S&W MP40 shield. Slide stop issue

[Rastoff]

That just says that "releasing the slide from the slide stop" causes the slide to move forward. It does not recommend using the "slide stop lever" to release the slide.

Page 17 of the same manual states:

• To make sure that the magazine is fully and securely inserted,
apply some removal pressure to the exposed portion of the
magazine floorplate.
• Pull the slide to the rear and release it, allowing it to carry fully
forward. This strips a cartridge from the magazine and seats it
in the chamber of the barrel.

You're funny. Using your own logic, the statement you posted doesn't mean that pulling the slide is the only way it can be done. It simply states that pulling the slide to the rear will strip off a round and make the gun ready to fire. It doesn't say that pressing the slide stop is wrong.


Haliwa04,
The slide stop should not rust like that. Call S&W and they will probably send you a new one. It should have the same Melonite treatment as the slide.

Water based oil? Man, you guys are off your meds. You can't have a water based oil. Further, that particular oil is intended as a protector. Putting water in it would eliminate any ability as a protector.

 

[Haliwa04]

You're funny. Using your own logic, the statement you posted doesn't mean that pulling the slide is the only way it can be done. It simply states that pulling the slide to the rear will strip off a round and make the gun ready to fire. It doesn't say that pressing the slide stop is wrong.


Haliwa04,
The slide stop should not rust like that. Call S&W and they will probably send you a new one. It should have the same Melonite treatment as the slide.

Water based oil? Man, you guys are off your meds. You can't have a water based oil. Further, that particular oil is intended as a protector. Putting water in it would eliminate any ability as a protector.

E-Mail sent last night. Will call in a couple days if I don't get a response. I had a bad experience with s&w customer service. But that was back in January and was handled by a crappy local gunsmith that broke the gun and sent it off without permission. But, I'm going to give them another shot, hopefully it was an isolated incident, and the guy I dealt with was fired for breaking protocol(offered to ship a revolver to my doorstep, no ffl). I'm going to use the search feature to see what everyone uses for lube. Thanks guys.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

 

[Rastoff]

A guy from S&W offered to ship you a different gun without going through an FFL? Wow! If S&W knew about it I can't imagine they wouldn't fire the guy. That could get the whole company in hot water with the BATFE.


Hmmm, that gets me wondering. A repair shop can ship a gun back to its owner after repair. I wonder if they can do the same with a new gun if the old one wasn't repairable. I don't think they can, but I feel a new thread coming on...

 

[Haliwa04]

A guy from S&W offered to ship you a different gun without going through an FFL? Wow! If S&W knew about it I can't imagine they wouldn't fire the guy. That could get the whole company in hot water with the BATFE.

No, same gun. It was shipped from the gunsmith to s&w, and it was there for 3 months. The guy said the gun was ready, and they would overnight it to my house. Two weeks later, nothing. So I called again, and the woman got a manager on the phone and I explained what happened. The gun hadn't even been looked at, I was advised that them shipping to me directly would be against the law, and they pulled the gunshops ffl stays with s&w for breaking my gun and sending to them without my permission.


Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

 

[Rastoff]

No, same gun. It was shipped from the gunsmith to s&w, and it was there for 3 months. The guy said the gun was ready, and they would overnight it to my house. Two weeks later, nothing. So I called again, and the woman got a manager on the phone and I explained what happened. The gun hadn't even been looked at, I was advised that them shipping to me directly would be against the law, and they pulled the gunshops ffl stays with s&w for breaking my gun and sending to them without my permission.


Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

Oh, that's different. It's completely legal for them to ship you your own gun back. It doesn't matter that it was the gun smith that sent it to them. As long as you can prove ownership, they can ship it to your door.

The issue comes when there is a change in ownership. That was not your situation.

 

[Haliwa04]

Oh, that's different. It's completely legal for them to ship you your own gun back. It doesn't matter that it was the gun smith that sent it to them. As long as you can prove ownership, they can ship it to your door.

The issue comes when there is a change in ownership. That was not your situation.

Oh, OK. They still made a huge fuss about it and it went back to the gunsmith and the gun shop. They tried to act like they didn't have it when I went to get it. Had it scooted back behind a counter. It was a 642 airweight prelock. I only paid $300 ($200 of that my friend owed me). I didn't understand the big deal until the guy I deal with told me they hadn't been able to keep on in the case. The last one I saw in there, they wanted $550 for used, and I do mean used.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

 

[Rastoff]

I trust you've found a different gunsmith?

I've had nothing but good dealings with S&W customer service. They've always paid for shipping and worked quickly. I hope things go better this time for you.

 

[Jyezahn]

That just says that "releasing the slide from the slide stop" causes the slide to move forward. It does not recommend using the "slide stop lever" to release the slide.

An absence of recommendation, does not constitute a non-recommendation, nor a non-intention.

So, with this warning in mind:

WARNING: UPON FIRING THE PISTOL OR RELEASING
THE SLIDE FROM THE SLIDE STOP, THE SLIDE MOVES
REARWARD OR FORWARD WITH SIGNIFICANT FORCE
AND SPEED. TO AVOID INJURY, BE SURE NO PART OF YOUR
BODY IS IN THE PATH OF THE SLIDE'S TRAVEL.

What part of your body would get caught in the slide if you're pulling the slide back with your other hand and letting it go? The way the warning is written, (presumably, though I could be wrong) it addresses making sure your fingers are clear of the ejection port when pulling down on the slide stop. Otherwise, why waste the verbage, "or releasing the slide from the slide stop", and instead write, "or chambering a round". Point is, S&W does not specifically deem the slide stop to be only a stop, and not a release in anything that I've read from them. You said you've seen it... I just want to know where?

 

[Haliwa04]

I trust you've found a different gunsmith?

I've had nothing but good dealings with S&W customer service. They've always paid for shipping and worked quickly. I hope things go better this time for you.

Yep, myself. I've taught myself to either not break it, or if I do break it, know how to fix it. Several books and long nights of detail stripping, cleaning, polishing, etc and I can take apart most handguns and some long guns apart to the itty bitties no problem. I now know to never ever ever take the side plate off of a revolver unless I have to. I also bought, built, refinished, and sold a Norinco 1911 just to get that under the belt. I trust s&w will handle this situation a lot better since the panic is dying down and I actually own a couple of their newer firearms.

Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using Tapatalk 2

 

[Rastoff]

Point is, S&W does not specifically deem the slide stop to be only a stop, and not a release in anything that I've read from them. You said you've seen it... I just want to know where?

It's the note on page 17 that he and everyone else is refering to. He quoted it previously. The claim is because S&W said to pull back on the slide to chamber the first round, that means we shouldn't use the slide stop to release the slide.

It's not true, but that's the claim.

 

[Jyezahn]

It's the note on page 17 that he and everyone else is refering to. He quoted it previously. The claim is because S&W said to pull back on the slide to chamber the first round, that means we shouldn't use the slide stop to release the slide.

It's not true, but that's the claim.

I read that, but we all know that's not all inclusive. Same could be said for those of us who do not use the sear deactivation lever to field strip, and pull the trigger instead.

Let's not forget these two warnings on pg 22:

WARNING: DO NOT ALTER, MODIFY OR REPLACE
ANY OF THE PARTS OF YOUR FIREARM UNLESS
THIS WORK IS PERFORMED BY A QUALIFIED GUNSMITH USING GENUINE SMITH & WESSON PARTS. IF YOU
DO OTHERWISE, IMPROPER FUNCTIONING MAY OCCUR
AND SERIOUS INJURY MAY RESULT.
WARNING: NEVER DISASSEMBLE YOUR HANDGUN
BEYOND THE FIELD STRIPPING PROCESS OUTLINED IN THIS MANUAL. NEVER MANIPULATE ANY
INTERNAL COMPONENTS BEYOND WHAT YOU ARE
SPECIFICALLY INSTRUCTED TO DO IN THIS MANUAL
SINCE THIS MAY AFFECT THE RELIABILITY, FUNCTIONING
AND SAFETY OF YOUR HANDGUN.

S&W specifies these two things because it could affect the way the gun was INTENDED to function. Nowhere does S&W specify that the slide lock SHOULDN'T be used to release the slide, yet in my first post, it can be said that they DID address it's use in the release of the slide.

Neither here, nor there, not a big deal, but one would also question the texture of the upper part of the slide lock lever, if it was meant by S&W to NOT be used to release.

Each to their own, I guess.

 

[Rastoff]

I completely agree with you. I was just telling you where he got the idea from.