Which Is More "Desirable" M28 or M27?

You can not make a mistake owning either but the truth is the Model 27 is a lot better looking and the difference is would you rather date Rosanne Bar or Sharon Stone.

Wouldn't disagree.
 
PURIST---Do not read this reply, it can lead to stomach disorders and extreme anxiety.
First lets discuss your thoughts and what YOU want. If you want a shooter and a project then the 28 is the choice.
If you are into collecting and keepin the weapon as is and think the idea of original is your cup up tea, then the 27 is for you.
I am not a tradionalist. I don't think beauty is the same for everyone---we all married different women----some several, looking for the perfect.
I like to make things my own---I don't really care what others think along the lines of beautiful.
Guns are tools and like all tools, they are what they are too you.
I like projects and I like making guns MINE---this makes me happy.
Blessings
 
As a kid, I admired my fathers' model 28 with 6" barrel. I always believed it to be my birthright and would someday posess it for myself. Unfortunately, he foolishly traded it in on a 30-30 instead of having the timing fixed on it(was spitting lead out the sides).
A few yrs ago, I decided I was going to obtain an N-frame 357magnum and this dilemna was mine now. After alot of reading up on the choices, I went with the 27 with 5" barrel.
375574_3038949752162_176455484_n.jpg

Mine is not in perfect condition as the bluing has some imperfections, so I shoot mine.
 
A few yrs ago, I decided I was going to obtain an N-frame 357magnum and this dilemna was mine now. After alot of reading up on the choices, I went with the 27 with 5" barrel.
375574_3038949752162_176455484_n.jpg

Mine is not in perfect condition as the bluing has some imperfections, so I shoot mine.[/QUOTE]

I shoot all my 27's, and the 28's, 29's, 57, 25 all the Kframes (even the K-32) and even my I frame 22/32 one in a while. Guns are for shootin'
 
I shoot all my 27's, and the 28's, 29's, 57, 25 all the Kframes (even the K-32) and even my I frame 22/32 one in a while. Guns are for shootin'

My statement that I shoot it is referring to the trend in this thread that model 27's are too pretty to shoot and that one should get a 28 if you plan to. Mine is not mint condition, and if it was and I paid top-dollar for it(not that I have any guns like that) I understand those who don't shoot them and want to keep them in unfired condition. If you payed beau coup bucks for an unfired classic revolver and wish to take it out to the range..good for you.
 
Buy the Model 28, then a Model 27 they are both strong, serviceable revolvers. The Model 28 is a "workhorse" while the Model 27 is a "pretty revolver."

Its your choice.

Scott
 
Get what you can get. Don't wait for never came.

I really appreciate the contour of the barrel vs a straight pipe, and am now interested in shorter barrels as well. Not so common are they?
 
If both were in front of you and you could only buy one, I would go for the 27.

Both are equally durable but 27s are just classy.

Since only a 28 stands before you, buy it.

model28s.jpg


If a 27 comes along and you want it, you could always sell the 28 if you had to. Personally I try to sell as little as possible.

model27s.jpg


pre-27s.jpg


27-set.jpg


27-bers.jpg


27%20classic%204n.jpg
 
Back
Top