Walther P99 vs SW 990L ?

SW990L--P99/PPQ Sta-Tite Recoil Spring Assembly

Just purchased an SW990L and I would like to replace, (nicks and marks on nylon bushing means use, though function is good, and it's best to start with new "unstressed" springs), the recoil spring assembly. Can't find OEM replacements in stock anywhere but I am interested in the Sta-Tite assembly from the BT Guide Rods | website. It is a ss rod that uses the mfg.'s bushing and spring. More expensive than oem but the appearence and reputation seem to imply quality. Given your qual's...What are your thoughts?


The original SW99's had the Walther AS trigger (the sear housing block controls the 'action'), so they were traditional double action pistols and equipped with the Walther decocker button.

The SW99NJ was an interesting variation which S&W reportedly didn't really want to make the way the agency wanted it made, and there's seemingly more to the story which isn't really relevant to this thread. FWIW, the second SW99/P99 armorer class I attended had a manual which listed the SW99NJ. I'm keeping that manual as a potential collector's piece.
icon_wink.gif


Anyway, the SW990L, or the "Lightning" version as it was being called by some folks at S&W when I first heard about it, features the Walther QA trigger. There's an interesting difference in the SW990L pistol compared to the Walther P99 QA, though, and that is that the 990L doesn't incorporate the reduced profile decocker button in the slide that Walther uses in their QA models. Instead, S&W decided to use the 'smooth' DAO slide (think of when the early SW99 manuals first listed the SW990, which would've been similar in operation to the original Walther P990, which was really DAO, and therefore didn't have, or need, a decocker).

That meant that in order to release the striker of the partially cocked 990L the user has to pull the trigger on an empty chamber, in the same manner as on the Sigma (and the Glock). On the Walther P99 QA the user depresses the reduced profile decocker in order to release the partially cocked striker.

The Walther P99 AS and the P99 QA models use different striker springs, too, with the QA model having a slightly heavier striker spring.

The trigger bar guide, a small steel part located on the bottom front of the sear housing block, can be different, as well.
 
SW99 GUIDE RODS

"Just purchased an SW990L and I would like to replace, (nicks and marks on nylon bushing means use, though function is good, and it's best to start with new "unstressed" springs), the recoil spring assembly. Can't find OEM replacements in stock anywhere but I am interested in the Sta-Tite assembly from the BT Guide Rods | website. It is a ss rod that uses the mfg.'s bushing and spring. More expensive than oem but the appearence and reputation seem to imply quality. Given your qual's...What are your thoughts?"

KCREEK, I am new to this forum and have had my SW99-.40 for about 3 years now, and absolutely LOVE IT, and with much searching I found that MidwayUSA carries S&W 99 parts, Their Recoil Guiderod P/N is 168115 for the SW9940, If yours is not a .40 cal then ask the guys is customer service to look up the part number for whatever cal you pistol is. They are much faster than looking through page after page of Parts. I know that is has been a while since you wrote this, I hope this helps you. I have no info on the sta-tite assy. from BT Guide Rods. Sorry :)
 
Just saw this thread. Dunno why it didn't notify me when you posted back in Aug ...

Anyway, I order all my SW99/P99 parts directly from S&W, meaning from either the S&W parts dept or the Walther America parts dept.
 
I have an SW99 in 45 ACP---I like it quite a lot---maybe I'll pick up a PPQ in 9mm---heard good stuff about the PPQs from people I respect.
 
Back
Top