Filed in my memory of arcane trivia is the fact that Elmer Keith was horrible with spelling and grammar. However his writings shared so much knowledge not in general circulation that his editors worked overtime to get his stuff into print.
On the other hand, the guy I consider to be THE guru, Jeff Cooper, was a master of the English language and his vocabulary was immense. If there wasn't a word for something, he would coin it himself, and it often stuck, witness hoplophobe.
As for pure enjoyment, I don't think anyone will ever match Skeeter Skelton. His characters, such as "Dobe Grant," were priceless.
Technically, Dean Grennell was superb for reloading knowledge, as was George Nonte.
And of course, Bill Jordan and Charlie Askins Jr. had seen the elephant, been there and done that. I'd sit at their feet to learn anytime.
I loved reading them all, and very few can come close to matching these icons of gun writing.
John
Back in the early 1960's, I wrote to Field & Stream' s Warren Page about a statement that Jeff Cooper had made about Colt or Remngton .44 revolvers being better weapons than Springfield .58 rifles.
Page, having no idea that he was writing back to a kid, said, "Who is Jeff Cooper? We had a gink who used to write camera stuff for us. He is now doing an interesting job of copying both information and misinformation about a variety of topics and selling articles elsewhere." He went on to point out the many thousands of casualties caused by those .58 Springfields and .577 Enfields.
I assume that before long, he realized that Jeff Cooper wasn't anything like the gink that he knew. In fact, Cooper was probably more famous than Page. Few today comment on Page.
Both were real wordsmiths, though. I think Warren had been a schoolmaster at a private prep school and had a master's degree in English. Cooper was also a very talented writer. I saved a few of his letters.
Jack O'Connor was also a former college professor, who created the Journalism program at the Univ. of AZ. He is the sole gun writer who received nice obituaries in major newspapers.
John H. Wootters, Jr. was also a splendid writer, and he was a very talented photographer. He wrote a book on outdoor photography. And of course, books like, "Hunting Trophy Deer."
It's true that Elmer had serious language difficulties. I think his ongoing quarrel with O'Connor was in part due to Elmer feeling socially inferior to O'Connor. Both had a lot of field experience, but Jack cared relatively little for handguns, and Elmer was much the more knowledgeable man there.
Elmer Keith was probably unique in having so much original knowledge and so many fans that he got away with editorial shortcomings that wouldn't have been tolerated from anyone else. He was also the only guy who I ever saw pour Scotch in his tea at breakfast. Said he picked up the habit from his white hunter on safari. I like tea and I like some Scotches, but I never cared for that idea. I guess it warmed Elmer's old body and lifted his spirits. Try it, if you like and tell us how you like it. BTW, he really could shoot like he said he could. I saw him fire a .44 Magnum off of a bench at 200 yards when he was, I think, 78. He complained about his fading vision, but you wouldn't have wanted to be his target, even at that range!
I think Brian Pearce is the closest that we now have to Elmer Keith, with the added advantage of being a good writer.