Tumbling Primed Brass

  • Thread starter Thread starter AJ
  • Start date Start date

AJ

US Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2003
Messages
11,833
Reaction score
28,105
Location
East of Stick Marsh, Fla.
In a deal I ended up with about 1500 9MM reloads. They were not marked as to what powder or load was in them. Since I am not a trusting soul, I broke them down and threw the powder in the garden. Was thinking of reloading the primed cases, but they are filthy. Has anyone ever tumbled primed cases? Run into any problems? If so will load them as is....... However, I do like bright shiny cases.

TIA
AJ
 
Register to hide this ad
I don't know if tumbling exposed primers might break down any priming compound or not. However, assuming that was not a problem, there's a very good chance of media particles getting stuck in the exposed flashhole on top of the primer. You'd have to check every single case, then remove a media particle now and then using a tool with a fine point.

There will likely be someone respond to your post that's allegedly performed this same chore many times without incident, but I wouldn't do it. I'd wipe the cases clean with a soft cloth occasionally moistened with alcohol or something similar that would dry quickly and leave no residue.

Unsightly brass that's clean works just as well as shiny brass.
 
I might have tumbled the loaded ammo since you weren't going to shoot them. If you have lot of time on your hands, you could press bullets back in the cases and tumble them and pull them again. :)
 
Reload the dirty cases, then tumble loaded ammo for 30 minutes to 1 hour, load and fire in normal manner. I've tumbled loaded ammo for 35 years without a single problem.

EDIT: I just finished tumbling 200 rounds of .308 Win after loading on my Dillon. Case lube is gone, jacketed bullets are gleaming, and the brass is almost surgically clean. Another successful tumble in the vibratory drum.
 
Last edited:
I accidentally tumbled some primed 45 Colt once. Loaded and fired with no problem.
 
I have deprimed live primers many times. The technique is to do it in a single stage press and use a slow downward press on the press' handle with NO impact, jarring or quick motions. Primers don't go off on compression pressure, just sharp impact. I have never had even one go off. Even if it did the small explosion is totally contained. No harm, no foul. Don't reuse these primers as the de-priming will compress the anvil to the point there will many failures to ignite. Put them in a jar and cover them with WD-40 for several days and then dispose of them. I never did that while they were still in the brass because whatever one uses to kill them still has to be removed from the interior of the brass.

You might think about tumbling the cases with the live primers still in and then de-priming as described. I can assure you that dry tumbling cases with live primers WILL put tumbling media into the primer hole. It might go off but the standard deviation will go sky high making for very inaccurate ammo. Wet tumbling will kill some of the primers, but not all of them as one would expect.
 
Tumbling primed brass?

No! Nope! Niet! Not me.

Edit. The brass does not need to be shiny. As long as it is clean.
Before I had a tumbler I washed my brass. They weren't pretty and shiny, but they were clean, and they worked without a glitch.

By the way. I never take others reloads. Not even for free.
 
Last edited:
I have soaked primed cases in WD 40 for a week then allowed them to evaporate. 4 out of 6 fired hard, 2 fizzled. I would use heavy gear oil.
 
Why do people obsess over "Killing" primers? Or even tumbling them for that matter?

Go shoot them and enjoy....Any obstruction in the flash hole will be aggressively dislodged upon firing.....

Randy
 
Why go to the trouble and maybe have some duds.......... (more pulling)

It is only 9mm brass that can wait one firing to get nice and clean, again.

Put your time into loading them up for shooting.

I was given about 600 primed .45ACP cases that were pretty tarnished looking. I just loaded them all up, fired them, and then did my regular cleaning regimen of decapping and wet tumbling.
 
I have deprimed live primers many times. The technique is to do it in a single stage press and use a slow downward press on the press' handle with NO impact, jarring or quick motions. Primers don't go off on compression pressure, just sharp impact. I have never had even one go off. Even if it did the small explosion is totally contained. No harm, no foul. Don't reuse these primers as the de-priming will compress the anvil to the point there will many failures to ignite. Put them in a jar and cover them with WD-40 for several days and then dispose of them. I never did that while they were still in the brass because whatever one uses to kill them still has to be removed from the interior of the brass.

You might think about tumbling the cases with the live primers still in and then de-priming as described. I can assure you that dry tumbling cases with live primers WILL put tumbling media into the primer hole. It might go off but the standard deviation will go sky high making for very inaccurate ammo. Wet tumbling will kill some of the primers, but not all of them as one would expect.

I am a cheapo and was planning on reusing the primers, cases and slugs, just was going to put in powder of my own. I trust my reloads and some of my friends reloads, but when I get a bunch of reloads from someone I do not know then those get torn down.
 
I don't know if tumbling exposed primers might break down any priming compound or not. However, assuming that was not a problem, there's a very good chance of media particles getting stuck in the exposed flashhole on top of the primer. You'd have to check every single case, then remove a media particle now and then using a tool with a fine point.

There will likely be someone respond to your post that's allegedly performed this same chore many times without incident, but I wouldn't do it. I'd wipe the cases clean with a soft cloth occasionally moistened with alcohol or something similar that would dry quickly and leave no residue.

Unsightly brass that's clean works just as well as shiny brass.

I have 1000's of times. any miniscule(sp) particle in the primer hole will be blown out by the primer. I do with rifle and handgun brass. Never a problem and won't be. Primer/ignition=a micro second of 1200+ degrees. Nothing can stand that. I also tumble primed cases and load them. Again never a problem and won't be.
 
Plugged flashholes are not a problem. Primers are powerful enough to push a bullet (no powder) into the barrel. A grain of corn cob will not be noticed. I've never tumbled primed cases but I don't see a problem. If in doubt, call Hodgdon's.
I definitely would not tumble loaded rounds. The size of the powder flaks controls burning rate. Break up the powder into smaller pieces could be a real problem.
 
Back
Top