak of.

Go hike on Vancouver Island and you may find yourself wishing for a pistol to protect you from cougars. It's probably the cougar attack capital of the world. But the entire province of British Columbia has a pretty high bear and cougar problem. Across the nation, singer Taylor Mitchell was killed by two coyotes in a park on Cape Breton Island. Lots of animals in between, too. And human villains! But it's illegal to carry a handgun for protection.

Canada is composed mainly of people who like to fear a powerful government that grants a few privileges amidst many restrictions. Your people didn't understand the United States in 1775 and still can't.

Great Britain has even stronger gun laws than you do, but MP Jo Cox was murdered there last week. Shot and stabbed. They have strong knife laws, too. The media bleating for more gun laws here is carefully minimizing reporting that Cox was shot in a nation with so many heavy gun laws.
 
Last edited:
This must be a joke or sarcasm that we aren't picking up on.


I think he made that post to wind us up and get the ignorant knee-jerk Americans offended so we'd make a lot of posts while he sits back and laughs at how he manipulated us. Probably makes him feel superior. I suppose he felt that need, given where he lives and how repressed his nation is.
 
Here is the big difference Your Canadians and we are NOT.

If the Canada government told everyone in the stadium to leave in the final quarter of the Stanley cup, Canadians would mumble politely under their breath and leave.

If the US government told everyone to leave during the 4th quarter of the Superbowl, there would be a riot.

You have low crime hooray. Montana and Wyoming have a very high rate of gun ownership and very lenient gun laws and they also have very low crime rates. Its because of the people not the laws.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Latest posts

Back
Top