Ruger #1 in 458 Lott makes an impression, too.My little Ruger #3 in 45/70 will get everyone else's attention.
\\Mine is a Ruger No.1 in 45-70 with a max load. Such a small light rifle can really rattle you.
My vote goes to my 91/59 Nagant Carbine. When I fire it at the range, a fireball the size of a bowling ball erupts from the muzzle...children scream and women swoon....okay, not really...but the next guy over says..."***"? Two magazines of 7.62x54 and my shoulder has had enough....
I once had a Remington "Zouave" replica (like this)
![]()
.58 cal 500grains pure lead in front of 100+grains of blackpowder
Not much when standing.... but lie down and it was a sholder breaker.
My vote goes to my 91/59 Nagant Carbine. When I fire it at the range, a fireball the size of a bowling ball erupts from the muzzle...children scream and women swoon....okay, not really...but the next guy over says..."***"? Two magazines of 7.62x54 and my shoulder has had enough....
Marlin guide gun loaded with Buffalo Bore 500 grain solids. That little sucker kills on both ends!
I had a Winchester Model 88 in .308 Win. I shot three rounds from a standing position at the range before I traded it for a 12 gauge Winchester Model 94 that was mild on comparison.
Do you realize that 100 grains of FFg or FFFg is about a proof load in a Zouave repo? The service load of the 1860s was 60 grains of musket powder (FFg) behind the 460 grain Burton (Minie) bullet. My first black powder rifle was a Navy Arms Zoli Zouave and too much powder would kick. My usual North-South Skirmish Association target load was 45-48 grains of FFFg under a 525 grain Lyman Minie.
The big mistake that folks make when shooting from the bench is that they almost lay prone and put the butt on an area of the body that has little padding and no give.
Elmer Keith had the best solution. His bench rest position was a sitting position so that the upper body could help absorb the recoil.