The late John Wootters, Jr., a well known gun and hunting writer, got one, a .357 Magnum Martial model revolver. I think he came by it through some promotional visit involving one of his publishers. He was very demanding of quality and I doubt that he'd have bought a Spanish gun unless he had some special incentive.
But he told me that he was pleasantly surprised by the quality. I think it was out-of-time a little, but the same was then true of most US-made revolvers, inc. S&W's. This was probably in the 1970's, maybe about 1980. I suspect that he had a gunsmith fix the timing issue. He said that he was overall pleased by the quality.
That surprised me, for John was not a man to suffer bad quality products. He was very knowledgeable about guns and about wildlife. He was a consultant to the Houston zoo on Texas snakes and was also an avid enthusiast of WW II aircraft. His death a couple of years ago was a real loss, although he'd retired from writing after suffering a retinal detachment.
If he gave the Llama Martial .357 such a charitable review, at least some Llama guns must have been good. I should note that he told me this on the 'phone; I don't know if he reviewed the gun in print. He usually tried to avoid writing typical gun reviews, because he didn't like to risk stepping on some editor's or ad manager's toes or an advertiser's, if he was candid. One gun that he did review, because he really liked it, was the Winchester M-70 Classic Featherweight .30-06. I thought that I'd throw that in, in case anyone here might be wondering about getting one. It's also one of my favorite rifles.
John also used to load Llama and Star locked breech .380's hotter than usual, if memory serves.
He wouldn't have done that unless he trusted at least those particular guns. He was a very knowledgeable reloader.
Chas. Askins told me that the Spanish pistols were pretty fair, if not as well finished or as consistent as US equivalents.
He had been US military attaché in Spain and knew Spanish guns quite well. He owned some of their better shotguns, like the AyA copy of the German Merkel guns.
My only exposure to Spanish arms was to a Star 9mm, Model S. It was on loan from the importer and I fired just a few boxes of ammo in it. It felt very good in the hand and fed well and was accurate, more so than a typical Colt .45 auto. I thought of buying it, but was alarmed by finding what looked like scratches by a nail on the underside of the slide. I was afraid that the gun had failed inspection in some Third World country and been sold as surplus to Interarms. The PR man didn't want to say from just where they'd gotten that batch.
I've since read that this marking may have been usual in several Spanish makers, to let assemblers see the number marked, like an X, to keep parts from a given gun together as they were processed.
I don't know if it might also have been their way to check hardness, as more advanced countries use Rockwell test needles.
Spanish pistols, inc. those by Star and Llama, some marked as Ruby, were bought by France in WW I and these and the Astra brand were also bought by Nazi Germany to supplement their other sources. The best were generally conceded to be by Astra and Star.
I have a baseball cap from Star, given to me at the SHOT show one year by a rep from that firm. And I've stayed at a motel more than 50 miles from home and I carry a briefcase.
That is the extent to which I can be deemed an expert on Spanish guns. But the story of the Llama brand is so well known that I think they were "iffy" but okay if you got a good one. In other words, somewhat of a dart toss as to quality. Personally, I might buy a Star. I wouldn't buy a Llama.
Oh: Again, this is about Star; not Llama. But a shooting range here rented their Model 30S DA 9mm autos. I called that range after reading an Interarms ad about those guns exceeding 100, 000 rounds in rental use and holding up fine. They confirmed the quality and said that Interarms was very good about service if ever needed. I was impressed. But Interarms is now out of business and parts are often hard to locate.
I'm impressed by Cyrano's post here, as I usually am.