Iam legend, I suppose you SHOULD be able to but it back from the insurance company for what they gave you for it. I once had a colt new frontier bought new by audie murphy stolen. I probley got about $250s from the insurance at the time, 25 years ago. I can prove audie bought it new. Now the insurance wouldnt pay me for the factor that it belonged to murphy, but just the going rate for a generic one. Yet were that gun to turn up I imagine it would go for at leaqst $25,000 or maybe much more! If the insurance company tried to pull that, I think you would read about me in the newspaper!