wats the .444 marlin

jdf1966

US Veteran
Joined
Mar 9, 2012
Messages
55
Reaction score
12
Location
minneapolis
Ran across this ad and dont know what the diff. is from the 45-70 to .444 mar. other than obvious.
Anyone know what performance is . like comparable?
Is it a popular cal. ?too much for whitetail?
thx; jd
 
Register to hide this ad
The 444 never caught fire.

It was a predecester to the current popularity of 45-70 lever guns such as the guide guns in 45-70.

Performance could be comparable to 45-70, but commercial loads are quite limited and don't do justice to what's possible with the cartridge. The biggest issue was the use of 240 gr 44 mag type projectiles. They were too fragile to do well when penetration and smashing large bones in, eg, grizzly or brown bear situations.

The 444 would work very well on whitetail out to about 125 yards It is considerably more than necessary, but the deer will drop very convincingly.

Ammo availability may be a problem: unlikely to be available at the LGS in small towns. It may be hard to come by even in metropolitan centers.

Overall, an interesting cartridge if you hand load and want, for reasons I can't imagine, to avoid the 45-70.

I wouldn't spend MY money on a 444 Marlin rifle.
 
Last edited:
You have valid points all the way around, but there is a pretty good sized cult following to the .444 Marlin, a lot of people simply like it without giving a lot of reasons why, I had one myself and loved it - but I inherited mine, but if was putting out actual money I would get a .45-70.

Range is slightly further with the .444 due to the slightly smaller bullet, but other than that not much difference other than more expensive and harder to find ammo.

But....the cult following will never go away and it's still a great caliber.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rpg
I believe there is ammo in the 265 grain area also. Barns bullets brought out a 300 grain JSP at least a decade before anyone else. I have a Contender and find it to be all I want for hand gunning (I own 4 45-70 rifles). Ammo and brass can be spotty at times, which is why you should reload and/or keep a personal stock of ammo on hand! 444 Marlin and 375 Win are round I try to keep 100 to 200 rounds in stock (I get up to 200 and start ordering when I'm near 100).

Full length 22" and Guide Guns 18.5" by Marlin are the only rifles commercially made for the round. There are also some barrel makers that make pistol and rifle barrels for Contenders and Encores.

Ivan
 
I have 2 ea. marlin 444P's(18" ported bbl.). All I shoot in mine is my cast 310 GC flat point bullet pushed by 40 grs. of H4198. This load will shoot through a whitetail or hog from ANY angle. Lots of critters have fallen to mine. Ammo is available if you look......Georgia Arms/Remington etc.....I also have a Marlin 45/70 LTD III......Like the .444's better....
Some cronograph data from my rifles...
250 gr cast GC x 46 grs H4198=2096 fps
310 gr cast GC x 40 grs H4198=1904 fps
250 gr cast x 56 grs H335=1997 fps
Rem 240 gr JHP x 36 grs #2400=1795 fps
250 gr cast GC x 58 grs H335=2134 fps
Rem 240 gr JHP x 53 grs IMR3031=1982 fps
Rem factory 240 gr sp=2268 fps

All data shot over Oehler 35P

Disclaimer.....All above data safe in MY rifles.....If you load always consult a loading manual first.

Sadly......The 444's are no longer made by Marlin(Remington) and those out there usually fetch big $$$.
 
Last edited:
It might have been a bit of overkill, but I used a 444 Marlin with a 300gr Hornady XTP bullet at over 2,000 f.p.s. to kill a couple of Missouri whitetails many years ago.

I loved the gun (an older Marlin lever gun), it shot great and knocked the ever loving **** out of everything I pointed it at. Every deer I ever shot with it (always inside 100 yards) dropped right where they stood as if hit by lightning.

I was young and dumb and foolishly let that gun go in a trade. Even though I don't hunt deer much anymore, I'd sure like to have that one back.

TRE
 
Remlin is trying their damnest to get rid of the 444 after selling them steadily since 1964.
The only problem is there are a LOT of the guns out there including Europe where it may be even more popular than here.
They mostly shoot boars and moose with it for which it is perfect.
Winchester also made the 94AE "BigBore" in 444 and those are commanding big bux now too.
They are supposed to be stronger even than the Marlins.

As a 44 fan I have always considered the 444 to be the ultimate 44.
It will do anything the 45-70 can do if you are willing to handload.
Heavy cast bullets overcome any shortcomings revolver bullets may have.
The Marlinowners 444 subforum is home to much of the wisdom associated with this cartridge.
Beartooth Bullets main man is a fanatic and has written what may be one of the best series of articles on the 444 and its performance
444 Marlin- America's Most Versatile Big-Bore Part I
444 Marlin- America's Most Versatile Big-Bore Part II
444 Marlin- America's Most Versatile Big-Bore Part III

I like the 444 so much I acquired one of the only double rifles chambered in 444 in this country.

Try it. You'll like it!
 

Attachments

  • 265FTX46H4198-2.785in.jpg
    265FTX46H4198-2.785in.jpg
    72 KB · Views: 53
  • Rizzini444-1.jpg
    Rizzini444-1.jpg
    241 KB · Views: 66
  • WilliamFP-2.jpg
    WilliamFP-2.jpg
    251.3 KB · Views: 56
Last edited:
Swift manufactures .429 A-Frame slugs at 240, 280, & 300 grains. These are guaranteed up to 3,000 fps. Their manual includes data for the 444.
 
Last edited:
Remlin is trying their damnest to get rid of the 444 after selling them steadily since 1964.
The only problem is there are a LOT of the guns out there including Europe where it may be even more popular than here.
They mostly shoot boars and moose with it for which it is perfect.
Winchester also made the 94AE "BigBore" in 444 and those are commanding big bux now too.
They are supposed to be stronger even than the Marlins.

As a 44 fan I have always considered the 444 to be the ultimate 44.
It will do anything the 45-70 can do if you are willing to handload.
Heavy cast bullets overcome any shortcomings revolver bullets may have.
The Marlinowners 444 subforum is home to much of the wisdom associated with this cartridge.
Beartooth Bullets main man is a fanatic and has written what may be one of the best series of articles on the 444 and its performance
444 Marlin- America's Most Versatile Big-Bore Part I
444 Marlin- America's Most Versatile Big-Bore Part II
444 Marlin- America's Most Versatile Big-Bore Part III

I like the 444 so much I acquired one of the only double rifles chambered in 444 in this country.

Try it. You'll like it!

That's...BS...on the Winchester...They were and are a ***!!!!! I had one. The stock cracked.......The forend slid forward like a pump gun and it started snapping.......Sent it back and they sent another rifle.....Second one the forend/barrel bands & magazine tube shot loose...... Ifixed and promptly sold that ***.......Purchased first Marlin 444P in 1999.......Have shot the H!!!! out it..........ALL ITS EVER NEEDED IS........ammo and an oily rag for clean up.
 
You'll find that just as with loyalist of the .41 Magnum or .44 Special, the fans of the triple 4 are just as passionate about the cartridge.

I happened onto an almost new 1980 manufacturered Marlin 444S sitting in the used rifle rack at my LGS with a $299 price tag. Seeing an older Marlin in great shape with a price tag like that.... being a Marlin lever gun fan, it made me stop in my tracks.

I wasn't looking for one, had never thought about one... but I left with it.

As for factory ammo availability, Bass Pro Shops carries the Remington 240gr SP, and the Hornady LEVERevolution 265gr FTX bullet. I've found that the loaded Hornady ammo is fairly common and in my area there are 3 local gun stores that carry it.

You can find both the 265 gr. FTX Hornady LEVERevolution and the Hornady 265gr SP SuperFormance (should be called SuperThumper) ammo online.

Finding loaded ammo hasn't been a problem, and prices have been within the same range as 45-70 round boxes.

So... as with my .41 Magnum and .44 Special revolvers.. when asked "Why?" I say "Why not"?

Effective medicine without the extra punishment of a 45-70... plus, I like to see my friends eyes widen when I say it's the only thing effective on those big free range "Texas Jackalopes". :D
 

Attachments

  • The Works .jpg
    The Works .jpg
    63.8 KB · Views: 49
  • How Much.jpg
    How Much.jpg
    63.7 KB · Views: 52
  • 444Marlin.jpg
    444Marlin.jpg
    173.5 KB · Views: 46
Last edited:
I have an Uncle who owns a .444 Marlin and he bought it when they first started making them and he's killed more than a few whitetails with it. It's a great round but unless you're going to handload, get the .45-70.
 
The Marlin .444 appeared on the scene when .45-70 was relegated to history books, and not well-read books either. It was a super .44 Magnum, which was getting a lot of ink at the time due to a certain movie star. While Marlin barrels for .44 Magnum had microgroove rifling with a 38" twist (< 300 grain stability), the .444 had standard rifling and a 20" twist (good for 350 grain or more), and respectable ballistics.

For whatever reason, .45-70 enjoyed a resurgence in interest when lever guns appeared for this classic caliber, me among them. It performs well with cowboy loads (really light) to bear thumpers. Components are relatively easy to find, and they are easy to reload (no shoulder). I reload 405 grain bullets to about 1800 fps. Ten rounds makes a good afternoon's shooting.

The penetration of hard-cast .45-70 is legendary. It has been shown to penetrate 29 gallon jugs of water, put a 4" hole in a piece of 2" ballistic polycarbonate, or make an heavy duty Master padlock literally disappear (half a shackle left hanging).

On the other hand, a .44 Magnum carbine will take a deer or hog with dispatch. .444 Marlin? I think I'm good.
 
It's a good round, just not sure it offers enough over a 45-70 to justify the higher brass cost. With good 300gr+ bullets, it is an effective game taker out to about 200yds for me, same for the 45-70.
 
Ran across this ad and dont know what the diff. is from the 45-70 to .444 mar. other than obvious.
Anyone know what performance is . like comparable?
Is it a popular cal. ?too much for whitetail?
thx; jd

The .444 has a higher pressure plus a lighter bullet which equals in a higher velocity (fps) and higher energy (ft.-lbs.) and therefore flatter trajectory and a longer range than the .45-70.

Unless you have a hand/custom loaded .45-70 round (i.e. Buffalo Bore .45-70 Magnum - Lever Gun) the .444 will outperform the .45-70 any day of the week.
 
I am a fan. I bought an older Marlin 444 (1970) a couple of years back on a whim and fell in love with it. I've owned Marlins for years, but somehow never bought a 444 until then. I was wanting a gun for whitetail that would keep me from having to trail what I shot. Being that I've hunted for years with the old reliable 30-30 and .35, and many times would watch the deer run, sometimes walk on like nothing happened. Don't get me wrong, they always dropped dead, just not right away every time. Now with the 444 Marlin, they are knocked over in their tracks. The first deer I shot with my 444 Marlin, not only was slammed to the ground, it was facing the other direction! I was sold! I've shot 4 deer with that rifle now, and not a one took even one step.

Now being a Marlin fan, I've also owned a couple of 45/70's over the years. But they did not perform like that on whitetails. I've used handloads and factory loads too. I do not still own a 45/70, but I do own two 444 Marlins. That's my story and I'm sticking to it. Like I said, I'm a fan.
 
That's...BS...on the Winchester...They were and are a ***!!!!! I had one. The stock cracked.......The forend slid forward like a pump gun and it started snapping.......Sent it back and they sent another rifle.....Second one the forend/barrel bands & magazine tube shot loose...... I fixed and promptly sold that ***.......Purchased first Marlin 444P in 1999.......Have shot the H!!!! out it..........ALL ITS EVER NEEDED IS........ammo and an oily rag for clean up.
Sorry about your 94 BigBores.
I have never owned one and now may never!
I was repeating what I have read about the designed allowable chamber pressure: ~50 kpsi as opposed to ~45 kpsi.
That does not seem like a lot but I have in the 444 binder I have assembled over the years some loads specifically for the 94BB.

My 444s was made in 1981, has no safety, and shoots very well as you can see from the target I posted.
The Marlins also come apart and go back together way easier than the Winchesters.
The screw sets are still available and I suggest anyone wanting to work on their Marlins get one or 2 while they can.
I have also put the Happy Trigger in it and am well.... happy with it.
trigger-happy-kit/
They are expensive but well engineered, and easy to install if you are comfortable taking down and rebuilding lever guns.
The trigger pull was reduced and more importantly the creep was all but eliminated.
This without replacing or lightening any springs which I am leery of.
I also think nickel plate (could be chrome) looks better than the cheesy gold wash on the stock trigger.
Also available in blue.

I agree Mike.
The 444 Marlin is (pun intended) bulletproof.
I do clean it from the rear.
Simply take out the lever screw and then the lever.
The bolt comes right out and you can then insert the cleaning rod from the breech.

There are custom jacketed bullets like the Hawk which are less expensive than the $1 apiece (or more) Swift and Woodleigh.
Hawk Bullets master list but these are swaged cup and core and may not be bonded as well as factory bullets.
The Hornady 265 JFN (not the FTX) was the first and remains the most used jacketed bullet designed for the 444.
It works.
But as I have said, the WFNGC is much more versatile and much less expensive.
And don't believe the oft repeated "wisdom" from gun writers who have obviously never owned or shot the 444
that the 1/38 twist will not stabilize 300 grain or heavier bullets.
Read those articles by Marshall Stanton I posted and join the Marlinowners forum.
Real people have shot real bullets with accuracy up to 355 grains.
It's the length that determines stability not the weight.
In fact heaviness adds to stability.
The WFN is about as short as you can get for a given weight.
I see no need for anything heavier unless pursuing large dangerous game like brown bears..
John Taylor thought 400 grain 41 caliber bullets were ideal for elephants (450/400 NE).

Those of you lucky enough to own the later 1/20 twist Marlins or single shots don't have to worry about any of this.
If Marlin had simply chosen to rifle the 444 with as little as a 1/30" twist in the beginning, this decades long debate would never have started.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top