We were eventually able to identify the woman who snagged the Sneaky Pete from the grocery cart, although it took about 24 hours. The next afternoon another deputy and I drove to the address we had and, sure enough, the vehicle that fit the description of the one she got into on the video was sitting in the driveway.
We went to the front door and rang the bell. A man came to the door, we identified ourselves (although we were in uniform) and asked to speak to "Mrs. Doe."
"What do you want with my wife?" he asked.
"We have a question we'd like to ask her" I replied
Before he could say anything else, the door opened a bit wider and Mrs. Doe stood beside her husband and said, "can I help you?"
"Mrs. Doe, I'm Deputy Faulkner with the sheriff's office, and we've come to get the gun that you picked up at the grocery store yesterday."
The blood drained out of her face. She stood there looking right at me for 15 or 20 seconds, then she said "Okay", and she turned and went back into the house.
Her husband took a step towards us on the front porch and said, "what the heck is all this? Ya'll need to get the _____ off my property! Ya'll don't have no warrant to be here!" We just stood there looking back at him.
Mrs. Doe returned in less than a minute and handed the Sneaky Pete over to me and said, "I was going to turn it in to you guys tomorrow."
"Why didn't you just take it back into the store and hand it over to them?" I asked.
She replied, "It was raining."
"Mrs. Doe, according to the store video that's not true."
Mr. Doe jumped in, "are you calling my wife a liar?"
Mrs. Doe put her hand on her husband and pushed him back and asked, "am I in trouble?"
"No ma'am, not for this, but you will be hearing from the detectives about the shoplifting at the checkout, we have that on video too. Thank you for returning the gun to us, have a good day."
She started crying and turned and went back into the house, the husband slammed the door as we walked back to the patrol car.
After we got back to the sheriff's office we called the owner of the Sneaky Pete and told him that he could come pick up his gun . . . just ask for the sheriff. He showed up within the hour and the sheriff visited with him before handing the Sneaky Pete and gun back to him.