J Frame Grip Recommendations

Joined
Jun 12, 2006
Messages
90
Reaction score
10
Location
Michigan
Figured I would ask the experts here for some advice. I am not even sure if what I am looking for is even made. I have been trying to find a set of rubber grips that cover the backstrap on Jframe RB's that doesn't add length to the grip. Looked at the Pach compacts but they seem bulky. Hogue with the screw adapters are to long for my tastes. Any other options out there? Thanks.
 
Register to hide this ad
Right after I saw your post, the next thread I opened was a for sale post for a 442 with 9mm conversion, by a member named slabside2. The grips on his gun appear to be what you're looking for. You might want to look at his photos, then contact him. Hope that helps.

I have the Hogue tamers. Love the way they mitigate recoil, but don't have them on the gun right now because I prefer wood boot grips for concealment. The tamers are longer.

Good luck.
 
For average size hands I like the Pachmayr "Compact" grips.

Brownell's
692-000-004WB
Model SJ/C S&W "J" frame
Mfr Part: 03252

Smiles,
 
For average size hands I like the Pachmayr "Compact" grips.

Brownell's
692-000-004WB
Model SJ/C S&W "J" frame
Mfr Part: 03252

Smiles,
What about the reviews that say the new ones have major fit and finish issues. I been searching ebay to try and find a old pair of the originals. I just went with the hogue bantam for better conceal carry than the larger hogue grips that were on there but it has the open backstrap.

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
 
This is an old and grainy photo of a bunch of 640-1's with a nice variety of grips/stocks. From left to right: Uncle Mikes extended grip, a pair of early 640-1's with Uncle Mike's Boot Grips, Eagle Secret Service checkered, and Hogue Bantam grips. Right now my EDC 640-1 wears a set of Craig Spegel walnut boot grips, and the 13-2 wears Pachmayr Compac full coverage grips. Very grippy.

Gila's 640-1's.jpg Model 13 3 in and 640-1.jpg
 
This is an old and grainy photo of a bunch of 640-1's with a nice variety of grips/stocks. From left to right: Uncle Mikes extended grip, a pair of early 640-1's with Uncle Mike's Boot Grips, Eagle Secret Service checkered, and Hogue Bantam grips. Right now my EDC 640-1 wears a set of Craig Spegel walnut boot grips, and the 13-2 wears Pachmayr Compac full coverage grips. Very grippy.



View attachment 508259 View attachment 508260
I also have a 640-1 and still trying to find a grip that conceals well and one that you can still shoot 357's without it causing pain. Do any of those grips conceal well and still work well with recoil? I just put a set of the hogue bantams on but with the exposed back strap I am not looking forward to shooting 357's out of it. Thanks and very nice collection you have there.

After looking at how shiny yours are I will need to do a couple more rounds of polish on mine. Lol
6e465689c6160d00926b25d309d4bc76.jpg


Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:
What about the reviews that say the new ones have major fit and finish issues. I been searching ebay to try and find a old pair of the originals. I just went with the hogue bantam for better conceal carry than the larger hogue grips that were on there but it has the open backstrap.

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
I had some wood grips on my 36 that was really uncomfortable shooting any 38 +P rounds. The boney base of the thumb on the palm took a beating. I put on the Hogue rubber grips, and even though the back strap is uncovered, the base of the thumb is protected by the rubber. It made huge difference, and the fit is perfect.
 
Last edited:
I had some wood grips on my 36 that was really uncomfortable shooting any 38 +P rounds. The boney base of the thumb on the palm took a beating. I put on the Hogue rubber grips, and even though the back strap is uncovered, the base of the thumb is protected by the rubber. It made huge difference.
Thanks!! I just put these smaller hogue grips on with exposed back strap. Haven't had a chance to shoot it yet with 357's. I will give it a try before looking further. Thanks again!!

Sent from my Pixel 2 XL using Tapatalk
 
Right after I saw your post, the next thread I opened was a for sale post for a 442 with 9mm conversion, by a member named slabside2. The grips on his gun appear to be what you're looking for. You might want to look at his photos, then contact him. Hope that helps.

I have the Hogue tamers. Love the way they mitigate recoil, but don't have them on the gun right now because I prefer wood boot grips for concealment. The tamers are longer.

Good luck.

LOL, I have the exact same revolver in 38. the grips dont cover the backstrap. They are the best for concealing i have found so far though. Thanks
 
Looked at the Crimson trace grips a few times. Grip is what i am looking for but not sure if i am ready to take that plunge or want the laser.
Thought about buying a new pair of compacts (pachs) and trimming them down. I have a couple sets of older compacts but dont want to ruin them. I hear the new ones are not as nice.
 
It’s a matter of math and geometry. You can’t cover the back of the grip strap without increasing the distance to the back of the grip by the thickness of whatever covering you add. The only other option would be to reshape the back of the grip strap, a strategy I strongly DON’T recommend! My best solution to getting a comfortable grip on my J frame was to add a Thai (via e-Bay) set of smooth combats. The sad truth is, you won’t know what fits your hand comfortably until you actually have it in your own hand. :confused:

Froggie
 
Back
Top