In your opinion, which is the best speed loader for a J frame?
That is a good point. The HKS does not work well with the factory rubber boot grips.
I would have to do some rubber grip trimming on bother of my J-frames, so I just don't use speed loaders with them.
It's a trick. There is no 'speed' with 'speed loaders.'
Anything you would need a speed loader for, you would be better off running.