Never had one, but also thinking a quarter would surely be too big!
Then again, I don't have a clue as to how big a quarter was back in the day------just that it was worth more than it is now!
Ralph Tremaine
Ralph, quarters then were the same size physically as the ones made today. A Seated Liberty Quarter would make sense because they were made between 1838 and 1891, so the dates fit.
The cool factor is pretty high for me.