Need help. I am considering buying this.

Killian

Member
Joined
Apr 8, 2015
Messages
30
Reaction score
37
Location
New York
I could use some help with this revolver that I am considering buying. I would like to know the model and approx. value. Thanks in advance!
 

Attachments

  • 11117369_10206509747446115_613216162_n.jpg
    11117369_10206509747446115_613216162_n.jpg
    118.2 KB · Views: 998
  • 11134345_10206509748726147_365014062_n.jpg
    11134345_10206509748726147_365014062_n.jpg
    59.7 KB · Views: 773
  • 11134323_10206509748846150_1553858448_n.jpg
    11134323_10206509748846150_1553858448_n.jpg
    79.3 KB · Views: 698
  • 11115953_10206509749246160_1262027747_n.jpg
    11115953_10206509749246160_1262027747_n.jpg
    67.2 KB · Views: 730
  • 11149101_10206509747726122_316890244_n.jpg
    11149101_10206509747726122_316890244_n.jpg
    76.3 KB · Views: 636
Register to hide this ad
Looks like a 38/44 outdoorsman, A.K.A. pre model 23. It's the target version of the heavy duty. I paid $900 for one about 2 years ago.
 
Last edited:
If a 357 cartridge will fit all the way in, it has been reamed. It should stop with 1/10" left. If it has been reamed for 357 it greatly reduces the value.
 
How would I go about doing that?

Try dropping in a .357 cartridge. If that makes you or anyone else nervous, a fired .357 case can work but may be a little more of a snug fit since it's been expanded when it was fired. Or use a .357 snap cap, if available. Having been reamed to .357 wouldn't affect the gun's ability to shoot .38 Special, but detracts from its collector value.

Note that the stocks on the gun are not factory. They have a Sanderson's look to them (to me) but I am far from any kind of judge on that. Non-factory stocks is another detraction to collector value, although a bonus in my eyes since I consider most factory stocks uncomfortable.

Also, the number on the frame in the crane area doesn't mean anything, it was used only during manufacture. The actual serial number on this S&W is on the butt, underneath the stocks. The number stamped on the barrel should match, (and is probably also on the rear face of the cylinder) but cannot be relied on as the official serial number as barrels can be replaced.

This is a pretty good looking specimen - the $900 quoted above is not out of line.
 
Last edited:
If a 357 cartridge will fit all the way in, it has been reamed. It should stop with 1/10" left. If it has been reamed for 357 it greatly reduces the value.

Ok that makes sense and seems simple. The asking price is $350.
 
I certainly would not put a loaded cartridge in it. That could make the seller very very nervous! :eek:

Most gun shops would give you a new, empty .357 case (often called a shell) or at worst, one that has been fired. Either one should fit ok if it has been reamed for .357.

However, that deal is sooooo good, it is almost like looking a gift horse in the mouth! Just buy the durn thing!
 
Back
Top