lemi- shine question

[Moonman]

Thumbler's Tumbler 15 pound Rotary Tumble model B, Hi-Speed.
5 # S.S.Pins a 9 MM cap full Lemi-Shine, Gallon Water, 2 lbs brass

and I switched from DAWN dishwashing detergent to using
Armor-All Car Wash and Wax with Carnauba Wax.

 

[Bart45]

I wet tumble with a Thumler's B, some liquid dish detergent, and citric acid, which is available for a lot less than LemiShine. They do tarnish eventually, but have never heard of shiny brass being more accurate than tarnished brass.

 

[Bkreutz]

I wet tumble with a Thumler's B, some liquid dish detergent, and citric acid, which is available for a lot less than LemiShine. They do tarnish eventually, but have never heard of shiny brass being more accurate than tarnished brass.

But then again, I've never heard of shiny brass being less accurate. (if I had to tumble my brass after pin cleaning to get(keep) them shiny, I wouldn't do it). Mine tarnished until I started using the wash and wax stuff. I think the car wash/wax works out to about the same cost as dish soap. (but I've never actually checked )