K22 vs. Model 17

Alpo

Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2006
Messages
5,875
Reaction score
6,627
Location
N/W Florida
Help me out here, y'all, 'cause apparently I'm confused or he is.

Another board, and the poster is complaining about a deal that went south. Among the other problems was, "The dealer said it was a K22. It wasn't. It was a Model 17".

Now, my understanding is that long ago Smith made a target revolver on the 38 Special "K" frame, that they called a "K 22 Target Masterpiece". Then 'long about 1957 they started giving the guns numbers, so the K22 Target Masterpiece was now, also, the Model 17. Still a K 22, it just picked up a model number. Then they took that gun, put a 4" barrel on it, for easy carrying, and a ramp sight, and called it the Model 18. Still a K22, but not a "Target Masterpiece". So my 17 and my 18 are K22s. My 19 is a Combat Magnum. I've got four Military & Police revolvers, even though one of 'em is marked Model 10.

So, is my understanding wrong? Do names only apply to pre-numbered guns?

I understand that he was assuming that because it was a K 22 it was a pre-model number gun, but is he correct in that assumption?

I know my 28-2 is roll-stamped Highway Patrolman, so even though it has a number is still has a name.
 
Register to hide this ad
A M17 is a K-22.
Some people would see K-22 and think "Pre-17", I don't know what the poster was thinking so I can't comment, but some people are touchy. I still call my M19 and M66 Combat Magnums, and a lot of people on here do too.
Maybe somebody needs to lighten up.:D I wouldn't worry about it.
Jim
 
K22's and such

Any K frame revolver chambered in .22 is technically a "K22".

Target Masterpiece, Combat Masterpiece, Outdoorsman, Pre war, Post war , 3,4,5 screws , Target hammer, High speed hammer etc ..
are all descriptive terms that help narrow each change in the evolution down to a specific characteristic.

If the buyer was looking for a Pre 1957 4 or 5 screw 6" K22 Masterpiece but ended up with a 3 screw 17-2,3,4 etc K22 Target Masterpiece,
Someone dropped the ball communicating what was what even if it was not model marked as some guns occasionally get through unmarked.

Case in point:

In my search for a "pre 19" I found an non model marked Model 19-4 ,
I luckily recognized it only had 3 screws,
removing the grips confirmed it serialed to the 1980's.

The fact that it got through QC unmarked doesn not mean it isnt a 19-4.

If someone advertised it as a "Non model marked Combat magnum I would be expecting a 4 screw "Pre 19",
To not disclose it as a 19-4 would be deceptive.

Eventually I did find my 4 screw non model marked 19 but it has a serial number slightly above what is recognized as the
cut off date by SCSW 3rd ed.

If I ever sell it I would not feel comfortable advertising it as a "Pre 19" even though it may technically be.
AS both model marked and non MM guns were coming out the door I would feel abliged to call it a,
Non Model Marked 4 screw Model 19 Combat Magnum"
 
Last edited:
IMO, if the buyer was familar with the terms K22, model 17, etc., and it made a difference to him, he would have verified exactly what it was before he bid. I would...
 
Any K frame in 22 caliber can be called a K22.

Most people refer to model stamped guns by the model number. Guns made before 1957 get called by the names S&W gave them, like "K22 Masterpiece" and "K22 Combat Masterpiece" (note how both are K22).

Perhaps the buyer THOUGHT he was getting a pre-model marked gun and was disappointed to learn it was newer than he thought. In general, older is more desirable to collectors so a 1955 K22 Masterpiece would be more valuable than a 1959 Model 17 if all variables were otherwise the same.
 
"Any K frame revolver chambered in .22 is technically a "K22"." Engine49guy

"Any K frame in 22 caliber can be called a K22."Saxonpig

Is this a K-22?

bdGreen


Model45nonmarked.jpg

Funny you should ask that question. I was just looking at an auction for a "Pre-45 .22 M&P--RARE Fixed Sight K22 POST OFFICE".
 
Is it a K22..... sorta but no.
Notice i said K frames in .22 are "Technically K22's".

Although its a K frame chambered in .22 ... the arguement could be made that referring to it as a K22 would be like calling a .38 M&P a K38.

I think we can all agree it is not a " K22 Masterpiece"

Nomenclature Nomenclature I love to hate Nomenclature.
 
Last edited:
There are always 2 names for S&Ws: the one the factory used and the popular one. Any K frame 22 may be called a K22 by popular calling, the factory had specific names which may or may not have included the K22 label.

Does anybody besides me not really care any longer?
 

Latest posts

Back
Top