Which To Keep?

X

xfarfuldog

Member
Joined
Mar 9, 2007
Messages
781
Reaction score
688
Location
SW Ohio
I recently purchased several revolvers from a collector. Now I am afraid I may be in a little over my head. I admit breaking one of my cardinal rules by going into debt to purchase some of these. I do not have to sell any of them. But it will be tight for awhile if I don't.

My present collection of revolvers includes 2 Pythons, a 27-2,
19-4 snubby, 19-4 4", 65 3", 13 3", a 66 no dash snubby, a 686 no dash, and a 686-3. I also have about a half dozen or so autos I might sell.

Please do not view this as a solicitation. I am just looking for some input. I am a member of OGCA and there are several monthly gun shows including tomorrow. Some are a no brainer such as the 66 and my Python I ave had for 30+ years. Which to sell and which to keep?
 
Last edited:
Register to hide this ad
For sure keep the Pythons and 686's. Ditch the semi autos... Take a breather, check your finances before considering selling any more.
 
Definitely keep the 3" 65 & 13. These are hard to come by and IMHO the perfect carry revolver.
First choice to sell would be the 686s as those will be fairly easy to replace later. But with the 3" guns, the 19s and 66 are a bit redundant.
Honestly, I'd keep all the revolvers and dump some semi-autos. Good wheelguns are getting harder to find, but semis are a dime a dozen. ;)
 
The 27 is the 3 1/2 barrel. All the guns are in excellent condition. I could easily replace the 2 Glocks, the Shield and the VP9. But the Beretta cougar 45, the P228 and the Colt pony not so much
 
I would never sell a Python the prices are only going higher. Plus it's one of the best 357 magnums ever produced.. sell what you can easily replace down the road. Keep the pythons, m27-2, the two 19's, 686. Is sell one glock, beretta, that should get you back in the black.
 
Last edited:
xfarfuldog said:
The 27 is the 3 1/2 barrel. All the guns are in excellent condition. I could easily replace the 2 Glocks, the Shield and the VP9. But the Beretta cougar 45, the P228 and the Colt pony not so much
Click to expand...

I would keep the 27 3 1/2 for sure. 686 and the semi's you mentioned would be the first to go. But, only if necessary...
 
I am not an L-frame fan so those would go if I owned them

Probably most of the semi autos would go as well.

I would certainly keep the Pythons, snub 27 and snub 66.

The 13 and 65 are up in the air. Probably would sell the 65 and keep the 13....I like Blue

The 19 Snubby would be a keeper and the 4" 19 would depend on how much money I needed and how close I was to that goal.
 
I'd have to keep that 228 out of all the semis mentioned. If it's too tight to manage through, i'd sell anything still being made first, then the 686 first of the wheelers. If you need fast cash, just about anything 3" will sell fast and at top dollar, but will be harder to replace. You know what you like the best. Firearms can be a somewhat risky investment. We never know for sure who will be running the show years down the road. They may not always be so easy to liquidate.
 
Tighten the belt as has been said. The 4 semi's you mention are not going to bring that much. You could probably sell the 686's for double what the auto loaders would bring and not lose money (or as much). And the 686's would probably be easier to replace. JMO
 
X, if I had to, I'd start with he 686's, as they will be the easy ones to replace, when your bucks up again.

I hope you can find away to avoid selling any of them. Start bring lunch to work, quite drinking beer:eek:, and assorted. All of these are good ways to save a few bucks.
 
Personally, I think the Pythons are over rated and right now you can get so much money for them that you might not have to sell anything else. If you think they'll make you more money tomorrow that's up to you but there is a point of diminishing returns and I think Pythons are there for awhile.

Keep the M27 and M19s. This is, after all, the S&W Forum - and those are very special guns.

If you still need to raise more funds dump your polymer pistols and keep your 3rd Generation S&Ws.

After that, well, if money is the issue you will get more for the snub nosed revolvers in today's concealed carry market.
 
OK, I am planning to retire in a little over 3 years. I know I shouldn't have used credit, but felt this was a once in a lifetime opportunity. I bought 7 revolvers from this collector. I can pay them off in about 3 1/2 months.

I am deciding whether to keep my house or sell. This will make a difference in my finances. Already painted inside and replaced the carpet. Just not sure I want to go into an apartment.

I do not plan on shooting the blue revolvers. Originally I did but they are just too nice. I thought I could move from being a shooter to a collector. Maybe not.
 
Last edited:
I'm not a Colt or semi-auto guy so the answer is easy for me, but my answer may not fit your situation.

I've been buying and selling S&W revolvers for 45 years, and I consider myself a pragmatist. "Things" can cause emotional reactions, but for the most part they're still just "things." The pleasure you get from each one is often hard to measure, but each of those you listed might range from "just a tool" to "my favorite of the bunch." I often read folks on this forum making statements to this effect: "I sold a Model XX years ago, and I wish I had it back." I can think of one I'd buy again (a blue Model 27 5"), but I'm not looking for one. I cannot know which ones hold meaning to you so I believe you need to answer that question for yourself.

Reading between the lines in your post, I interpret your rationale for selling any of your handguns would be to let you pay off the dept you've incurred from buying them on credit. If I'm correct I like your thinking.

Make your decision, then look out the windshield, not the rear view mirror.

Best of luck with your decision.

ps: you posted your last post (#19) while I was typing. Knowing this update I wouldn't sell any of them. I'd pay off the debt in that four months, and then I wouldn't go into debt for any more.
 
Last edited:
xfarfuldog said:
The 27 is the 3 1/2 barrel. All the guns are in excellent condition. I could easily replace the 2 Glocks, the Shield and the VP9. But the Beretta cougar 45, the P228 and the Colt pony not so much
Click to expand...

Sell the Glocks and the VP9. See if that will take you through.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Grimjaws
I think I see a trend in my collection
Replies
7
Views
586
duke2002
D
J
Which 357 revolver is next?
2 3
Replies
44
Views
3K
jeffrefrig
J
JW5400
Which one should I sell/keep?
2
Replies
20
Views
736
thinklikeido
T
JW5400
Which one should I sell/keep?
2
Replies
21
Views
754
44wheelman
4
Fvernic
This may or may not have already been done
2
Replies
33
Views
881
Baxter6551
Baxter6551

Latest posts

Back
Top