Removing scratches

UKWildcatFan

Member
Joined
Jun 25, 2020
Messages
46
Reaction score
79
Location
St. Charles, Missouri
Hello, I picked up a really nice 19–3 last weekend at my LGS. It’s blued, and is in good shape but if possible I’d like to try to buff out some scratches. What do y’all use/do?
Thanks.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
Register to hide this ad
You have to be Very Careful ... a buffing wheel can buff out the Blued finish easily ...
Scratches can be too deep to buff out .
My advice is use the hand and a very very fine polishing compound to see if you can clean up some of the surface ... Blueing is not very thick or hard so ... go slowly .

Post some good photo's for more better advice ...
Let's see what cha got .
Gary
 
Last edited:
You don't "buff out" scratches on a blued gun. Bluing is not a coating like paint, it is the actual surface of the steel that has been chemically treated to produce a surface that is Iron oxide, literally fancy rust! There is no thickness to it, it would be measured in microns if measurable at all. What the result would be is removal of the blued finish leaving bare metal.


If the marks bother you enough then re-finishing/re-bluing is the answer. Either that or have it plated in one of several Chromium/Nickel finishes or painted with Cera-Cote or one of the other synthetic finishes
 
You have to be Very Careful ... a buffing wheel can buff out the Blued finish easily ...
Scratches can be too deep to buff out .
My advice is use the hand and a very very fine polishing compound to see if you can clean up some of the surface ... Blueing is not very thick or hard so ... go slowly .

Post some good photo's for more better advice ...
Let's see what cha got .
Gary


47e59a5b6127ad363d8a34bbc61c63b0.jpg

0bae3e506d7eceb49cfb91e5bf896887.jpg

38b6ec734aea88df7932297a4303ba4d.jpg

fd3b0028c820a03dfdc57df1ba1e1dbd.jpg



Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
You have to be Very Careful ... a buffing wheel can buff out the Blued finish easily ...
Scratches can be too deep to buff out .
My advice is use the hand and a very very fine polishing compound to see if you can clean up some of the surface ... Blueing is not very thick or hard so ... go slowly .

Post some good photo's for more better advice ...
Let's see what cha got .
Gary


Maybe a tiny speck of Mothers, very lightly in a circular motion?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
I wouldn’t worry about it. Hit it lightly with some steel wool and a little Hoppe’s and call it good.
You can file or sand down damaged screw heads while you are at it.
 
Maybe a tiny speck of Mothers, very lightly in a circular motion?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Yes ... Very Lightly in a circular motion , by hand ...
Then a protective Wax Job .

It's better to under-do polishing on a finely blued revolver like yours than to over-do it .

Stay away from Steel Wool ... copper wool from Brownell's is safer ... I have emoved blue with steel wool when I didn't mean to ... it acts fast !
Gary
 
Mothers, Fitz and the like are rubbing compounds with very fine abrasives. They will remove blue, they will not fill the scratches with blue. Gun blue is a hard form of iron oxide and is only about .0001 thick. Notice that even a leather holster will wear it away when rubbed against the muzzle or front of cylinder. DON'T use polish on it expecting it to remove scratches. Light haze, etc maybe, but any goo, paint hardened oil wax etc is better removed with a solvent.
 
Last edited:
To OP, you have a beautiful gun that has acquired handling marks from usage & just general wear & tear. It is a 50 year old gun afterall. You were given good advice, the most you would want to do is apply a light coating of wax which will minimize those marks.
However if those marks will always bother you or your eye will always be drawn to those "scratches" I suggest that you just sell this gun and shop for a finer condition gun. Some guys are that way, they have to have things in a perfect condition. I'm Not knocking you for that, But there are alternatives and this may be the solution for you.
So before you end up doing more harm than good trying to mask those blemishes give this some thought. In any event Good Luck in whatever you decide to do. Your gun, your choice.
 
Back
Top