Sounds like your experience is very similar to mine. I tried another hybrid IWB with even worse results and gave up on hybrids. I've had good luck with Remora, Kusiak, and Lobo Gun Leather IWB. They are quite different from Old Faithful.I gotta say, Old Faithful is one class act.
I've been wearing this holster for a while now and it's just not working. It's fine when standing, but when I sit it's quite uncomfortable. I'm not bashing the holster, just that I think IWB is not for me.