Joni_Lynn is probably correct but I had a 686 with your symptoms some time back.I oiled it,cleaned it nothing worked.I ended up removing the entire thumb piece and physically scrubbing down the inner surfaces of the frame and thumb piece.I then lightly oiled the parts after assembly and never had any further problems.What had happened was the previous owner had cleaned this gun a lot,even removing the side plate often and spraying WD-40 inside the gun.The stuff dried,built up and finally turned into a sticky mess making the thumb piece stick in operation.