Square vs Oval flat latch...

[zellerSC]

On an older M36 2" barrel.

Is one more desired/valued than the other?

Also, which one is the older latch?

Thanks.

 

[toddimusnimski]

My SCSW 3rd edition defines the flat latch as "Thumb latch configuration used on I and J frames and Airweight K frames from about 1950 to 1966." It gives photos of 4 different latch styles, newest to oldest:
1. Current - appears to have a piece cut off from the 3 to 6 o'clock position, probably designed for easier use when pushing it forward from that location. Large screw towards forward end.
2. Traditional - More of a square appearance I believe you're referencing. Large screw towards forward end.
3. Flared flat latch - flat and rectangular shaped. Small screw in middle.
4. Early flat latch - slightly humped and rectangular shaped. Small screw in middle.

What makes one more valuable/desirable to me over another is whether or not it is original to the gun. I love the unique appearance of the flat latch but it would sure look out of place on a newer gun.

Hope that helps!

Todd

 

[fyimo]

I have a pre Model 36 made in 1952 and it's a flat latch and I love the looks but for function I like the current design.

 

[Hondo44]

There are 3 varieties of flat latch. The earliest is the one I believe your describing and it's shown above. It wasn't the 1st thumbpiece used on the Chief's Special when 1st introduced in 1950. Here's the 1st style that they went back to in 1966 after using all 3 styles of flat latch:

Here's the 3rd style FL (3rd type used on Chief's Specials):

The 2nd style FL is very similar to the 3rd style but with a larger flat on front end. It has less peak in the front.

 

[zellerSC]

Thanks Fellas.

Mine looks like the last gun in your pics Jim. Has the little peak right at the front. Works for me and I assume it's original, so all's good!

Good info.

 

[Hondo44]

Thanks Fellas.

Mine looks like the last gun in your pics Jim. Has the little peak right at the front. Works for me and I assume it's original, so all's good!

Good info.

As far as value, it depends more on the vintage of the gun, earliest models being mostdesirable. The top gun in my post is the most valuable with the blade front sight and no barrel rib especially with the very early pre war style service grips instead of the Magna grips.