The Hollywood flip - put to the test.

sigp220.45

US Veteran
Joined
Dec 19, 2005
Messages
8,616
Reaction score
36,353
Location
Colorado
I'm not a flipper, but I've always suspected flipping a revolver shut is not a big deal.

You know what I mean - a private dick or hero or bad guy takes out his gat, checks if its loaded, flips it shut with a flick of the wrist, then heads out into the murky shadows.

It is nails-on-the-chalkboard to gun people. If someone does it they are excommunicated from the club forever.

When the gun is flipped closed, the spring loaded center pin hits the on-ramp of the recoil shield and slows everything down. Then the whole shebang hits the frame, where there is nowhere for it to go so it can't overextend. No biggie.

XpIQeAP.jpg


So lets give it a try.

This is the victim. If it suffers permanent damage, I'm not out much. Its my TV watching gun anyway, so it can still continue in that capacity. If this 90 year old fella can survive, anything can.

dNYAstZ.jpg


Here's the before picture. I left the cat hairs in place for proof it was the before picture.

n9sjz3u.jpg


I loaded it up with some 158 grain ammo.

gl9Snx5.jpg


Then I commenced flipping. I had planned on doing 50 flips, stopping every ten to check for damage. I wound up doing a hundred, with the last ten being as hard as my old wrists could flip.

nfYm9Tb.jpg


No change. Still works great, locks up tight as ever. Back to TV duty.

Flipping it open might be a different thing, since the crane doesn't have a cozy frame to slam into. But, I watch a lot of film noir, and the open flip isn't nearly as common as the close flip. I'll try a few of those another time.
 
Register to hide this ad
Loving this already, keep testing it. I'd also love to hear ideas for how this should be tested for damage, like which dimensions should be changing, and how it should be measured.

Just be careful, in the other thread we had a frightening number of people saying someone accidentally doing it deserved a beating or pistol whipping, who knows what the punishment for doing it intentionally is!
 
I am almost banned for life for saying clip instead of magazine and thats not even Hollywooding a revolver
There are degrees of felonious forum behavior...Now load up some bullets in that revolver clip, and flip that cylinder to the tune of Gunnery Sergeant Hartman's stirring rendition of "This Is My Rifle & This Is My Gun" while the jury determines your punishment...:eek:...Ben
 
Well, school’s out for the summer, maybe you can hire some high school football player for a long-term endurance flip study, under your supervision (might want to replace the live rounds with inert ones). I predict the gun will still win :)

Just from a physics perspective, given the forces a gun has to handle when fired, the idea that the measly energy generated by the indirect centrifugal force of flipping one’s wrist could do damage is pretty far-fetched.

My only issue with the flip has always been that it’s silly. Basically the film-noir director’s equivalent of the hero racking his pistol slide right next to his face before going in, beloved of action-film directors.
 
What was the purpose of the test? To see if it would harm the revolver?

So, either it did, or it didn't. Now we know. Why did we want to know?
 
Pictures 3 and 5 clearly show a crack under and to the right of the ejector rod. Please stop before you crack the other side where the side plate is. Probably too late. :eek:

Not sure what you’re looking at, but there are no cracks (before or after).
 
Back
Top