Is a model 10 really a $450 gun now?

Old corp quite the deal on the 12! I don’t see many vintage K frames in my area at all, and have only in all my years seen a handful of 12’s about half of those having cracked frames. For that reason I won’t consider buying an alloy frame gun sight unseen on line unless there is a very well executed picture of the area known to crack.

Yessir MajorD - it was the last thing I expected to see in this particular LGS.
First thing I looked at were the known problem areas in M12's and other alloy framed revolvers known for the infamous 'crack' near the barrel's entrance to the frame from either +P ammo or too-energetic handloads. It was fully intact.
This one doesn't get shot much, and when it does, it's often .38 WC's, some bulk .38 Spl. 130 gr FMJ's or some sedate handloads I made up for it pushing a 158 gr 'Blue Bullet' cast/coated moving along at less than 800 fps.
On the rare occasion I carry it, it will probably be loaded with the Federal 125 gr. 'Nyclad' HP's in the pic.
 
For Sale: S&W 10-6


I listed this 10-6 in the classifieds several weeks ago. It has generated little interest. My intention at the time was to replace it with a S&W 67; however, that ship has sailed. I have not found a model 10 of any variation in the same or better condition for under $700.00 in local shops. I can’t replace it for the price I listed it for.
 
They are out there

I have never seen a Model 19 at a gunshow for $450-600.

Got this 19-3 about a year ago or so with some bluing loss, no box or paperwork, tight lock up and best trigger I’ve ever felt and as an added bonus came with Herrett Jordan Trooper grips in great shape! $360 out the door.

Keep looking you’ll find one. That’s half the fun.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_0119.jpg
    IMG_0119.jpg
    108.1 KB · Views: 44
Got this 19-3 about a year ago or so with some bluing loss, no box or paperwork, tight lock up and best trigger I’ve ever felt and as an added bonus came with Herrett Jordan Trooper grips in great shape! $360 out the door.

Keep looking you’ll find one. That’s half the fun.

I have found a couple on GB for between $400 and $500, just never at a show.
 
This is a M&P .38 3" (Unusual, yes. A slight taper and all markings centered) with a ship-date of 1958 per Mr. Jinks at S&W. About 8 years ago or so, I was working one of my p/t 'retirement jobs' at a LGS/Indoor Range.
This one had come in the day before, on my day off, and needed to be logged in. Story was a youngster came in and traded it on, of course, a Glock. Came with a slightly worn DeSantis pancake actually made for a K-3". I got no real back story on the gun. One of the guys said he got the idea it was an inheritance - not sure.

Photo doesn't show it, but it shows signs of having been a 'work gun' at least for a time. Someone had done a decent job of smoothing away all the grooves on the standard service trigger. Mechanically, near perfect.

Checked with the owner/boss - he made me shell out $150 for it!

It now wears correct Diamond Magnas and a BK grip adapter.
__________________
Ret'd LEO
SWCA #2275
 

Attachments

  • S&W M&P  3 in.JPG
    S&W M&P 3 in.JPG
    190.7 KB · Views: 50
Last edited:
Is a 4 inch Model 13 worth $900? That seems to be the average price on GB…..
 
Most of us can remember "back in the day". Like, when I could go to a gun show and take my pick of one of 3 new Colts, Python, SAA, or AR15(they were all Colts then.) for $375. I recently went to a show, where a guy had a couple of SKS rifles on his table, and had a sign that read, "I've already heard you cheap SKS story." I told him he had a sense of humor like mine. Last year I bought a high condition post war, low C serial number M&P .38 4" for 500 and felt great about it.
 
Last edited:
To add a little new data to the discussion, there were two S&W 10-5's on GB this week. I bought one for $336 BUT with shipping, tax, cc fee, it came to $427.08! I think you can still see it if interested at:
Just a moment.... There was one more that sold for $365 plus all the other costs. It was item 1005704175. I really wanted an S&W to compare to my Colt Official Police. From my reading, the two would have made up 90% of the police issue sidearms. Comments welcome
 
I just bought a pre model 10, or M&P to be correct made around 1946-47, that looks very nice from the pics. Price was reasonable at $372 I thought., Only $20 for shipping rather than the typical over charge like the $40 you paid, C&R so it's coming to me so no transfer cost. The details make a difference in the real cost of buying on GB. Don't have it yet so I'll have to see what it looks like in hand compared to pics. Persistent browsing can lead to good buys occasionally.
 
Is a really nice let’s say 98% finish with matching grips model 10 ( no box or papers) really a $450 gun these days?

The gun was very clean ( the ejector rod still had a full blue finish)
And I am tempted to try to trade for the model 10.

Input appreciated

I'm a cheapskate but I'd expect that much or more at a pawn/gun shop. And I'd pay it, were I in the market,
 
There can certainly be some regional variation.
In California with “the roster” prices on used guns are higher than elsewhere. ( high demand limited supply)
Being a former NY resident I can say prices were lower there, probably owing to the onerous handgun ownership laws which means a lot less people buying handguns ( I could go on for a long time on the nonsense in NY but suffice to say you needed a permit simply to own a handgun, and in some jurisdictions the start to finish time from application to approval was sometimes two years or more!)
 
The OP stated that the gun in question is in a pawn shop. That brought about some offering buying strategies but the majority of pawn shop comments were derogatory. I fall into the opposite camp
I have dealt with pawn shops in my local area as well as out of town, on the road, etc. Have bought many items over the years, guns, tools, jewelry, misc, etc. Bought a few things that bit me but that is on me. Dealt with good people who happen to be in the pawn business. I've seen them make money and lose it. When they loan on stolen goods they lose their money when the pawn shop squad show up to get it. They fill a niche. They deal with people who are not candidates for more traditional sources to get loans to buy food, keep the lights on and yes just to throw it away and lose the property. I ve bought many guns from my favorite pawn shop. And I've pointed out to them when they got in over their head and loaned on busted, unsafe, misidentified or otherwise guns they should have passed on. They are in a high risk business and high risk deserves high returns. When we make a good deal on something we crow about it. But the pawn shop seller is villified for it. Value and cost are two different things. Nobody sells for cost. If you knew what the cost of that jewelry you just bought the wife you would never buy another piece. EVER. Pawn shop owner is another business person, hires and pays salary, pays taxes. Utilities, insurance, and suffers losses from theft and burglay, etc and deserves a profit. The amount not to be judged by me as I do not have his risks.
I often queer my own deal. If there is a gun I want and I am Sked what it is worth I give them an honest answer. It may be higher or lower than their listed price and we discuss. Sometimes I can buy it for my price, sometimes not. They quote me a price and I say yes or no.. No haggling, no character assassination or rail about his cost or business ethics.No hard feelings, it's business. If they give me any price break I always thank them.. I try to be a resource for them on anything I can help with. In turn they do not charge me a transfer fee. Sometimes, maybe twice a year I'll bring in lunch for them when they're too busy to take a break. Bottom line is I want them to be profitable, successful,, so they will be there the next time I need them. Who benefits if they close their doors?
My take. Pardon the length and don't feel I strayed too far.
 
Last edited:
50 target you are good points and well stated. Agree with you completely
 
Back
Top