The "I scratched my gun thread"......

rdcl

Member
Joined
May 14, 2010
Messages
511
Reaction score
741
Location
Westlake Ohio
A bit of backstory first.

I've always wanted a pristine ( or nearly so) 29-2.

Some years back ( around 2010) I found a very nice used model 29-2, blue, 8 3/8" barrel......at my local shop. No box, paper or tools.....just the gun itself. Price: $600.00. The gun had no bluing loss but it did have a few minor scratches on it.

I bought the gun instantly despite the few scratches figuring it would be my "shooter" with the idea that I'd keep looking for a more pristine example later. So, a few years later at a local show I DO find a more pristine example of the same exact gun. When I say pristine by comparison I do mean that. Except for a faint turn line.....the gun was flawless. Came with box, tools & paperwork. I bought it, and yes.....it cost me nearly double what I paid for the less than pristine example. I hate to use the word "mint" as that is a word applied to loosely these days.....anyway...

You know where this is going.......don't you?:o


I decided that I have no safe queens. So a few days back I decided to take my pristine example out to put some .44 special down range. After 50 rounds I decide to switch over to my Ruger Mk3 and shoot some .22. I lay the beautiful 29 down on the table upon a soft clean silicone cloth. After I did that.....some loaded 1911 .45 acp mags needed to be moved to another part of the table. Wouldn't you know it. I mean seriously. Why would fate, karma, just plain bad luck.....or even the devil himself do this to me. My own damn carelessness I suppose.

I fumbled with the handful of 1911 mags and dropped one of them directly on top of my pristine S&W model 29-2. There is now a nice big scratch right in the middle of the left side barrel.
I'm still sick over it even after a few days. I'm quite angry at myself.

I chose not to post a pic of the finish damage because it means digging out the gun and looking at it again.

Surely others have accidently scratched a beautiful finish on their guns as well.


Please post your story so as to make me feel like I'm not the only one.

Russ
 
Register to hide this ad
That's an "ah #&%$" moment for sure. Quite a few years ago, I spent $1500 on my first .45 semi. I loved everything about it. Fit my hand like it was made for it, shot to point of aim and was just nice to look at. I field stripped it for cleaning and during reassembly, put an idiot scratch on the slide. I was heart sick and really angry at myself for being so careless. It taught me to pay attention to what I was doing and take more care when handling my guns. I still have it. It still fits my hand, shoots well and is nice to look at in spite of the scratch. When I see it, I still get angry at myself.
 
My story isn't as sad as yours because it involves a gun that was already re-finished. But I spent good money getting this 681 PC refinished in Robar's NP3. Even posted a thread about it:
http://smith-wessonforum.com/s-w-revolvers-1980-present/400782-refinished-681-pc.html
It looked nice until I recently noticed a pretty good scratch in the finish on the cylinder. I don't even know for sure how it happened, but it obviously rubbed up against something sharp/hard in my safe. Grrr :mad:
 
Yep. I like to do it right out of the gate to avoid regret later. There it happened and I can now move on with my life and to more serious things like blasting ammo through it!!!
 
I used to beat myself up over making a dummy move and marking-up or marring one of my collector pieces...I truly felt unworthy of ownership at times...but then I realized, hey, what the heck, it's "personalized" now...just remember how special the day was (or the times were) when it happened and think of them each time you notice the marks in the future :)
 
Many years ago, I had a Ruger #3, in .45-70. I was crazy to trade it off, but being young and dumb, I did. I've always wanted another Ruger single shot, but didn't want another .45-70, so last year I bought a Ruger #1a in .270 Win. A beautiful rifle, flawless except for one little ding on the buttstock. The first time I took it out to shoot, I was only testing the open sights, with factory ammo, at about 50 yards. I was resting it on top of my opened car door, not directly, but on top of my hand which was on the top of the door. I didn't know it, but each time the rifle fired, it came back down on the door itself. Not very hard, mind you, I didn't even notice it. Six times, though. The dents are tiny, but huge in my eyes! I showed my new rifle to my neighbor who's a gun guy and a hunter, and he didn't even notice them, but I sure do!

This isn't going to make you feel any better about your revolver, but please understand, YOU ARE NOT ALONE!

On the plus side, I can now take it hunting, which is what I bought it for in the first place, without too much worry!
 
Last edited:
I'm still trying to figure out how all the new pickups around here seem to have banged-up tailgates within minutes of leaving the dealer's lot. Maybe they come pre-battered...
 
Plenty of idiot scratches and dings not just on guns but on other, even more expensive stuff. Like MP1983 said the gun is now personalized and there is no sense to continue beating yourself up over it....It will happen again.
 
1976, Visiting Army buddy after we recently got out. He bought a 4" Python. I bought a 6" M-27. We set the revolvers on the hood of our car and they both slid off when we sat on the bumper.
 
If a little scratch happens to my guns, from carelessness, I fret about it. If it gets scratched from use, I take pride in it. Most of my work guns show considerable blue wear and scratched stocks from decades of hard use. I like showing those guns off.
 
Several years ago I bought a stainless steel Springfield Armory Loaded 1911. It is a really pretty gun. I took it to the range for its break in; got it home an of course I put the idiot scratch in frame and dust cover. I was angry but it is my gun and I still enjoy shoot it and holding it. If I had wanted a pristine gun I would have left in the box and in the safe.
 
Yea,, cars and guns equals scratches. Mine was backwards. Brand new browning .22 semi, ran the first tube full resting elbows on hood of my Chevy nova. Nice set of divots in the hood..da bottom ejector.
 
I recently refinished a stock, removed all the scratches and dents stained it and hand rubbed six coats of Tru-oil it came out beautiful. Right after I was done I fumbled it while I was putting back together and it smacked into the edge of a steel bench block. That put a big dent that broke the wood grain right in the side of the stock, needless to say I was not happy. I put it back in the safe and haven't looked at it since
 
Back
Top