I Don't Get It, Revolver VS Semi Auto Pistols?

Let me set the record straight before I read the replies. This thread has nothing to do with CC. It was just an observation that I wrongfully posted on The Lounge and it got moved here by a Mod. I also screwed up because I meant to say these Youtube guys are covering a revolver saying they had never owned one or fired one but they are coming around. It just struck me times fly and things change before you know it.

My apologies.
 
To me, a modern auto pistol is just a tool, no emotion or ties to history.
The WWI GI 1911 and Colt Woodsman my Grandad had, however did have
those special memories as my brother and I got to shoot them a lot thanks to Grandad. And they had history too.
I got to shoot them a lot when my Grandad was alive, and now that my older brother (retired detective) inherited them, I can still shoot them if I ask nicely.

To me, the revolver seems so much more natural and it can take you places.
When I hold or look at a revolver, even if it is the latest Kimber or PC Smith, I can imagine someone holding a revolver at battles like Gettysburg, Ishlawanda, Little Bighorn, or all the guys in WWI that had revolvers instead of Lugers and 1911's.

Jack O'Connor once said that he had little interest in revolvers, adored nice shotguns, but rifles, he lived rifles. Writing about rifles, shooting with them, and hunting all over the globe.
He could probably look at one of his Custom Model 70's and recall a lot of good hunts.

I carry revolvers much of the year but not in a "social" setting.
When in the outdoors it is almost always the M69 or M66-8 with me.
I like the versatility of bear loads or snakeshot in the same package.

I admit that when the threat might be 2 legged I do grab my Hellcat, or G48, both of which have a TRL light and front Tritium sight.
Not so much that I'll need the 13+1 or 15+1 that they hold, but they are thinner, lighter, and easier to conceal for me.
Both are utterly reliable.
Another is my .45 Shield, it too inspires confidence in a compact pistol.

Not that I couldn't defend myself adequately with the wheel gun.
I've even felt confident out camping and exploring with single action .45's,
and I can load and unload an SA pretty fast.
Hiking up this 150 year old dirt road near here, I can feel a connection with the Calvary troopers under General George Crook, who built this supply road to link the northern Arizona forts in the late 1860's. It was used until the 1930s when a more modern highway (AZ 260) paralleled it.
The soldiers from Camp Verde, Fort Whipple and Fort Apache that built
it probably used horses to move boulders, etc, but much of the work was done by pick and shovel in extreme weather, snakes, threat of Apache, and the occasional Scorpion in your bedroll.
Pretty hard work at $13 a month, but they did get to experience some excitement for maybe 2 weeks out of the year.
Like getting shot, bit, heatstroke or scalped.
ZBst8uwl.jpg

7kgYmMll.jpg

d6fQZ8Ml.jpg

These guys served over a hundred years before I did, and when walking that road I feel a connection, especially when I'm carrying one of these:
8NNgn1Yl.jpg

af2htQal.jpg
vQpcXs4l.jpg

Or even one of these !
cLWPiajl.jpg
 
Back in the 90's

Remember all the gun magazines ran endless articles "Revolver or Semi-auto" ad nauseum. I really got tired of it. Now a new generation is ready to start it all back up again.
 
To me, a gun is a gun. I don't split hairs over others choices because I don't subscribe to the belief that their exists some illusive ideal one-size-fits-all optimal self-defense firearm, nor do I believe that any centerfire firearm in particular is objectively superior to all others in every conceivable role, and I most certainly don't share the downright absurd notion that some others seem to be operating under in which firearms possess some form of enchantment which makes one gun in particular capable of turning any cartridge in particular into some form of death ray or instantly incapacitating hand phaser.
Sorry, but if you shoot a bad guy in the vitals with a Hi-Point, then it's going to be equally as effective as it would be with your Tactical Pterodactyl Armaments Company Niner Mike Mike Elite Professional Gold Cup Match Loaded Performance Package custom tuned by Cajun Langdon Wilson Tactical Gunworks fitted with Barbara Novak Lo-Mount Sights, Holofoil Luna Red Dot Optic with a compass in the brace and this thing which tells time.
Likewise, a Colt Single Action Army Revolver is equal to whatever the latest Whiz Bang .45 Caliber Semiautomatic with proper shot placement.
 
All I kept when I retired were my wheel guns.I could never get used to the semi autos and have always felt more comfortable with the revolvers.Hopefully my son and grandkids will take a liking to some of them when I'm gone.
 
When I renewed my CC permit, only me and one other person had revolvers out of a class of about 30 or more. And his was a NAA 22 magnum revolver. So that made me the only "revolver" person in the entire class. I carry J frames.
 
Last edited:
I'm 68 years old.

Even the "old farts" at my club show me respect when I clear the plate rack shooting a revolver DA.

Within the last several years I've discovered Glocks and now I shoot them often. Could even see carrying one.

I've always loved 1911's.
 
I believe the semi is cheaper to shoot and own, so more appealing to the casual gun owner.

Prior to my state making CC legal all I owned were Revolvers, now the only one I own is a Ruger Blackhawk.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
 
I was introduced to revolvers around 1952. The Navy introduced me to 1911s in 1963.

I have about an even split of revolvers versus semi-autos today. I carry either a Colt Python 357 magnum or a 1911 in 45 ACP or 10mm most of the time.

When I want more capacity, I go to a plastic semi-auto like my FN FNX-45 Tactical or Glock G40 MOS 10mm. When I want more power, I have 41 magnum, 44 magnum, and 454 Casull revolvers available.
 
How many pistol uses understand the need to "slap and rack" to clear a misfeed? Revolver can simply try again.

For self-defense, if six (seven or eight) rounds don't stop an attack, I'm not convinced twelve (seventeen or twenty-one) would improve the situation.

LOL, I say the same thing, back a few years I got into it with a gun counter salesman at the shop I've been buying from since the 80s. A woman came in looking for a gun for home defense, she seemed very nervous about owning a weapon but stated she'd do enough training to get comfortable with the gun.

The clerk then went on to try to sell her either a 92FS, an HK and a Glock, I told her what she really needs is either the 3" or 4" smith revolver in .38spl at that time selling for 365.00 versus the over 500 others. She ended up buying the smith 38. After she left the salesman got pissed at me for interfering in his commission, I took it up with his boss who ended up letting him go, after all, repeat business is better than onesies.
 
I dunno. I'm probably weird but I'm 33 and my daily carry is a 3 inch 357. Either a Python or a 19 carry comp. I love revolvers and the 357 cartridge. I occasionally carry a commander sized 1911 with no extra mags. I feel protected with 6 rounds of good 357 or 7+1 of 45.

44 magnum is my woods round and a 22lr revolver is my favorite range toy.
 
I think it may have a lot to do with age, as others have said. I'm 55, and to me a correct handgun is either a revolver (S&W specifically) or a 1911. A correct shotgun is pump or double barrel. A correct rifle is bolt action. Other things that seem " right" to me... a correct sports car is a Cobra with a 427, or an E Type Jag with a 3.8 six. Both have 3 pedals. A correct intercontinental airplane is a 747 with four engines. I could go on and on, but I tend to like the classics. Having said all that, I do have one polymer gun, and I really like it. It's a 380EZ and it's a joy to shoot. My friend took me for a ride in his Tesla Plaid and it freaked me out with its performance. After that every car seemed obsolete. And dull. New isn't all bad...
 
Including my two gun businesses and my own personal guns, I estimate I've owned about 18,000 guns in my life...Today I own 121 S&W revolvers, and two semi-automatic .45 ACP's, both Kimbers...I rotate my every day carry guns between two revolvers and the two Kimbers...I only wish I could have kept all the guns I've owned...:rolleyes:...Ben
 
Most of my handguns are S/W revolvers of most models. Only semi's I own are Hi-Powers { a T series, C series, a WW II era , and an SA-35 } . Tried tupper ware guns..no thanks.
 
Back
Top