If you had to choose?

[bossduce]

I recently came accross two older Smiths and can not decide on which one to get. I appreciate everyone's information on my previous threads. Here are my options:

1. Pre model 14 Target Masterpiece 6" from 1957 very good condition, I would rate it around 90 to 95%, non original target grips.
4 screw. I can get for around $440 out the door.


2. Pre model 10 2" from 1948 good condition, I would rate it at around 85% 5 screw with original grips. $550 out the door.

Since purchasing a Pre 15 5 screw I have developed a fondness for these timeless works of art. So, which would you choose? Thanks in advance.

 

[Muley Gil]

IMHO, the pre M10 is overpriced for it's condition.

Good with the pre M14.

 

[K&Nframe]

I would go with the pre 14. It is priced right, and in better condition. The pre 10 is over priced and in lesser condition. Plus the pre 14s are a pleasure to shoot.

Kevin

 

[Buford57]

+1 on the K38 Masterpiece unless you're looking for a carry piece.

 

[DCWilson]

Another vote for the Pre-14. The Pre-10 ought to be down around $400 in my opinion -- or even a little less.

 

[Iggy]

Do we see a pattern developing here. I'd go for the pre 14 too

 

[pace40]

Depends on the serial number of the M&P. If its between S990xxx and C1 and has a short action, I'd take the M&P.

 

[kpm]

I have always thought there was a reason it's called a "Masterpiece".

 

[moosedog]

I'd go with the K-38. The 2 inch M&P is not a bargain at that price.

 

[peyton]

Pre model 14 Target Masterpiece wins in a landslide. Or better yet, buy both!!!

 

[Win712]

The K-38 Masterpiece is a MUST HAVE in your collection, my first choice. But of course so is a 2" K- frame. Ah, the addiction starts with not being able to choose just one. Try to get a package deal and buy both. Greg

 

[dasandman]

pkg. deal

make a package deal if you can!

 

[bossduce]

I would do that, but unfortunately, they are at two different shops.

I think the pre 14 K-38 is the way to go (based on the feedback). Thank you for everyone's input.

 

[Michael Stern]

For me, it's a choice of logic or passion

No question: objectively the target gun is the better deal, and if you are planning on plinking or target shooting, the right choice. On the other hand, I've rarely met a 2" M&P that doesn't want to climb into my safe.

 

[Sebago Son]

Michael! Good to see you Amigo! There's probably not much room in your safe for anything other than a 2" snub anyway!

However, my logical self has won out in this conversation and I vote "Masterpiece".....

Drew

 

[handejector]

Depends on the serial number of the M&P. If its between S990xxx and C1 and has a short action, I'd take the M&P.

OP needs to check on this.
It would be a very rare bird, since none of us have ever seen one.

 

[fyimo]

I'd go with the pre 14 unless it turns out to be that rare bird no has ever seen.

 

[bossduce]

No, its not the rare one. It has a "C" prefix.

 

[310Pilot]

The K-38 Masterpiece ("pre-14" - cringe) wins hands-down, without any hesitation. The M&P is, IMHO, overpriced, and the K-38 is such a sweet gun to shoot you'll kick yourself repeatedly for not buying it if you ever shoot another. 2" Ks are quite nice, but that K-38 will have you dreaming of shooting it again and again.

 

[pace40]

No, its not the rare one. It has a "C" prefix.

Then buy the Masterpiece. The M&P is way overpriced for an 85% gun.