Which Revolver? Personal Prot. Issue

[Darkenfast]

Ask yourself what you are used to carrying and most proficient with. If you carry an auto, perhaps a full-size version of what you already CCW, loaded with the hot ammunition optimized for deeper penetration might be just the thing. If you use a compact revolver already, then I think that a four-to-six inch barreled 7-shot L-frame in stainless steel would probably be the most versatile handgun you could ask for. I think it would give you the best chance of planting seven rounds quickly and accurately. Other people might be best off with a 1911-type platform because they've learned it so well. Anyway, all the power in the world won't help you if you can't draw and make the hits smoothly and quickly under stress, as I'm sure you've already figured out!

 

[crazyphil]

Idaho recognizes all other states concealed carry permits. But you are
also right about obtaining Idaho's permit. No problem.

As to the revolver: Black bears will generally try to avoid you unless you happen to get
between a sow and her cubs. The lion has been known to stalk humans but generally
they will want to get away from you also. Wolves in a pack could present an interesting
situation.

I tend to agree with Kanewpadle: A pump or auto 12 gauge with OO buckshot, backed up with a .357 mid-size revolver
K or L Frame. I have killed large black bear with a .38 Sp. round nose lead, but given a choice I would prefer the .357
with hard cast bullet like a Buffalo Bore Keith.

 

[Fast-Eddie]

While I have great confidence in my 686+, If I were buying another revolver for what you described I would get a 629 and potent back up gun.6 rounds goes fast.

 

[Donn]

A .44 Mag revolver as backup to a rifle.

^^^ Good advice ^^^ If I were in your boots, I'd have a rifle too. My 45-70 would easily handle anything that might threaten. I think I'd opt for my Ruger Redhawk 41mag as back-up. Plenty of horsepower, better second shot recovery. MHO you understand.

 

[Kid44]

I recently purchased some property in the back country up near McCall ID. Been up to the property several times this winter. Have witnessed wolves taking down an elk yearling and seen numerous cat and bear tracks. Also this property is off the road and I have concerns about the 2 legged or editors. I am thinking I will do open carry of a.357 mag or .44 mag. I have a CA CCW and was told it will be no problem getting an Idaho permit. I am not looking for a mini pistol but one that is medium framed and accurate. Maybe a 4inch or more barrel. Would like adjustable sights. Any advice would be appreciated.

Don't fear the 2 legged editors, they are harmless, they only carry pens.

 

[Rpg]

I'd be happy carrying my usual 1911 with 200 gr hard cast swc at 1,000 fps.

Remember: you aren't hunting. If you need it, you have to be able to shoot fast and accurately at rapidly closing close range.

If I felt I needed more, I'd go with a good 12 ga pump or auto loaded with slugs: Buckshot is highly overrated for bear.

 

[keith44spl]

Jest a good ol 44 will do....



.

 

[Watchdog]

Also this property is off the road and I have concerns about the 2 legged or editors.

Editors? You're concerned about editors? Why?

I don't understand.

 

[keith44spl]

Editors? You're concerned about editors? Why?

I don't understand.

Mabee he was goin for predators, but outdoor rag editors
may be of concern in that area, local kinda ordeal.



.

 

[Maddog 521]

I usually carry my Ruger Super Blackhawk in .44 and close by is my Marlin 336 in 35 Remington. I feel that is the best of both worlds.

 

[Scott in NCal]

The real question to be answered here is how did you get a CA CCW permit ? Does it become null and void when you move?

 

[shotgun693]

Before you buy a .44 Mag you really ought to shoot one and see if you can put up with the recoil and blast.
In reality for dangerous animals you ought to carry a .22 revolver and always have a friend with you. If you are approached by a dangerous beast, shoot your friend in the leg and move away as discreetly as you can.

 

[Darkenfast]

Editors can be extremely vicious, especially if they're cornered.

 

[kraynky]

I'm not necessarily a Glock fan, in fact I don't even own one now. But if it were me, I'd probably be all over a 10mm Glock, mostly for capacity. Any of S&W's 10mm would do too. (I do have a 1076) I would not want to have to worry about remembering to cock the durn thing like someone else said. Point and shoot. I have a 44 special and a .41 mag in single action, but I would not pick either as a bedside gun if a double action or semi-auto were available. Same thing for woods walking where there's lions, wolves and bears! That's my opinion, because you did ask.

 

[Andrew2105]

I'd lean towards something that you could deploy quickly & shoot fast. (sacrilege I know). Somehow I feel that you might find yourself with multiple adversaries & no time to waste. I'm not a fan of pistol caliber long guns. If it's a long gun it needs to shoot a rifle cartridge. I'm thinking a DA/SA .45 ACP pistol backed up with several pre loaded magazines. For the long gun I'd like a 7.62X 39 piece, Ruger mini .30, SKS or an AK, also with back up magazines. I agree with an earlier poster that a chest holster probably would be best as it's weight will be on your shoulders & not your waist.

 

[Laddy Smith]

Maybe

I think you've got some great suggestions so far.

Perhaps the best idea is to narrow it down then fire a couple boxes through your top 5 at the rental range.

One I didn't see would be a S&W .357 TRR8. Lightweight, nice handling, 8 rounds, 5 in barrel.

I do think it's wise to have a fast handling rifle--if you carry it or lock it in the truck while walking the property. I do like the Ruger Mini 30 for this.

Whatever you decide....pictures

Lad

 

[josywales]

Chest holster, yes
Don't rule out the 45 Colt
I would think double action might be better, lest you be caught off guard and have to fire quickly.
Sacrilege I know, but Ruger makes a nice double action, 45 colt. Stuff some Buffalo Bore ammo in that and rock on.

 

[sunnyd]

glock 20, 10 mm. My woods carry. Easy to carry, 16 + 1, quick follow-ups, tremendous firepower, moderate recoil.

 

[amazingflapjack]

as suggested-a 357 lever gun with red dot-a 16 inch barrel, along with a 357 revolver.

 

[Highhawk1948]

Don't forget a good sheath knife.