More questions about revolvers for women beginners

EydieG,

I see that several other posters have replied to your question; there is a lot of advice from many people's experience. I have only fired one Ruger LCR belonging to a friend and it was very smooth.

As far as quality, Ruger is the only other American manufacturer that comes close to S&W. I'm sorry to say, Charter Arms are somewhere lower on the build quality, unless you get from the '70s (had one).

Not to belabor the point, but the weight of the revolver affects your perception of the effort required to pull the trigger and of course, absorption of recoil. So a steel revolver will feel as if it has a lighter pull.

Trigger pull is a subjective thing, we all have different hand strength and develop a different trigger finger.

As far as breaking in your revolver, back in the day we were told to go home and dry fire several hundred strokes a night.

One other thing, a poster recommended using a .22 Rimfire revolver for practice, I don't see any advantage in your situation, most .22s have heavy trigger pulls to insure reliability with the sometimes dubious quality of rimfire primers. Obviously, recoil will be less than .38.

I understand your reticence to have your gun worked on, especially if your husband likes it the way it is. An action job done properly can work wonders, but in the end, you have to try a few guns out and see if you like they way they feel. A good shop will let you try several, if they stock them. Maybe you will have to go to a few different shops to find what you are looking for. Just stick to your guns, if you want to stick with a revolver, stick with it - there are many people today who swear by the semi autos and denigrate the revolver. Nothing beats the revolver for simplicity of operation and reliability.
 
The LCR's in 38 and 357 normally have a better factory trigger than a S&W J Frame. They also have a grip that soaks up recoil better. As was said above no quality problems with a Ruger. The LCR also has a pinned on front sight that can easily be upgraded to something that you can see. (Fiber Optic, or a Night Sight)
I have had an LCR357 that I traded to get a Grail Gun that I stumbled into. , and I still have an LCR22. I use the LCR22 as my practice J Frame.

I currently have a 442 Pro Moon Clip. It seems to have a little better than average factory trigger for an air weight J Frame, but I still need to take a couple hours and slick it up, and put some Springs and Shims in it one of these days.
The 442 still suffers from a Black front sight that is hard to see. The front sight can be improved on a 442 by machining the front sight down to a post and installing an LCR Front Sight for about $100 and parts.

I guess where I am going with this, is that the LCR 38 will be more shootable out of the Box than a 442. The 442 trigger can be improved with a little work, and money however.

Do not get concerned about the Purse comment above. While not as good an option as on body carry, the revolver is way better in the purse than in a drawer at the house. Where I live we never have a purse snatched, EVER. I think this is more of a City problem.

If you could put up with the carry weight an SP101 Ruger is one Very Shootable Revolver. I have both a 2 and a 3 Inch SP101, and both have Trigger Jobs as well as the Little Wonder Fiber Optic front sights. I would bet that you could shoot my SP101's just fine. They are just too heavy to pocket carry.

Bob
 
Last edited:
You need to consider giving the 442 to your husband and find a pistol you are comfortable with. I noticed your first post contained a number of "we" when I suspect it should have been "he".

FWIW, the guns my wife owns and picked out for herself really surprise me. If you aren't comfortable with it or can't shoot it, you will not carry it. She also carries in a dedicated handgun purse. If you choose to go that way, practice your draw with an empty gun. It's way too easy to point the gun at yourself.
 
We need a photo of your cat with that gun. We haven't had one of your great cat and gun photos lately.



With my peripheral neuropathy, I've been diagnosed with profound weakness in my right hand and wrist.
I did a spring change and smoothing of the guts of my 442. The mainspring's been replaced with an 8 pound spring and the rebound's an 11 pound spring. I've never had a misfire and it's a lot easier for me to shoot.
Adding a Pachmayr Compact grip made it easier for me to hold.
 
Thanks for all of the advice. We had already decided to have my husband use the 442 and get a new one for me, I think I mentioned that. And yes, I meant We not He. We both like this style of revolver. I agree with BobR1, purse stealing around here isn't really heard of unless someone leaves it in plain sight in a car so that isn't an issue with me, just stated it so you wouldn't recommend a heaver revolver. I think we have decided on the LCR and found a place that has a good price on it so this weekend we will be checking it out.
Thanks again!
 
Gals and Guns in the Fastlane (70 at least)

Hi: I'm a 70+ year old gal and started shooting 18 months ago . . . lots of fun. A few thoughts:

- Changing the grips can make a huge difference - did for me
- The K and L frame models will be smoother to handle in my experience, a little heavier but quite sweet to shoot
- I took a 2-DAY self-defense course and lots of lessons. If I were to CCW, it would be with a semi-auto (S&W, Sig, Kimber, Ed Brown). Just the way I'd do it; revolvers are great too.
- Getting the action worked on is a great idea. It's often not the total pull weight that is the problem but the unevenness of the pull - smooth is the 1st thing I look for.

Also, after about 500 rounds and several hours of lessons, I became more confident handling my revolvers and semi-autos. Everything seems easier now, some 2,000 rounds later.

Hope this was helpful (PM me if you want),

Rachel
 
I agree that the LCR sounds like the right choice for you. Ruger makes fine, reliable American guns.

About carrying, a "Concealed Carry Purse" has a built-in holster in a separate compartment. The very best, and most expensive, are made by Coronado Leather Company.
Coronado Leather - Designing and crafting premium leather goods since 1981
One of the most popular, and affordable, brands is "Gun Totin' Mamas".
GUN TOTE'N MAMAS - Concealed Carry Handbags by Gun Tote'n Mamas

Get plenty of range time. You cannot practice too much and you and your husband may find that it is a fun "couples" outing. I know that my wife and I enjoy it immensely.

Oh and recognizing that women have a different set of sensibilities, this web site is a highly regarded "women and guns" place.
https://www.corneredcat.com/

And from one member to another, Welcome to the forum. We were all new, once.
 
Snubbyfan- I just gave my father in law that exact laser in "payment" for doing some work on my truck. He wouldn't take money, but accepted the laser for his 442.

To the original poster- the LCR is a good revolver. Ruger stands by it's products, and will repair/replace anything short of having hammer or tire marks on it.

Also, what is your manner of carrying? If it's on body, the lightweight 442 is a great gun for it's weight. If it's in a purse, go with a 2 inch model 10 or 15 in a Smith, or a SP101 in a Ruger. A little heavier, hence better for in a purse, but both will have better triggers than the 442.
 
Back
Top