If you could only have one!

[XTrooper]

My PC 627 UDR.

 

[Stainz]

I wanted one long enough... finally got it. Personal protection or plinking, it's appropriate/fun. A bit much to CC, however.

Ultimately, I bought two... since they are now similarly gripped, one could think they were seeing double...

I wouldn't cheat... and keep 'em both... no, not me!

Of course, if the reason for the 'one only' was ammo cost, I'd keep a .22 rimfire. I know some say they can reload .38's for what a .22 rimfire costs, but I do believe they are being disingenuous. At current prices, ~$30/1k, primers alone cost more than the least expensive brick ammo at WallyWorld ($16/550). Of course, you need more than primers, so I'd likely consider a rimfire - like my 4" 617, especially if range use was the main consideration. My 3" 63 would be decent, too - probably could be CC-ed, as well. My recent find, a 4" 651 (.22 WMR), might work with .22 LR's as is - I haven't tried them - or have an older x6 63 cylinder fitted as a choice. The added power of the new short-barrel .22 WMR ammo, like the Hornady FTX 45gr-ers, would be comforting.

I hate these one only choices. I CC because it may save my life - or my wife's. I plink because it's fun. Then, what if I had to feed myself? The prospect of becoming a vegan isn't exactly mouth watering!

Stainz

 

[JDW250]

Pretty hard choice, but I think it would have to be my 4" 686 for its overall versatility...

• Size - Large enough to be accurate at distance, small enough to carry concealed.
• Ammo - .38 special or .357 Magnum. Abundant supply and adequate stopping power.
• Stainless Steel - Low maintenance for all environments

And of course...

• Best Looking Revolver Made - If you can only have one, then you might as well be Stylin' and Profilin'!!!

What he said. Plus, a 4" .357 meets most state's handgun hunting requirements. Admittedly, my 686 4" is not my favorite handgun, but it would probably be one of the last to go considering it's versatility.

 

[YeshuaIsa53]

My first S&W was a 14-3. It is nothing good to look at(been through heck and back), but I sure wouldn't want to be lookin' down the wrong end of its barrel. Most natural shooting gun I have, and the one I have the most confidence in. Fits my hand like a glove. I could go back to the days when it was my only revolver...

 

[RHINOWSO]

One of these two... Probably the 640-1, but depending on the situation maybe the 65-3 3".

Rhino

 

[Shamrock]

I will go with my 6" 686-3. I'm large enough to put her in a shoulder holster and conceal comfortably. Accuracy,range, and power. For me the perfect package. If it were'nt I'd have bought something different in the last 22 years. "Merry Christmas to all"

 

[harleyvato]

It's a no brainier for me, 66 2 1/2". I didn't even have to think about it,versatile ammo choices, concealable,and for me one of the best looking revolvers ever made. YMMV

 

[heeter3]

My 442 that Ive carried every day since 1996 both on and off the job.

 

[Rapidray]

So close

Pretty hard choice, but I think it would have to be my 4" 686 for its overall versatility...

• Size - Large enough to be accurate at distance, small enough to carry concealed.
• Ammo - .38 special or .357 Magnum. Abundant supply and adequate stopping power.
• Stainless Steel - Low maintenance for all environments

And of course...

• Best Looking Revolver Made - If you can only have
  one, then you might as well be Stylin' and Profilin'!!!
  

I agree with you on all the above! Just one reason why I will keep my 681...I can not loose my rear sight or break it.

 

[williamlayton]

ALAS---it is to late for me & don't ask me to make a choice between my children.
Blessings

 

[Mule88]

My one revolver would be my 5 inch 629 DX. A bit heavy for CCW but a jack of all trades properly loaded.

 

[Blaze]

The very last to go would be my S&W model 60 38SPL. But I sure would miss my S&W model 34 4" .22RF. Both are great!!!

 

[G.T. Smith]

Looks like nobody is going to mention the most famous S&W of all time! It's the best CC weapon. It's the best hunting gun. It's the best target shooter. It's the.....CTG!!!!!!!!
Peace,
Gordon

 

[MacA]

I agree with you on all the above! Just one reason why I will keep my 681...I can not loose my rear sight or break it.

The 681 is definitely on my short list for future purchases!!

 

[SuperMan]

..a Mountain Gun... .41, .44 or .45 ACP....

Depending on my "circumstances" I would probably lean towrd the .45 ACP. One can find ammo everywhere, recoil is light, one can also fire .45 Super for hunting...

Bob

 

[WFR]

Probably one of these 2 with the Mtn Gun being much more versatile.
A 4" 629-4 or 629 Mtn Gun would have to be a top pick as well.

625 Mtn Gun in .45 Colt

CS-1 3"

 

[rkjent]

model 10, a very good all around gun

 

[Marshall 357]

If I could have only one revolver,it would mean the 'SHTF' and that the USA was in trouble. I would not be worried about concealed carry wouldnt be allowed,it would be a matter of which revolver can I shoot the best,will last the longest,be able to hunt 4 and 2 legged creatures at a good distance.My 29-2 with 8 3/8'' bbl would be going with me,its almost a small rifle.Just my thoughts on the subject......Merry Christmas

 

[Hearsedriver]

J-Frame Model 36 snub, hands down.

 

[dirtygeary]

dumb question. I cannot give up enough to get down to one. Its inconceivable.