bananaman
Member
How often do you see them up for sale? I rarely do. Not looking really hard though. I would be very tempted at that price. Did you try price negotiation? Let us know how you make out. Bob
Should I take the plunge on this Model 57???
- Thread starter Duckfood
- Start date
@Duckfood,
Considering the condition, and how the market appears in my area, if I were looking for another 57, I would jump on it without a second thought. Right after my first shooting session with my 57, I went looking for a pair of Pachmyers. I don't feel that they detract from the value of the revolver, but add to the utility. The physical condition is not really all that bad, in my opinion.
The only way that I would not make the purchase is if I were looking for a collectable to hide in my safe, but that is not me. I purchase handguns to fill a specific shooting niche.
Considering the condition, and how the market appears in my area, if I were looking for another 57, I would jump on it without a second thought. Right after my first shooting session with my 57, I went looking for a pair of Pachmyers. I don't feel that they detract from the value of the revolver, but add to the utility. The physical condition is not really all that bad, in my opinion.
The only way that I would not make the purchase is if I were looking for a collectable to hide in my safe, but that is not me. I purchase handguns to fill a specific shooting niche.
Unless there is something mechanically wrong with it that I can't see, I'd be all over that one.
simmitt
Member
41 for 600.00 cash. 41 here in Louisiana is in the 1000.00 range. I would buy it. Stocks will pop up as fast. or just post here.
Sugar River
Member
I would insist on seeing the metal condition under the Pachmayrs. Rust and rubber seem to like each other.
Jump on it. That is a super price around here. If You don't like it PM Me and we'll talk.
S.B.
Member
- Joined
- Feb 7, 2003
- Messages
- 1,617
- Reaction score
- 725
I don't know what part of the country you're from but, I haven't seen a S prefixed model 57 priced at $480 in my part of the country in several decades. Some think every N frame with diamond serice grips are all the current rage but, not correct for this pistol?
Steve
BigBill
Absent Comrade
A little polish will fix the fading blue. It would be in my safe growing roots already. With some S&W wood you could maybe double the price if she cleans up good.
The prices on the n frames in any barrel length is going out of sight it's silly. Repeat any n frame that's under $1,000 was once a buy now it's a steal considering the condition of the finish. The shooter, beaters are still drawing good cash. Yours is no shooter, beater.
The prices on the n frames in any barrel length is going out of sight it's silly. Repeat any n frame that's under $1,000 was once a buy now it's a steal considering the condition of the finish. The shooter, beaters are still drawing good cash. Yours is no shooter, beater.
Last edited:
Careful following that advice. You don't want to do it too often.
There was a recent thread about the dangers of buying for resale and the potential to be considered a "dealer" by the BATF
Just sayin....
charlie sherrill
Member
I'd pay that and then shoot a bunch of rounds through it. I'm kinda fond of .41 mags and have several.
I have been looking for a shooter grade 57 for a long time now. My experience has been 57's come in two flavors when for sale. Near mint or beat up. But always at a premium price.
If I was not stuck on 4" guns that one would be in my safe already. At that price, I would be tempted to try the longer tube. I could always get my money back and more if it didn't suit me.
If I was not stuck on 4" guns that one would be in my safe already. At that price, I would be tempted to try the longer tube. I could always get my money back and more if it didn't suit me.
Long overdue update...
After initially passing on this gun, someone put the gun in layaway, made a few payments, and then stopped... The shop defaulted of the plan, and was putting back on the wall for sale... A buddy at the shop texted me saying that it was available again, and wanted to know if I was interested... I ended up putting in layaway for a couple of months and picked it up this past weekend... I haven't had the opportunity to shoot it yet...
After initially passing on this gun, someone put the gun in layaway, made a few payments, and then stopped... The shop defaulted of the plan, and was putting back on the wall for sale... A buddy at the shop texted me saying that it was available again, and wanted to know if I was interested... I ended up putting in layaway for a couple of months and picked it up this past weekend... I haven't had the opportunity to shoot it yet...
Attachments
@Duckfood,
Personally, I think that you made the right move. Just because it is marked Magnum, doesn't mean that it has to live on a steady diet of Magnums. I put together a nice handload with a hardcast Lyman 210gr SWC over a light but safe load of 231, and it shoots just like a K38. Keep in mind, you will never lose out on the deal, you can always sell it and turn a profit if you don't like it!
Personally, I think that you made the right move. Just because it is marked Magnum, doesn't mean that it has to live on a steady diet of Magnums. I put together a nice handload with a hardcast Lyman 210gr SWC over a light but safe load of 231, and it shoots just like a K38. Keep in mind, you will never lose out on the deal, you can always sell it and turn a profit if you don't like it!
C Broad Arrow
Member
You won't regret the purchase!
One of the most under-rated calibers and a pleasure to shoot!
One of the most under-rated calibers and a pleasure to shoot!
If you don't reload, I suggest LAX for ammo. I don't remember the specs on their house brand but this old gal can shoot it just fine.
The Model 57 is a great gun.
The Model 57 is a great gun.
Shooter6br
Member
Have a 657 6in I bought new in 1986 no dash. Best trigger I have seen. My 25-2 comes close.
Out here Cabelas would pay $750 for that and list it at $1199. I could get that one at a gun show for around $900 maybe. Glad You jumped on it. Great purchase. Like others have said, if You don't like it post it for sale here and make a profit.
I'd say you must live a charmed life. You passed on it and ended up with it anyway... ? 
Put an extra $5 in the collection plate next time it comes by.
Put an extra $5 in the collection plate next time it comes by.
cowboy4evr
Member
I have 4 , 41magnums . 3 Smiths and One Ruger . I would take that deal in a heart beat as I don't have an " S " model yet . I and my sister are both real 41 fans . It's about all she will shoot anymore .
Similar threads
- Locked
