IMO there's lots of good JHP's out there for self defense in the .45 acp and any of the offerings by the major manufacturers will do fine with no real measurable difference. I have Remington Golden Saber 230gr, Mag Tec 230gr and 185gr JHP +P, Win Ranger SXT 230gr, CCI Gold Dots 230gr and 200gr, Federal HST and Hydrashok 230gr and a single box of Starfire 230gr JHP's. Have carried and loaded each at various times and have always felt well armed.
I've picked up this variety as its come on sale or when found for a good price over the years.