most sickly 610 in america

Do you have access to a Ransom Rest? Hard to believe it's all over with factory loads out of a lightly-used 6" at a mere 20'. It hasn't been recrowned, has it? I wonder if it's a tiny bit out of time, and relying too much on the forcing cone; I don't even know if you could catch that with a chrony but the possibility would scare me out of shooting it until I got it to a 'smith.
 
I appears that the front screw that holds the rear sight in place is loose. See if that helps.

Nice gun and at half the price I paid for my 5". You did good.

Did you tighten up the rear sight before you shot it? That would probably explain the groups if you haven't. You can see the front of the sight body is raised way up in the air.:)
Ed
 
Had the sight tightened and worked the bent blade back into place after being told by 2 smiths getting any parts wont be fast. That picture was literally the minute I got it in the door from purchase so I would have the memory of it and proof that I got it at that price as i wouldnt believe it without pics. I dont have a rest but plan to get one soon ... same with a chronograph since my friend that had one I no longer see and I absolutely have to have one for working up loads. No clue on the guns past at all. I do know im not that bad though period as I picked off a rabbit with the 686 at 40-50 yards to save a broadhead recently. TR Graham and another smith both cleared the gun to shoot. If it was just left or just right, no problem because the sight blade is bent so that would be expected. Personally it feels loose for a smith but I only have 3 smith revolvers (686+ and 66-5) and only have experience with maybe a dozen that ive put more than 50 rounds through in my life. One thing I left out ... shooting offhand sent my arm almost a foot right with the recoil yet not at all left or right a minute later with the 686.

Its not getting groups, nedlate. If it was shooting 5 inches left and 2 inches down I would be quite pleased as thats just an easy cure. It is very inconsistant and that implies something (or someone) is the problem. Since I wasnt the only someone I know its not someone. When I go to the range with friends we switch up guns to compare one to the other and a fun "hell you might as well sell it to me since it seems to like my hands better". My gun isnt a wife anyways ... if you handle it properly and dont act like your in the movies I gladly let people around me enjoy my guns and some of my ammo even. I didnt adjust sights as I was just wanting to shoot it period and generally I shoot no less than twice a month so theres plenty of opportunity to get things adjusted for field use later. I dont normally go to two smiths to ask if a gun is safe to shoot though but the fact that the sight blade is bent, the cylinder release is finicky about letting go and in my opinion the whole gun just feels off for a smith revolver sent me for advice before pulling the trigger with a live round. Only the trigger feels right. I am convinced something is wrong with the yoke but im neither a gunsmith nor a guy who owns a massive collection of guns and has a lifetime of experience in anything more than the enjoyment of target shooting for fun and hunting. No question in my mind that she has hit the ground or at least some other solid object hard before reaching my hands. Because of what it is though and the price it was selling for I wasnt going to pass it up. Just like a car, it can be fixed. And this is a car you dont see often so its worth taking a risk on needing to replace an engine.

At this point its just going to get cleaned from sundays outing and im going to ask if theres any reccommendations of who to go see within 100 miles of houston who is well versed in smith revolvers that anyone here might know of. I like to be present to listen and learn as often as possible. The second smith did say in his rushed opinion (he was backed up for a month but was gladly willing to take a quick peek at an old clients gun for a safety exam) that it looked to not be the original trigger but he wasnt sure. I was more than tempted to snatch up the older model coonan in his store but I didnt have a 1500 dollar bill laying around and im not going to pay a premium for a low serial number when im a shooter, not a collector. Dont want to explain that decision to the wife less than 3 weeks later either after buying one of my 10 guns to own in life.

Ill post an updated picture of her later tonight when I have a free minute after I get back from work.
 
Polishing the front of the cylinder (and elsewhere if needed) and replacing a rear sight blade are pretty easy tasks, and moon clips are not difficult to find. Well done on the price negotiation!

Sounds like he's a good negotiator and actor to me :) Nothing particularly difficult to fix with that gun. He done good.
I'd send it to S&W as good wheel gun smiths can be hard to find, and the good ones are back logged with work. Congrats to the OP
 
I talked to smith and wesson on the way home from purchase. Looking at a 4-6 month wait time after it arrives with them. At that time I will get a written estimate of the cost to repair if they determine it needs repair according to the representative on the phone. Lets expand that ring to a revolversmith within 200 miles of houston ... austin and san antonio area even. I dont mind driving.

I have friends willing to build me a 1911 38 super from the ground up yet no one can properly smith a real smith?
 
Right at a year later it is finally resolved. The hangup was from a groove worn into the hole in the recoil shield. Alan Harton of Single Action Service happens to live 2 miles down the same major street from me!!! He told me after hearing my problem to bring it in and he could fix it in no time. I dropped it off and he called me back an hour later to come pick it up. Now the problem is a week later I just had to pick up a 625-3 that was giving me the puppy eyes behind the glass. Was not the same luck in price though.
 
Right at a year later it is finally resolved. The hangup was from a groove worn into the hole in the recoil shield. Alan Harton of Single Action Service happens to live 2 miles down the same major street from me!!! He told me after hearing my problem to bring it in and he could fix it in no time. I dropped it off and he called me back an hour later to come pick it up. Now the problem is a week later I just had to pick up a 625-3 that was giving me the puppy eyes behind the glass. Was not the same luck in price though.

Glad to hear it worked out. Speaking of Alan Harton, take a look at this 10mm he fixed up for me:
Ruger1copy.jpg

Alan even took this photo to show me what he had done with my bright stainless .40 S&W Vaquero...now it has adjustable sights, is bead blasted stainless, and is a 10mm!
 
He will be getting the nod to build a 500 linebaugh from me in the next year. And holy heck, I got to see his customer projects and personal toy collection with my wife present! Take that, hon. I do not own near enough revolvers!
 
Not knowing the history of the gun or what all has been done to it we can only guess lots of use lead to the problem developed.

I get tons of offers to buy it including a few 2 gun trades that would make anyone dump it quicker than lightning. I dont see it ever leaving my hands by my free will. A thousand revolvers might touch my fingers between each purchase. Theres a certain shop that makes it easy and knows which revolver im going to take home before I randomly show up maybe 3 times a year. Thats how the 625-3 met my hands ... 3 625s there and while I was joking with employees as I walked in, another rushed ahead and got it out for me knowing it was getting sold.
 
Back
Top