SD9VE vs 910
- Thread starter marc417
- Start date
Register to hide this ad
Striker fired plastic glock clones are a non-starter for me so 910 it is. But, in all actuality I'd really rather have a .45
I have the 910 and love it. VERY accurate and reliable , plus it will accept the 15 magazine.....plus just as my preference I like a metal frame , with a hammer. Also a big thing for me is how it feels. If its just not comfortable in my hand , why have it.
Last edited:
This will be used mainly for home defense and may be carried concealed some.. The 910 has an out the door price of $300 and the SD9VE OUT THE DOOR AT $340. I was also considereing the Taurus PT111 due to size and ability to conceal. Taurus new at $340-350. Would the age of the 910 slow you from getting it
The 910 is, in my opinion, superior in accuracy, reliability, trigger, construction and looks to all the other pistols you mentioned. $300 makes it a value as well.
If you don't care for the 910 after owning it, you will be able to recoup your investment in the classifieds here. With the other guns you mentioned? Not so much.
Buy it, shoot it, love it. Good luck! Regards 18DAI
If you don't care for the 910 after owning it, you will be able to recoup your investment in the classifieds here. With the other guns you mentioned? Not so much.
Buy it, shoot it, love it. Good luck! Regards 18DAI
910 only because a 915 isn't a choice...........
I never have been able to like striker fired guns. If you are a new shooter or new to autos....I feel (IMHO) that one is "less likely" to have a ND with a traditional DA/SA exposed hammer gun.
FYI The 910 will take any of the 5900 series mags or Mec-gar 15&17 rd mag.
also you can use any of the 5900 series grips
I never have been able to like striker fired guns. If you are a new shooter or new to autos....I feel (IMHO) that one is "less likely" to have a ND with a traditional DA/SA exposed hammer gun.
FYI The 910 will take any of the 5900 series mags or Mec-gar 15&17 rd mag.
also you can use any of the 5900 series grips
Last edited:
A holster can add $5 - 100+ to the value.......depends on the holster.
I picked up a "carried a lot shot very little".... 915 w/ "character" last month w/ 2 15 rd mags for $325......( I wanted a rough use/ utility gun ) Note: I think most here would rank a 915 a bit higher than a 910...... couple of extra metal parts.... including rear sight and most 910s (94-04)shipped w/ 10 rd mag. durning the last ban.
So ya $300 seems OK/good to me.... in this market.
I picked up a "carried a lot shot very little".... 915 w/ "character" last month w/ 2 15 rd mags for $325......( I wanted a rough use/ utility gun ) Note: I think most here would rank a 915 a bit higher than a 910...... couple of extra metal parts.... including rear sight and most 910s (94-04)shipped w/ 10 rd mag. durning the last ban.
So ya $300 seems OK/good to me.... in this market.
Last edited:
KarmannGhia
Member
50% of the guys around you are WRONG. Get the 910. 
ND = negligent discharge
ND = negligent discharge
FWIW and it's not worth much.........I'm an old foggie..... and years ago use to be an NRA instructor..... if this is a first handgun.......have you thought about a revolver?
Just asking
Of the 2 I would still recomend the 910 DA/SA for a "bit" of added safty
Just asking
Of the 2 I would still recomend the 910 DA/SA for a "bit" of added safty
Around here, the S&W 2nd & 3rd generation guns sell for more than that, unless they are in really bad shape. $300 with magazines and a holster seems like a very fair price, especially if it's not in bad condition. Are you buying it from an individual or a gun shop? Any idea of round count, etc?
The SD9VE is a good, basic pistol, and they are current production...I bought one a little while back for $299 at Academy Sports. I'd buy the 910 since you don't come across those very often at that price, and then get a SD9VE later if you wanted one.
One thing the SD9VE does have going for it, or a couple of things, is that if you buy it new, you'll have a warranty, plus it is easier to field strip than a 910...not that a 910 is hard for basic field strip, but if you want to get the firing pin out and clean out the channel often, which I like to do, it's easier on the SD9. On the other hand, some people never do that, so it's not a major deal.
As for a Taurus...no way, no how. I've had bad luck with their products. Poor quality, poor service, and no trade/resale value.
The SD9VE is a good, basic pistol, and they are current production...I bought one a little while back for $299 at Academy Sports. I'd buy the 910 since you don't come across those very often at that price, and then get a SD9VE later if you wanted one.
One thing the SD9VE does have going for it, or a couple of things, is that if you buy it new, you'll have a warranty, plus it is easier to field strip than a 910...not that a 910 is hard for basic field strip, but if you want to get the firing pin out and clean out the channel often, which I like to do, it's easier on the SD9. On the other hand, some people never do that, so it's not a major deal.
As for a Taurus...no way, no how. I've had bad luck with their products. Poor quality, poor service, and no trade/resale value.
A revolver is often recommended for new shooters because it is simpler to operate, and not prone to shooter induced malfunctions like "limp-wristing" (failing to maintain a sufficient grip on the gun to enable cycling under recoil.) A revolver is also not usually ammo sensitive, and doesn't often have malfunctions (like failure to feed, stove pipe, etc) that a new shooter would have to clear. If a round fails to fire, usually you can just pull the trigger again and advance to the next round (on a DA revolver, anyway.) A revolver will allow a new shooter to concentrate on getting used to shooting (recoil management, aiming, etc) rather than managing the gun.
On the other hand, if a revolver does have a malfunction, it's not always something that can be cleared easily or in the field. A revolver usually has lower capacity, and may be heavier or more difficult to conceal for carry.
You might want to consider going to a range that rents handguns, and shoot both types, and see which one you enjoy most before you buy.
There are pros and cons to both..........
I think most/many think revolvers are "simplier"...... for a beginner shooter....
it's easier to check the load/unloaded statis just by swinging out the cylinder.
you can load/unload without worrying about creating an "over pressure load.
Revolver lets you learn both a single and double action trigger pull (trick ; have someone load a mix of live rounds and cases to self evaluate your trigger squeeze......)
no issue of "limp wristing' a revolver
no failure to eject/ jam..... clearance drills to learn.......
point and shoot at self defence ranges.......no safeties to worry about
one can shoot light loads as early practice rounds and work up to full power......... think .38 target loads to .357 mag in a model 19/66.
bad round/misfire ....... just pull the trigger again........
no problem with the wife/ GF being able to work the slide.... Note: this that could be a good thing....depends on your fidelity.....LOL
Autos also have a lot going for them............
Chime in guys ....... opinions welcome
Edit for GCK comment: 1. weight is not always a bad thing as it helps w/ recoil control........ but is offset somewhat in an every day carry gun.
2. Good point if you can shoot both...........do so!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I think most/many think revolvers are "simplier"...... for a beginner shooter....
it's easier to check the load/unloaded statis just by swinging out the cylinder.
you can load/unload without worrying about creating an "over pressure load.
Revolver lets you learn both a single and double action trigger pull (trick ; have someone load a mix of live rounds and cases to self evaluate your trigger squeeze......)
no issue of "limp wristing' a revolver
no failure to eject/ jam..... clearance drills to learn.......
point and shoot at self defence ranges.......no safeties to worry about
one can shoot light loads as early practice rounds and work up to full power......... think .38 target loads to .357 mag in a model 19/66.
bad round/misfire ....... just pull the trigger again........
no problem with the wife/ GF being able to work the slide.... Note: this that could be a good thing....depends on your fidelity.....LOL
Autos also have a lot going for them............
Chime in guys ....... opinions welcome
Edit for GCK comment: 1. weight is not always a bad thing as it helps w/ recoil control........ but is offset somewhat in an every day carry gun.
2. Good point if you can shoot both...........do so!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Last edited:
Im buying this from a guy I know personally. He bought the 910 new and states approx 200 rounds have been shot through it and pretty much looks like the day he bought it. He also states it has shot flawlessly for him.
Personally I like the thoughts better of having a semi vs a revolver. No specific reasons though.
Personally I like the thoughts better of having a semi vs a revolver. No specific reasons though.
