New here, studying for 1st revolver

[beagleye]

I have decided to get a handgun. It all started at the range, a nice gentleman let me shoot his python. I have had a couple of handguns, both were frustratingly inaccurate. My experience with the python was an eye opener.

I like durable and historical guns (have C&R, nice collection of historical mausers). I detest cheap crap. I shoot for accuracy and would like a gun that can for some time shoot better than me. I tinker with guns and would like to be able to eventually make basic improvements or repairs on any gun I have. I like guns that serve a good purpose: in my case that would probably be hunting deer, varmints and personal defense for me and my family. i ain't rich, probably looking a 5 bills or less.

I am probably headed for a 38 spcl. or 357. I have been looking with some interest at the 5 screw M&Ps. Also colt troopers. I would also considered a 1911 although the RI are probably the only ones in my budget range and I am not confident about being able to get a satisfying level of accuracy. I'm looking for advice. Open to other directions.

Thanks, Pete

 

[murphydog]

Hi, and welcome. Given your stated criteria (price and uses), I think your best bets would be a blue or stainless K or L frame .357 with a 6" barrel. Assuming you will not use it for concealed carry, the extra barrel length will serve you well for target and game. The model 19 or 586 (blue) and 66/686 (stainless) are hard to beat for all-around use and can use .38 Specials and .357s. Nice examples are well within your budget.

Please post a photo when you make your decision, whatever it may be, and happy shopping!

 

[DCWilson]

Welcome, Beagleye. Alan gave you some good suggestions. I'll just mention in addition that the K-38 Masterpiece, which is essentially the adjustable-sight version of the classic M&P in .38 Special, is another good choice. Lots were made between 1947 and 1957, when it became known as the Model 14 in the S&W catalog. Excellent target revolver, completely satisfactory for home defense, and if you can get close to your quarry and know what you're doing, probably good enough for a deer, too -- but a .357 would be better for that. The K-38 came with a six inch barrel, but there is also a four-inch version called the Combat Masterpiece that is equally accurate and somewhat more convenient for a couple of your purposes.

Yes, we want to see photos when you decide on one and acquire it!

 

[bamabiker]

Welcome to the forum. I don't know if you want an old gun since your thread is in this section but if you could use a newer gun you might take a look in the forum classifieds. There is a M19, a M28 and a M686 for sale on the first page. All good revolvers.

 

[beagleye]

... I don't know if you want an old gun...

I do favor old guns cause generally they seem to be better. At least you seem to get more quality for a dollar amount. But I don't know that much about revolvers, maybe it's a different equation than with hunting rifles. I will check those guns out and thanks so far for the advice and tips, all you helpful people.

Pete

 

[Jack Flash]

I think the advice given above about getting a K-38 Masterpiece (M14 is the later version) is great...

... EXCEPT for the requirement for hunting deer.

The idea of having one revolver that can do all your requirements is very tough to fill. Before you do anything else, check your local hunting laws / regulations. It may not even be legal to hunt with a .38 Special in your locale.

Personally, I would suggest you get a separate gun (for me, preferably a rifle or shotgun) for hunting deer. Again, check your local regs. Some areas are shotgun (slug) only.

If you really insist on one handgun that does it all, you may want to read up on the Model 57 (.41 Magnum) and the Model 29 (.44 Magnum).

 

[Gary7]

I shoot for accuracy and would like a gun that can for some time shoot better than me. ... I like guns that serve a good purpose: in my case that would probably be hunting deer ...

Me, too. What you need is a Model 27 or 28 with at least a six inch barrel.

 

[long colt frazier]

Welcome Beagleye.
Given the 500.00 price I would think a nice 28 or shooter grade 27.

 

[m37dodge]

Welcome, I agree with many here but would guide you to a 686 4" barrel model.
I have carried one for years, they are accurate, easy to shoot and master to a level of extreme proficiency. You can shoot 38 wadcutters for practice and play, then upgrade to 357 defense loads for hunting or personal protection, with the same weapon. No matter what model you finally chose, make it a Smith, you will never be sorry.

 

[Battletech58]

Welcome to the hobby (or addiction-LOL ) of gun collecting. As stated above no one gun can answer all of your needs/wants but just the search will prove to be a lot of fun. My second S&W I traded for while inexpensive is fun to shoot. A .38 Victory model from 1943 that I enjoy shooting for just its historical significance alone.