What's Your All Time Favorite Ice Cream Flavor?

[johnnyflake]

It's really hard for me to pass up a high quality "Neapolitan", the 3 way combo just works, but is has to be high quality. The average in store brands are just okay at best!

Tied for 2nd are a quality Spumoni or Rocky Road!

 

[Donn]

There's a place called Ray's in Royal Oak, Mich that makes a flavor called Coffee Heath. Coffee ice cream with big chunks of Heath toffee. Little bit of Heaven.

 

[e3mrk]

It was Butter Pecan until I developed a Nut allergy so now it's Mint Chocolate Chip.

 

[pawngal]

Cherry Garcia or Pecan Praline.

Or anything with salted caramel

 

[whitestang]

Butter Pecan please.

 

[chaparrito]

I probably eat ice cream 3 or 4 times a year, maybe. They're all good. Can't pick a winner. I used to love Breyer's Vanilla back when they just used eggs, cream and vanilla. Now they've gone the cheap route and are using the same thickeners that all the other makers, including the much adored Blue Bell use. In Mexico there is a brand that is sold in stores as well as ice cream parlors called La Michoacana. You can get it here now too. There is a popular flavor that you have to experience to understand. It's called "Queso y Mora" and is vanilla ice cream with blueberries and little bits of mild white cheese swirled into it.
I love Talenti Salted Caramel Gelato. Any butter pecan will do, Breyer's is still very good.
As a kid I loved Baskin and Robbin's Jamoca Almond Fudge. Coffee, almonds and fudge. Prolly had something to do with those cuties in the pink striped outfits too!

Forgot to mention La Michoacana paletas. Paletas are ice cream bars. They have a coconut one that is real shaved fresh coconut, sugar, vanilla and cream frozen on a stick. Killer. Totally killer.

 

[Salty RI]

Garlic and liver!

I bet your their only customer.

 

[Arik]

I bet your their only customer.

I actually did try garlic ice cream once and it was good. Hard to explain but it wasn't like eating raw garlic or anything

 

[chaparrito]

Just remembered.There's a gelato place in the town nearest here that makes a maple gelato that they top with warm crumbled bacon. OM*G is it good.

 

[Erich]

I don't know that I could pin it down to only one, but I sure do miss Baskin Robbins' Mandarin Chocolate sherbet . . .

 

[ladder13]

Gads those where my Fathers favorites!

It must be health food he ate it every night and lived till 94!

I like Coffee and Pistachio nuts but not in my Ice Cream,

Well, I'm 85, see how good they are for you?

 

[walkin jack]

Blue Bell (only) Chocolate Chip. Big ol' chunks of chocolate that you actually have to chew.

 

[jimmyj]

tutty fruity

 

[wnwitzell]

Pistachio Pistacio by Ben And Jerry!

 

[Marshwheeling]

Zanzibar, a super dark chocolate. But when I am traveling west, I do like to take MN60 down to IA60 to La Mars for an ice cream stop at the Blue Bell factory. Never know what I might decide to try.

 

[Targets Guy]

Dutch chocolate

 

[pawngal]

Zanzibar, a super dark chocolate. But when I am traveling west, I do like to take MN60 down to IA60 to La Mars for an ice cream stop at the Blue Bell factory. Never know what I might decide to try.

That would be Blue Bunny in LeMars

 

[loknload]

I listed my favorite flavor but this is my favorite brand !

And this stuff is good!

 

[long boom]

Chocolate Malted Crunch

 

[Bill_inBouse]

WOW...37 posts before anyone said ROCKY ROAD....my all time fav-0-rite!