HELP , I DESTROYED MY LOVED 686

Do you have Kitchen Dish Washing 'scrub' sponges where one side is a coarse surfaced scrubb pad?

That coarse surface is 'Scotchbrite'.
The same material that they sell in separate sheets that SA Fireman talks about in post #12.

The scrub pad Scotchbrite is pretty coarse compared to the maroon and grey colored stuff.
But if you use it along with some oil or even water, it will not cut as much and will take the high polished surface you have now from the 2000 grit polish and bring it down in brightness.

I'm assuming you want to reduce the high glare polish the 2000 grit polish gave you on the barrel back down to better match the factory look of the frame and the rest of the revolver.

You can also use steel wool. Use one of the coarser grades like 00 grade or 000 grade.
It will cut the glare down but will likely still leave a shine to the metal.
The Scotchbrite is a better material to reduce the glaring polish.

If you can get some 'pumice powder' that will work as well.
Commonly used to polish wood finishes, it is sold by stores that sell wood refinishing products here.
A dry very fine abrasive powder. You can try it in it's dry state,,just a little on a soft cloth and wipe down the surfaces.

Use it on a damp w/water cloth and you will get a slightly different look as it cuts a little faster.

None of the above will change any dimensions or harm anything.
When done, brush out any polishing dust and residue from the mechanism especially if you use the pumice powder as it is very abrasive.


You can experiment with directional polishing of any of these to see what looks best.
Since the original factory polishing grit lines are likely gone, just do what looks the best to your eyes.

These modern S&W parts are mostly finish polished in bulk in vibratory polish machines with polishing 'stones' loaded in with the parts doing the work.
Not unlike we clean brass cases for reloading.
That's where they get that certain look to them.

If you have access to a wire wheel set up spinning on an arbor,,then you can use that to put a very nice burnished finish on the metal.
First coat the metal with oil,,any oil will do.
Then with very light pressure against the spinning wire wheel, go over the surfaces. Use a non-directional pattern to the work.
The surfaces will take on a very nice gray tone look very much like the orig S&W finish.. Very easy and quick to do.


Just some ideas.
 
The damage can be fixed. You have only scratched the steel.

Jeweler's paste may be available to you. It comes in various grits and you can use that on (clean) rags or cloths to bring back the polish.
 
But I did not made damage that cant be fixed???

Please step back and take a deep breath, romanson. All is not lost and you haven’t done anything to damage the gun other than in a cosmetic way, and that can be repaired. You cannot make it original again, it’s only original once, but you (or your gunsmith if you no longer trust yourself) can bring back the original appearance with a grey Scotchbrite pad. These are readily available here in building supply stores but can also be found online too. Bear in mind that the grey color is a code for the finest grade of Scotchbrite.

If you decide to do it yourself, work slowly and consult the areas you did not polish, so you can match it. On the barrel your strokes should be along the length of the barrel, not around. Likewise the cylinder (if it was affected). The receiver should be polished as the original appears. Go slowly and gently, and use light pressure, checking your progress often.

The good news is that you have not really damaged the gun… only a little damage to its appearance. Some people spend the time and effort to polish them all over to a mirror shine. That’s not my style, but this is where the Americanism, “Different strokes for different folks” applies.

Good luck and keep us informed with your progress.
Green Frog
 
Take up fishing.......geeeez

MMleyGLl.png
 
I think white Scotchbrite pads are the finest, gray is the next. I would use the gray to start with and follow the grain and then finish with the white. I always put a little oil down where you polish, this helps remove the very minute metal residue from polishing. With a little time and patience it will be back to original.
 
Hello to all from Montenegro.

I destroyed my 686 , but I will wait that you guys confirm that first.

I had a scratch on the barrel of my gun , i I tryed to buff it out , using 2000 sand paper.

Insted , I will have to go to gunsmith , but I think that I will never archive original finish back.

What do you guys say?

Also , while using 2000 sand paper , did I remove much material????

Did I destroy my gun?
Pink scotch brite pads will work you'll be fine

Sent from my SM-T813 using Tapatalk
 
Not a big problem. Should be fairly easily fixed, depending on how much damage has been done so far trying to fix it.

Number one: Always "go with the grain" while apply abrasive. There will be fine lines that indicate the direction that the factory polishing followed. Follow that.

Number two: I have talked with several gun makers, and a sword maker over the last few years about the size grit used in their final finish in the last few years. Their answer has always been "800 git". My experience with stainless Smiths so far has proven this to be true. So, using either the grey Scotchbrite stuff that you can buy cheap on Amazon (grey seems to be 800 grit, but double check) or some Emery paper in that same grit. Rub it in the direction of the original factory polishing and you gun should look good as new in short order.

The problem that you have encountered is that if you rub your abrasive against the flow of the original or use a different size grit you are going to create an area that sticks out like a neon light. The trick is to match what was used originally for grit size and use it in the same way.
 
Tell me one thing ,
If I just bead blast the gun , making it look like short 627 or 629 , does that bead blasting hurt the gun?
Is that bad for gun , if I do in now , than lets say again in year and so on?
 
Tell me one thing ,
If I just bead blast the gun , making it look like short 627 or 629 , does that bead blasting hurt the gun?
Is that bad for gun , if I do in now , than lets say again in year and so on?

Reread post 19 and follow the recommendation there.
 
Ok.
But now I am thinking to do finish in sand blasted look, like 627.
If that process is repeated couple of times , does it damages the weapon?
 
Bead blasting damages the gun that much that I can trow in the trash , or you mean that mine is for the trash?
 
Keep in mind if you bead blast and you holster the gun a lot it will get shiny spots over time which can then be touched up down the road otherwise it won't hurt the gun if taken completely apart and done without damaging the muzzle crown and the front of the cylinder throats.

Sent from my SM-T813 using Tapatalk
 
Your revolver now has beloved character and attitude....sort of like many of us!!

Randy
 
I am from Montemegro.
There are no those stuff here to buy.
You just need to say is all lost
All is not lost ... a stainless steel finish is easy to fix and polishing metal can easily be done by hand .
To start I would use #0000 steel wool and oil to polish, steel wool will conform to curves ... oil helps the wool polish the metal .
Make small pads , wet with oil and polish untill the pad starts to fall apart or gets thin ... make a new pad .
Experiment with direction . Steel wool has no direction and can be used in any motion , rub long ways with things like barrel , circular on wide flat areas , you will have to experiment with direction and pressure to get the look you want .
After completing the #0000 steel wool polish , If you wish a brighter look , repolish with a automotive metal polish ... this takes a bit of elbow grease (work) to complete but the gun can be polished to look like chrome plating . I'm sure the auto parts store will have metal polish for cars .
Don't worry ... it's just the surface finish and can be fixed !
Gary
 
Last edited:
Ok.
But now I am thinking to do finish in sand blasted look, like 627.
If that process is repeated couple of times , does it damages the weapon?

Search this forum and look at pics of members guns who used Scoth bright pads to refinish their guns. Then look at pics of stainless guns posted by collectors.If you want the later ( factory look ) follow my instructions. Anything else will look like an obvious amateur re finish. Meaning you can still see all the boo boos under the soft brush.Just like painting a car you have to sand out all the imperfections before you paint.Also the factory does an acid bath to smooth things out a little before they leave the factory . After you refinish a stainless gun passification will take place again .you can speed that process up by using vinegar or other like forms of acid to wipe on the surface and let sit for a day or just let time do it for you like a couple of weeks.
 
Back
Top