Well, thanks for all this approbation. Let me tell you about the super deal I got on the Highway Patrolman and see if you feel the same way.
Lola had told me there were only long guns. When I first looked at them, they were all wrapped up in old bed sheets. I started getting them three or four at the time, taking them to my home, cleaning them up and advertising them.
About a week after I first saw the guns, and after I had called in my friend to help sort them, I got a call. It was Bill, my friend. He was at Lola's house getting a bunch of scattered loose ammo he had bought. "We found another bunch of guns," he told me. "There are three handguns wrapped in another old sheet. A 1911A1, some kind of S&W 9mm semi-auto, and a big S&W .357 revolver." I thought he was joking with me. I had mentioned wanting a Model 28 earlier. He started reading off the barrel, "Says 'Highway Patrolman' on the barrel." I really thought he was fooling with me then.
Anyhow, turned out it was a 28-2, P&R. When I got there, I saw that it had flecks of surface rust on the sideplate and barrel, and a little more serious rust on the butt around the serial #. I checked the cylinder, noticing that it didn't want to open. I thumb-cocked the action, and it was almost bound up. I cycled it double-action twice and stopped, fearing that I was going to do damage. The thing is, I don't believe the gun had been fired since it left the factory, but it had never seen a drop of oil, either. I knew, or at least believed, that a thorough detail cleaning would fix just about anything that was wrong with it.
I told Lola that I really wanted the gun for my colletion. I told her that in the condition it was in, a pawn shop or dealer would give her maybe $150. (I can hear him now: "Lady, this old gun is so rusted up I can't even pull the trigger. I'll give you $100.") She immediately said for me to take it for that. I said, "No ma'm, I will give you $250 for it, because I can work on it some and make it a $400-$450 gun, or take it to a gunsmith and pay him $150 to do the same thing."
So I got a pretty nice HP out of the deal for $250. She would have taken $100. I made it clear to her that I was paying wholesale, and that the gun cleaned up and slicked up a little would bring more. She realized that I was spending at least an hour or more on practically each of the guns, just getting them presentable.
I took it apart and got it functioning pretty good, but I am either going to have to do more myself, or take it to a 'smith. The cylinder still doesn't open to my satisfaction, and I don't know exactly what I need to do to that front side plate screw to remedy. this.
Interestingly, I believe the satin finish came through the 25-30 years of neglect a whole lot better than a bright blue finish would have. The rust didn't leave pits the way rust on the bright finished guns seems to. There were even flecks of rust inside the side plate, and the action was bone dry. Usually, I expect to find the action on neglected guns gummed up, but this one had never seen a drop of oil.
Bill bought the 1911A1, which was pitted worse than the 28. I sold the Sigma for her for $250, which I thought was pretty good, considering the deals S&W has been running on new ones.