New Model 10 versus Model 15

[ral2531]

I'm tempted to buy one of these "new classics", since I really enjoy shooting 38 Special from revolvers. (Have done so using a 686 for many years.) I'd rather not begin the long/expensive search for older, legacy versions of these models.

Any thoughts on the difference between these two new classics, aside from the lack of adjustable rear sight on the 10, and the slightly different grips? Thanks.

 

[GerSan69]

Nothing "long" about it... there are several readily-available sources for used Model 10, 64, and 67(stainless version of the 15)... most are cheaper than brand-new: J&G Sales, Bud's, and Robertson Trading Post immediately come to mind. Also, there is a ton of info on this site about K-frame .38's answering your questions from every angle.

 

[kennyb]

nothing wrong with the new ones (although pricey) the originals for the M10 and m15 are both very easy to find and you will save $$
welcome to the forum!

 

[Roadranger]

The new Classic M15 is really a M19 in 38 Special. Original M15's never had shrouded ejector rods. The Classic M15 comes with really nice target stocks and is just a nice shooter. Since S&W are not going to make any more K frame magnums, they just turned the M19 into the M15. Bob!

 

[bpeddicord]

I own several model 10s and 15s. I really love the model 10s more than any of my other K frame guns. They are extremely eye pleasing and every model 10 I own shoots perfectly to point of aim with 158 grain bullets. You don't have to worry about knocking the sights out of alignment if you bump into a door frame or, heaven forbid, drop it. With a cylinder full of Remington 158 grain SWCHP ammo and three speedloaders loaded with the same, I feel very well armed. I also own several model 64s and they are great shooters, but the model 10s just look better to me.

 

[stantheman86]

Yes, you can get an older Model 15 for $400 or so, they tend to run higher than 10's since many people want the adjustable sights. The new Model 15, like was said is a .38 Special model 19........if S&W would make them into "real" 19's in .357 they would sell a ton of them. If they are made to the same specs as the most recent Model 66's, than that should make for a very durable .38 Special revolver.

If you buy new, you also get the S&W warranty coverage in the event the gun needs service.

 

[nipster]

I like the look of the shrouded ejector rod, but it's $300-400 more than I can get a used one, and I dont like the lock and MIM parts, so I wouldnt buy one. That's just me

 

[pennlineman]

I like the older pre lock versions myself. Used model 10's are not hard to find at all. They started making them over a 100 years ago so there are plenty of them out there. I like the model 15 too, you might have to look a little harder to find one but they are out there.

My model 10's, the oldest being th 6 1/2" barrel one made in 1924.

 

[ral2531]

Okay thanks guys. Regarding the new M15, does anyone know if it is constructed similar to an older M15 (e.g. 15-3 or 15-4). I ask because I've read about some potential problems with barrels on current production 67 guns (the SS version) and was wondering if this might apply to the current 15 as well.

 

[nipster]

Okay thanks guys. Regarding the new M15, does anyone know if it is constructed similar to an older M15 (e.g. 15-3 or 15-4). I ask because I've read about some potential problems with barrels on current production 67 guns (the SS version) and was wondering if this might apply to the current 15 as well.

They completely redesigned the K frame in 1999, including barrels (2 piece barrels). They are really not the same as the ones made back up through the early 90's.

 

[M3Stuart]

Okay thanks guys. Regarding the new M15, does anyone know if it is constructed similar to an older M15 (e.g. 15-3 or 15-4). I ask because I've read about some potential problems with barrels on current production 67 guns (the SS version) and was wondering if this might apply to the current 15 as well.

Welcome to the forum!

Short answer; NO. The new ones have many differences. Keep searching on these boards and you'll become an expert on all of these differences between new and old. Educate yourself and be sure to check your new, or used, gun thoroughly before buying it.

I know people who only buy new guns and others that only by older Smiths. Both are fine. Don't be afraid to buy a new one, it will last you a lifetime, and your kids' lifetime, and their kids, etc, etc... - as will the older models.