Why the lack of new blued Revolvers?

B

bftx

Member
Joined
Mar 10, 2016
Messages
43
Reaction score
7
Why does S&W produce so few blued Revolvers? Thank goodness for the Classic line. Are they just too labor intensive? You see quite a few blued shotguns, and 1911's from other brands.

These blued Classic Revolvers are also fairly hard to find. I wish they would realize not everyone wants a stainless Revolver. Blued firearms are the way to go, alittle extra maintenance never hurt anything. Not too mention they are classy.

I know I know, find an older model, but I want to be the first owner. I want a pristine gun that has only been shot at the factory. Its my gun to make memories with.
 
Register to hide this ad
Well it's been said that once the nickel finish is gone. The blued finish is next to be discontinued. In the near future were only going to have the stainless finish guns. Unless we see more and more epoxy painted guns.
Maybe still parkerized finishes too.

Now is the time to get the blue and nickel finishes before there gone.

Blue is cool, stainless is better, but that world famous s&w nickel finish freaking rocks,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,YOU BETCHA.
 
Blued finishes are gone like the dodo bird. The American public is not willing to pay what a factory blued finish would now cost, just like they're not willing to pay what a cheeseburger produced by a $15 per hour employer would cost, and what an automobile produced by an American union employee cost . . .
 
The over/under shotgun market is about 99% blued finishes, and the 1911 market has a good percentage. I'm not losing hope.

Let me tell ya, I was into black/polymer guns but over the past few years I have started loving blued guns. As a 30 year old I would take a blued gun over any black/tactical gun out there.

I just picked up a brand new 870 Wingmaster American Classic with a nice wood and blued finish, now I just need a nice wood and blued S&W revolver. Remington and Colt still have very nice blued finishes. S&W does as well. I just wish they would produce more, and not let the bean counters run the show.
 
Last edited:
Three thoughts here. You will not find a shortage of admirers for blued S & W revolvers here, but I would think the complex curves and contours of a revolver make it much more labor- and skill-intensive to polish than a semi-auto or a shotgun, thereby raising the production cost. They have to make guns at a price point at which they will sell, not easy in today's market.

Second, S & W still makes some very nice blued finishes but they are not in the league of ones they made in the 1930s, '50s and early '60s. Look for a few examples from those eras and you'll see the difference compared to a more recent one.

Last (and you may have seen this coming), perhaps the best of all possible worlds is to find that '60s era blued S & W revolver, NIB at an estate sale, and start making your memories from there :). Hope this is helpful.
 
If they aren't willing to make it good......

murphydog said:
Second, S & W still makes some very nice blued finishes but they are not in the league of ones they made in the 1930s, '50s and early '60s. Look for a few examples from those eras and you'll see the difference compared to a more recent one.

.
Click to expand...

They have cut corners on blueing to save some $$ but it's getting where they may as well not make if they don't do a good job. It doesn't affect the functionality of the gun as much as crooked barrels and all of that stuff.

Blued Guns Forever!
 
Last edited:
Hasn't blued guns in general been in decline for several years? I went looking for a blued centerfire rifle back in the mid 90s up in Kodiak,and Juneau, Alaska and they were scarce. Gun store owners told me stainless was in due to less maintenance required. 98 % of what I own are old blue revolvers and rifles. I never liked shiny guns till I picked up a couple of Colt Single Action Armies with a nickel finish. Then came the S&W 29-10 4" barrel in nickel. All three had a superb nickel finish that just called to me.

As for stainless I have a 625 (45 ACP) Performance Center, two 640 Pro Series and a 66 no dash, and a Colt Government Model. Meh... I could take em or leave em I reckon.....Well maybe with the exception of the 66 and Gov't Model. I've used blued revolvers in the field for years and never had any rust issues no matter what the weather has thrown at me.

I purchased two Model 22 Model of 1917 reissues three years ago in blue and their finish is holding up well, even using Hoppes No. 9 (along with the 625PC and 29-10 the only "Lock" revolvers I own). But their finishes don't hold a candle to that of my old blue revolvers of yesteryear.

Nickel Smiths no more eh? I reckon I'll hold on to the Model 29-10. Wish S&W would use solid wood grips instead of the laminate stuff they use now.
 
Last edited:
lots of people, like me, get their first handgun from ruger.
ruger blue doesn't look at all like the bluing i've seen on old shotguns.
worse, i had holster wear in 2 weeks.
after that kinda experience, stainless seems like a better idea.
 
Stainless is much less labor intensive to make and finish but the gun makers have convinced the gun buying public to pay more for what actually costs them less to produce!
Bluing as mentioned takes time and skill and probably in this day and age is costlier to produce
 
Bluing was originally used to protect guns from rusting as at the time it was the cheapest-only- way possible to do that. Thee were no magic coatings like there are today. Case hardening was used to harden softer steels to provide for sears etc. Nickle came along to provide greater corrosion resistance than blued guns and then stainless came along which was ever better for corrosion protection. Then the finishes came along-melonite, Black T, Ceracoat and so on. It's called progress. It's why people ceracoat their old beat up 870's rather than re blue them. Ans so on. Blued guns are beautiful and a reminder of the craftsmanship of yore but face it, it is the most fragile of all gun finishes-plus it is more expensive to apply. I mean face it-does it make sense to produce a blued slide Shield? Look at your shotgun you take into the duck blind. Chances are it has some kind of coating on it rather than bluing. Remember how fast your old A-5 would start to rust if it got wet? Face it-blued guns are a PITA to maintain as compared to the newer coatings and stainless. I've got an old K-22 and an old Ruger single action both blued and these are positively babied because I'm so afraid that I'll miss that odd thumbprint and get a nasty surprise down the line.
But then again that's just one man's opinion.
 
Last edited:
I have mixed feelings on blued guns. While they are pretty to look at I am a shooter not a collector. I have to be careful to wipe my sweat off stainless guns so they don't rust blued guns don't stand a chance. For my money I will take stainless or some of the other coatings that I don't have to worry about as much.
 
Aesthetics versus functionality. Beauty versus corrosion resistance and ease of maintenance.

I love the fine old blue finishes and miss the last two I had, which now live with my son and his boys. But in old age I have to go for practicality and durability, knowing the guns I have left will have to last the rest of my life.
 
Many of the "blued" or "blacked" guns produced today are not blued. They have other types of finishes that are more durable. S&W does not use the same process as they did even in the 70's and 80's. I think that process may have run afoul of the EPA. The blue finishes I have on some of my newer guns, not necessarily S&W's, appears thin and fragile. None of those ever sees a holster.
 
All I'm going to add is if we look at GM because there not offering what the consumer wants the sales go down. A quality finish in all three offerings is important.
 
Too many dimwits want easy, no brainier like guns. They don't wanna be burdened with that pesky thing called FIREARM MAINTENANCE! I mean, that will cut down on reality TV & social media time:mad:

Really though it's likely a cost measure for the manufacturing side of it. One type of steel to deal with most of the time, no messy blue finishing etc. I'm sure the EPA has an opinion on the hot bluing chemicals & they're proper uses.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

W
Cleaning new blued revolvers
2
Replies
32
Views
1K
djohns6
D
B
The Model 10 - Why the bull barrel?
2 3 4
Replies
60
Views
3K
CAJUNLAWYER
CAJUNLAWYER
W
Owners of the new no-locks
2 3
Replies
57
Views
6K
SWFan27
S
H
A Couple New PC No Lock Limited Edition Revolvers
2
Replies
27
Views
3K
Beju
B
S
A foursome of four inch revolvers
Replies
3
Views
456
sprscientist
S

Latest posts

Back
Top