Model 52, loading RN or SWC bullets

[sjmjax]

It works!

Range test using Starline 38 S&W brass, a generic 158g LRN and 2.7g Bullseye and my well worn 52-1.

Mild shooting and in my hands actually slightly more accurate and consistent at 25 yards than my standard wadcutter load using Barry's plated 148g DEWC.

Not quite as good as my load with Zero brand HBWC. Which is very accurate but produces horrific leading. Which is why I've switched almost exclusively to Barry's plated for nearly all target loads. I'm not a competitive shooter and willing to sacrifice a bit of accuracy to avoid the nightmare of deleading the barrel after every session.

Only a couple of issues regarding failure to feed. And that was exclusively with a troublesome magazine. One that's tight even with.38 special cases. Absolutely no issues with my other magazines.

Would make this a standard practice if it weren't for brass recovery. It almost impossible to find the S&W brass in the sea of 9mm & .380 brass at our local range!

Otherwise, I'm very pleased with the results.

 

[Sevens]

I wondered about this many years ago and told myself when the day comes that I find and buy a beater 52, I will run lots of crazy bullets through it.

I still have not bought a beater 52. Maybe one day!

 

[sjmjax]

Final thoughts:

Other than with a particular magazine, I saw no functional issues.

I have noticed that the chamber on my 52-1 is "generous". An anomaly or deliberate to facilitate feeding the long straight walled 38 special cartridges.
Seems otherwise counter intuitive for a pistol designed for accuracy.

If I were to make this a more common loading for my 52 or had one with a tighter chamber, I'd consider buying some of Starlines 38 Colt short brass which is for all practical purposes the same length as the 38 S&W.

On the other hand, I wonder if the slightly snugger fitting case contributed to the good overall accuracy.

 

[Eddietruett]

First, I delight in shooting my Model 52 with HBWC bullets over WST powder. The gun is phenomenal; the shooter, not so much. I've often wondered how it would do with typical round nose or semi-wadcutter bullets. Of course, the magazine is too short to do this with .38 Special cases. It's a wadcutter gun, after all.

I thought about cutting down .38 Special cases to allow use of RN or SWC bullets and keep the required OAL. Case walls thicken toward to the base which may squeeze the bullet down too much. Then I thought of the .38 Short Colt. It looks short enough to allow seating of a "non-wadcutter" bullet within the specified .38 Special case length. .38 Short Colt loads "should" be safe in a Model 52. Whether the 52 will feed alternate bullets remains to be seen. Since it will feed wadcutters, one might think RNs or SWCs are easy-peasy. Starline conveniently makes .38 Short Colt cases.

Anybody tried this? What might I be overlooking in this (so far) thought experiment?

https://www.starlinebrass.com/38-short-colt-brass

Why?

 

[AJ]

Why?

Concur!

 

[rockquarry]

More of a stunt than anything useful. What's wrong with wadcutter bullets the gun was designed for?