MODEL 28-2 NEED HELP!!!!

[Blindrider93]

More Pictures

More Pictures:

 

[Blindrider93]

More Pictures

More pictures:

 

[Narragansett]

More Pictures:

Looks great. Enjoy it!!

 

[Blindrider93]

Last Picture

Last picture: Serial number with the last 2 digits blacked out via photoshop.

 

[Bobbysixkiller]

Looks like a nice shooter. I gave 600 for one about a month ago. I’d shoot it and be happy with it.

 

[CLASSIC12]

That defaced serial number under the crane would bother me. And since the seller offered to refund it I would give it back. To be honest, I wouldn’t have bought it in the first place.

 

[Mike SC Hunter]

That defaced serial number under the crane would bother me. And since the seller offered to refund it I would give it back. To be honest, I wouldn’t have bought it in the first place.

The s/n on the bottom of the frame is the only one that MATTERS.

 

[CLASSIC12]

The s/n on the bottom of the frame is the only one that MATTERS.

I UNDERSTOOD that part, and I am not talking about the legality. It would bother me COSMETICALLY, and the gun does not seem to be in a great shape anyway. I wouldn’t buy a gun someone (probably a criminal as stated a few times here) took a file to and I think the OP can do better with his money. Chill Mike.



PS I’ll add that the OP is clearly bothered by this. How many times has someone called two friends and the original seller after a gun purchase ?

 

[BSA1]

Is it the serial number or the assembly number that is stamped on the frame that is covered by the yoke?

Why the question about it’s value? It’s current value is what you paid for it. There is no way to accurately predict it’s future value.

It sounds like the O.P. is having a case of buyer’s remorse. Since the seller is offering you a full refund returning the gun back to him would relieve you of any worries about it.

p.s. you do realize the the oversize target grips were not standard for the Model 28.

 

[daddio202]

I think the price was fair and the gun looks like its in pretty nice shape to me. The gun is completely fine. Clean it, fondle it, shoot it and enjoy it. The serial is on butt and the fitters number stamp in the yoke area look totally normal to me. The OP is simply WAY over thinking the situation. I dont know where anybody is buying nice condtion
28-2's with 4 inch barrel for under $500 now days but please tell me where because I only see them for $600 and up everywhere I look - and I do a lot of lookin!

 

[Ackley1952]

I’ll bet after all these conversations about the gun the dealer will Never sell you another gun. Model 28-2 have one serial number and your trying to ignore it .

 

[AZretired]

I agree, keep it shoot it and enjoy it. The number removed from the crane area was not the serial number. Serial numbers were not stamped on the crane when that revolver was made. If you bought it through a dealer and filled out a 4473 I would not worry. I had a 28-2 stolen in 2004 and that's not it.

 

[hemiram]

If it was in a pawn shop, it's NOT a hot gun. The serial number is no big deal, the one on the butt is the one that matters and I would have no worries keeping it. And whoever told you that you paid too much is not living on the same planet I'm on, $650 is not bad at all for the gun and those grips. I hope I can get one I'm looking at for the same price. If I could find a good one for $450, well, I would have a bunch of them, instead of just the 6" one I happily paid $700 for last year.

 

[Mrnurse]

In NC the Police will NOT run SN if you just request it...they WILL if there is a stop that warrants further Checking. The ATF ONLY uses the Frame SN...all others are not important from a Legal perspective. Any # thats been altered is cause of Concern. Me... I would want my $$$ back. 650.00 for a 28 with 90% finish 4 inch is a fair price. The stocks are newer SW.

 

[lrrifleman]

I have been watching this for a few days, and just saw the updated pictures. Granted, due to cataract surgery I am looking at the pictures with one eye, the "defacing" looks awful level/balanced, suggesting that if a criminal had it defaced, they had the barrel pulled and reinstalled! With the barrel on, even with a dremel tool, I don't think the "defacing" would be that even. The side of the frame nearest the cylinder window doesn't look disproportionately deeper than where the extractor shroud is.

Working on the premise that the revolver is clean, I think you paid a fair price! Makes me kick myself for not buying the 4" Model 28 my gunsmith tried to steer me into in the late '90s for $325!

 

[ispcapt]

My 28-2 has serial # N2775XX. Mine has the serial # stamped at the same place. It's stamped pretty light tho. The MOD 28-2 tho is stamped deeper.
I'm in agreement with KEN158. As light as the serial # is stamped on mine it wouldn't take much fitting filing to obscure mine.
I'm also in agreement with the others. The guy has offered to return your money. Since it's bothering you so much now and it will no doubt continue to bother you no matter what anyone says then return it and get your money back. He won't have any trouble selling it, probably for more money, and with less hassle. You'll be happier. The dealer will definitely be happier.

 

[hemiram]

Worrying about this gun is like going outside in the rain, and being upset about getting wet. There is nothing concerning about this gun in any way. But I have to agree, it would probably be better for him if he sent it back, as nothing anyone says seems to convince him the gun is fine.

 

[cmansguns]

any update from OP?

I'm late to this party, but wondering since post is several days old if the OP's gun has gone back to the dealer yet, or still languishing betwixt "should I.....shouldn't I"?

Pics below are my 1974 Model 28-2 and of course the serial number on butt is deep, clear, totally legible. Also, the same serial number including the "N" is on the yoke above Mod 28-2, and is also clear, legible (including the N...but my pic is crummy).

I have a FFL and agree with others that the butt serial number is all that legally counts, but I have also been involved with local gun shops with clerks and even owners/managers that are up to date on AR platforms and plastic fantastic, but really have no clue as to Smith wheel guns....that's why I've been called and asked to explain (to a prospective buyer in person) why the numbers shown around the firearm are "real" serial numbers and as you all know, in many instances they are assembly numbers. Yea......there have been some good stories sometimes the buyer really knows but is using "wrong serial numbers, non-matching" to dicker the price down, others (sellers) that don't have proper screwdriver at the counter, and don't want to pull grips...etc.

No long harangue here.....the Op's gun has raised questions in his mind, so what the rest of us think or say doesn't really matter. I will tell you that anything I sell has the same "gentlemen's warranty" in that you don't like it for any reason I'll refund your money provided I get it back exactly as I shipped it to you.

My vote would be to return it to the seller but thank him for being a standup guy....you are really lucky to have a "dealer" like that to work with.

 

[Blindrider93]

I’ll bet after all these conversations about the gun the dealer will Never sell you another gun. Model 28-2 have one serial number and your trying to ignore it .

I bought it from a gentleman, at a gun show, that lives 200 miles from me. I literally don’t care if he never sells to me again because I will probably never see him again. Your comment was neither helpful or informative. When did I ever say that I was trying to ignore the fact model 28-2 have one serial number. As a matter of fact, I stated multiple times I KNOW ITS LEGAL! Maybe before you make an accusation you should use your brain, and read the previous posts.

 

[Blindrider93]

To everyone who has been polite and helpful, I thank you. I came to this site in hopes to find information and advice. For the 78th time I KNOW THE FIREARM IS LEGAL. I haven’t decided what I’m going to do just yet. However, I’m leaning towards returning it. I think I can do better for my money. Like I said, I KNOW ITS LEGAL, it just leaves an unsettling feeling in my stomach knowing that the firearm was at one time illegally altered. Plus I believe it detracts from its cosmetic value and overall essence. Thanks again to those that were polite and helpful.